Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

The Election Bill and the Path of Democracy

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Politics
The Election Bill and the Path of Democracy
Image: detikcom

The discourse surrounding the turbulent development of the Election Law revision serves as a reminder to the public that the legal design of elections is never neutral from the tug-of-war of power interests. The fear that the regime may shape election rules to maintain its dominance is indeed a valid concern.

However, amidst the deadlock in the discussion of the Election Bill (RUU Pemilu), which has yet to find a resolution, another equally serious threat has emerged: the temptation to take a democratic shortcut through the issuance of a Government Regulation in Lieu of Law (Perppu).

In this context, the question is no longer merely whether the election will be controlled by the regime, but whether democracy is still being conducted through democratic procedures.

Perppu is often used as a shortcut. Yet, in a democratic context, shortcuts are precisely what risk being misleading. In the revision of the Election Bill, based on various sources gathered by the author, there are at least three major clusters that must be included in the bill’s material, such as the debate over presidential and parliamentary thresholds, the strengthening of the electoral system, and the possibility of separating central and regional election schemes.

These three clusters arose following the Constitutional Court’s decision which granted the main petition, making it vital that the revision of the Election Law be carried out before the 2029 democratic festivities are held.

Unending Debates

Simply put, in the formal process of legislative drafting, debates in determining policy direction are common and normal. However, in the context of drafting the Election Bill, these debates are no longer merely a space for healthy dialectics, but tend to transform into maneuvers of interest laden with the sectoral egos of political parties. Every party competes to propose a regulatory design that most benefits its electoral position.

In reality, as representatives of the people in a democratic system, legislators essentially bear the responsibility to ensure the representation of all elements of society and to direct the formation of laws towards the primary goal of democracy: political justice, meaningful participation, and equality in contestation.

When this orientation shifts towards an arena of interest compromise, the substance of democracy risks constitutional retrogression.

As it stands, the existence of the Election Bill seems to be in a ‘Pandora’s box’ that has yet to reach a resolution. This condition ultimately sparks public questioning regarding the sincerity of legislators in exercising their mandate—whether it is truly aimed at strengthening the quality of democracy or is instead trapped in the shadow of merely maintaining power.

A Temporary Solution

Several legal experts have attempted to provide ideas for a way out, questioning whether, if the Bill in question cannot be passed by the legislative institution, the final tactic of issuing a Perppu becomes the most ideal option for organising the democratic festivities.

Nevertheless, in the theory of Legislation, the term Perppu is not unfamiliar; it is a regulation established by the President in cases of compelling urgency. The existence of Perppu, as stipulated in Article 22 paragraph (1) of the 1945 Constitution and Law No. 12/2011 in conjunction with Law No. 13/2022, places Perppu on the same level as an Act (Undang-Undang).

Looking at the development of election law following various Constitutional Court decisions, the need to make adjustments to the Election Law could actually have been mapped long in advance. Various decisions that changed the design and rules of the upcoming 2029 elections should have served as an alarm for the DPR and the government to immediately draft and discuss a comprehensive revision of the Election Law. However, to this day, the discussion of the Bill has been slow and has not shown a clear direction for resolution.

This condition is important to note because it has the potential to create a paradoxical situation. On one hand, the delay in discussing the Election Bill can create time pressure approaching the election stages. On the other hand, time pressure that could have been anticipated from the start has the potential to be used as a justification for issuing a Perppu based on ‘compelling urgency.’

In fact, the parameters of compelling urgency, as intended in constitutional practice, should not be used to cover up the sluggishness or failure of a legislative process that was predictable beforehand.

Therefore, before the discourse on Perppu resurfaces, the question that needs to be asked is whether such an urgent situation truly arises from an unavoidable constitutional necessity, or is instead a consequence of the attitude of law-makers who are unresponsive to changes in election law following the Constitutional Court’s decision.

If a Perppu is issued to patch up a deadlock that has been intentionally allowed to linger, then what is at stake is not only the quality of election regulations but also the legitimacy of the democratic process itself.

Furthermore, the use of Perppu has the potential to narrow the space for meaningful public participation in determining the direction of election system reform, even though election regulation, as a primary instrument of democracy, demands an inclusive, transparent, and participatory formation process.

In the author’s view, the legislative institution still has a window of at least until the end of 2026 if it truly intends to complete this domestic task. Therefore, the urgency of issuing a Perppu is not the right step; rather, the drive to complete the Election Law is the ideal solution to be realised.

On the other hand, the role of the Constitutional Court is also vital to ensure that the revision of the Election Law aligns with all previously issued decisions. This constitutional oversight is not in the form of direct intervention, but rather as a mechanism to guard the consistency of norms so that no misinterpretation of the established constitution occurs.

More from 23 September 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-election-bill-and-the-path-of-democracy-1790136051)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/kolom/d-8675127/ruu-pemilu-dan-jalan-demokrasi), translated from Indonesian
Print