The ethnic Chinese's dilemma
The ethnic Chinese's dilemma
By Beni Sindhunata
This is the second of two articles on problematic issues
related to the ethnic Chinese in Indonesia.
JAKARTA (JP): Bank Indonesia's injection of Rp 140 trillion
(US$11.6 billion) to ailing commercial banks through the
Indonesian Bank Restructuring Agency (IBRA) has been touted as an
undesirable illustration of the unscrupulous practices of a
handful of ethnic Chinese in the country.
As of April this year, total capital of Indonesia's banks
amounted to only Rp 50 trillion, against total assets of Rp 759
trillion. About 63 percent of this amount constitutes claims to
companies and individuals affiliated to their conglomeration. The
question is whether such corrupt practices could have occurred
without collusion between a handful of Chinese-Indonesians and a
handful of so-called "native" officials.
The present government will score a tremendous success if it
succeeds in arresting and punishing the ethnic Chinese involved
in nepotistic, collusive and corrupt (KKN) practices.
In the trade sector, more than 12,000 companies are operating
as distributors and agents, cooperating with one another on a
mutual basis. When prices of daily needs soared due to reduced
supplies -- resulting from lower production activities, hoarding
by anxious consumers and closure of looted shops -- this sector
became an easy target to blame, especially because most of the
distribution networks were then in the hands of ethnic Chinese.
Unfortunately, only a few realize that the presence of the
ethnic Chinese in the trading sector has opened up employment
opportunities for 13 million workers, representing 17 percent of
national manpower. The burning in May of about 1,800 shops at the
Glodok electronic trading center in West Jakarta with estimated
total annual sales of around Rp 3 trillion, for example, has put
13,000 people out of work.
The government's announcement that it will establish an
alternative distribution system to replace the one left by some
ethnic Chinese is praiseworthy indeed. This plan has at least
shown the government's courage to take an open attitude (albeit
implicitly), a position better than the past practice of
discrimination behind a cover-up.
On the other hand, the government must find out why about 90
percent of the National Logistic Agency's (Bulog) partners
(mostly indigenous) have resold their delivery orders to ethnic
Chinese merchants, preferring to receive only fees. Clearly, if
the affirmative process of making the indigenous businesspeople
control the economic sector turns out to be a flop later on or
fails to reach the intended target, the government will also have
to bear all the consequences, including the necessity to find
suitable scapegoats.
Another classic dichotomy between the indigenous and the
nonindigenous is related to their historical origins. President
B.J. Habibie was quoted in an interview in the Asian Wall Street
Journal on Aug. 4 as saying: "... if we look at history, perhaps
some 2,000 years ago, we all had our origin in mainland China".
For comparison, historian H.J. de Graaf describes in his book
Moslem Chinese in Java in 15th and 16th Centuries (quoted by
Tiara Wacana Yogya in March 1998) that Raden Patah, the first
Demak king in Central Java, Sunan Ngampel or Raden Rahmat of
Surabaya in East Java and Raden Husen of Semarang in Central Java
were all of Chinese descent, with original names of Jin Bun, Bong
Swi Hoo and Kin San respectively.
Habibie, Indonesia's third president, was bold enough to
introduce a criterion regarding the indigenous and the
nonindigenous population without basing it on their ethnic,
religious or racial backgrounds, but rather on their dedication
and responsibility.
But many people forget and refuse to realize that in some
parts of this country, most ethnic Chinese share the same fate
as, or are even worse off than other Indonesians.
They are certainly part of the 79.4 million poor recorded by
the Central Bureau of Statistics (BPS). These ethnic Chinese must
be included in the 39.1 percent of Indonesia's poor people with
an average monthly income of less than Rp 41,000 (in rural areas)
and Rp 52,000 (in urban areas). The addition of 57 million more
poor people in the last 18 months does not discriminate between
the ethnic Chinese and indigenous Indonesians.
It is obvious at this juncture that ethnic Chinese involved in
KKN practices must be held responsible, including their direct or
indirect accessories. But the majority of the eight million
ethnic Chinese are simply victimized by evil deeds of a few of
their community. The worldly pleasure that goes with the wealth
accumulated by some ethnic Chinese involved in KKN practices was
certainly unimaginable to Hiu Po Thin, who killed himself and his
children in despair at his poverty.
The analysis above is expected to encourage all Indonesians to
better understand the existence of ethnic Chinese is just the
same as all other groups. All cannot be free from human beings'
basic and universal behavior. Cases cannot be generalized, but
must be considered separately in all objectivity. Generalization
is only true in the bestowal of rights and authority as citizens.
So what position should ethnic Chinese assume in the present
era of reform and as we approach the new millenium? Should they
simply sit idle, be passive and flee? Or should they act as
economic agents without getting involved in politics, knowing
they will be victimized in every conflict? The answer is clearly
in the negative.
Ethnic Chinese and other ethnic groups in Indonesia must start
reforming themselves in various aspects of life to enjoy a
harmonious state, just like the proverbial combination of ebony
and ivory in the beautiful ballad by Stevie Wonder and Paul
McCartney.
Implicitly, it is impossible to generalize about all the eight
million ethnic Chinese because they inevitably differ from one
another in terms of education, profession, religion and social
background. It is advisable therefore that ethnic Chinese should
channel their political aspirations and orientation through over
60 political parties, and in this way exercise their right as
citizens to help reach national goals.
The writer is chief research officer at the Center for
Indonesia Business Data (PDBI).
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-ethnic-chineses-dilemma-1447893297-1403222)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post