Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

The Ethics of Criticism and the Responsibility of Power

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Politics
The Ethics of Criticism and the Responsibility of Power
Image: Republika

The statement by House of Representatives Speaker Puan Maharani some time ago (21/4/2026) on the importance of maintaining ethics in delivering public criticism has reopened a long-standing debate: should criticism of the government be limited by certain ethical standards, or should ethics first and foremost bind those in power?

This controversy strengthened after the police reports by Saiful Muzani and Feri Amsari regarding their criticism of the Prabowo Subianto administration. Although reporting to the police is a citizen’s right, calls for “ethical criticism” cannot be understood unilaterally but must be placed within the framework of reciprocal state life. In this context, it is appropriate to refer back to MPR Decree No. VI/MPR/2001 on the Ethics of State Life.

Reciprocal Relations

The MPR Decree, made in the spirit of reform, explicitly positions ethics as the foundation of national life sourced from religious, cultural, and Pancasila values. Ethics is not merely an individual norm of politeness but a collective moral framework that regulates relations between the state and citizens.

In Chapter II on Political and Governmental Ethics in the Decree, it is emphasised that power must be exercised openly, responsively to public aspirations, and respectfully towards differing opinions. This means criticism is not a deviation from ethics but rather an inherent part of healthy democratic practice. However, on the other hand, ethics also demands that criticism be delivered honestly, non-manipulatively, and not based on lies. Thus, the ethics of criticism is not a tool to limit freedom of expression but a moral quality standard in expressing opinions.

In a constitutional democracy, public criticism is a manifestation of popular sovereignty. Criticism is not merely a right but a mechanism for controlling power. Therefore, making criticism the object of legal reporting risks creating a chilling effect that contradicts the spirit of openness mandated in state ethics.

This is where it is important to reread MPR Decree No. VI/MPR/2001 in full. The Decree not only regulates citizen ethics but also emphasises the moral responsibility of political elites to act honestly, with integrity, without arrogance, and to be ready to accept criticism and even step down if they violate justice values.

The MPR Decree affirms that political ethics not only demands citizens to behave politely but also requires power to be open, honest, and to respect differing opinions. Ethics must not be positioned as a tool to discipline society alone but must serve as a mirror for power itself. In other words, criticism is not a violation of ethics but part of the ethics ecosystem itself.

More from 14 May 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-ethics-of-criticism-and-the-responsibility-of-power-1778781527)
Originally published by Republika (https://rejogja.republika.co.id/berita/tf0va3282/etika-kritik-dan-tanggung-jawab-kekuasaan), translated from Indonesian
Print