Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

The Economy Is Growing Steadily: Time to Strengthen Its Foundations

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Economy
The Economy Is Growing Steadily: Time to Strengthen Its Foundations
Image: CNBC Indonesia

In 1966, in his inaugural lecture at the University of Cambridge, economist Nicholas Kaldor put forward an idea that later became known as Kaldor’s law: manufacturing is the engine of economic growth.

The faster manufacturing grows, the faster the economy as a whole moves, because this is where economies of scale are strongest, productivity rises fastest and links with other sectors are broadest.

Kaldor also showed that manufacturing productivity tends to increase as output expands, because larger scale makes the cost per unit lower. Many empirical studies have since tested this idea and, with various qualifications, generally support manufacturing’s distinctive role. The idea arose from the experience of advanced industrial economies, but it is increasingly relevant to developing countries building their industrial base, including Indonesia.

That relevance is clear because Indonesia’s industrial journey over the past two decades has not been smooth. Manufacturing’s share of GDP has fallen compared with the early 2000s, a trend many economists call premature deindustrialisation: when a country’s manufacturing sector starts to shrink before it reaches a high-income level. That is why any signs of a manufacturing revival deserve close attention, and the third-quarter data offer several such indications.

Kaldor’s framework provides an interesting way to read the latest data. The question is not only how fast the economy is growing, but whether the right engine of growth is running.

This matters because two economies with the same growth rate can have very different foundations: one may be supported by productive investment, while the other relies on consumption or temporary stimulus. The quality of growth determines how long it can be sustained.

Based on a number of early indicators, the economy is expected to have grown by around 5.3% year on year in the third quarter, in line with the 5.29% recorded in the second quarter. Available data are broadly consistent with that estimate. Amid volatile global trade and continuing geopolitical risks, steady growth at around this level is worth recognising.

The engine appears to be warming up. Bank Indonesia’s Prompt Manufacturing Index rose to 52.28 in the third quarter from 51.43 in the second quarter; a reading above 50 indicates expansion in manufacturing activity. The increase was driven by production volumes, order volumes and finished-goods inventories, all of which were in expansion territory.

Most subsectors were also expanding, led by non-metallic minerals, food and beverages, and basic metals. Imports of raw materials and capital goods rose sharply, a sign that factories are increasing production capacity.

The global environment has also been supportive: most G20 countries recorded manufacturing expansion, and the global manufacturing Purchasing Managers’ Index (PMI) reached 53.0 in September, according to S&P Global. In Kaldor’s terms, this is the stage at which capital accumulation in manufacturing begins to take hold.

Domestic demand has also provided support. Household consumption, the largest component of GDP, appears to have held up: the Mandiri Spending Index from the Mandiri Institute rose by 6% in the third quarter, up from 4.3% a year earlier, with essential goods providing the main support.

GAIKINDO data show that retail sales of new cars grew by around 25%, while Statistics Indonesia (BPS) recorded an approximately 9% increase in domestic tourist trips in July and August. Passenger numbers on trains, ships and ferries also increased. All this took place with inflation under control: BPS data show inflation at 3.28% in September, within the government’s target and below that of several other ASEAN countries, including the Philippines and Vietnam.

A quieter transformation is also under way. Bank Indonesia says QRIS transactions grew by more than 75% during the quarter, while electronic-money spending in July and August reached about Rp226 trillion, up by more than 30% and now exceeding spending using ATM, debit and credit cards.

Every small trader who switches to digital payments becomes part of the formal economy. Over the long term, those transaction records can broaden access to financing for small businesses and give policymakers faster, richer data on the pulse of the economy.

The figure of around 5.3% also reflects something worth noting: strong domestic demand is being met in part through imports. BPS data show that imports grew more than three times as fast as exports in July and August, narrowing the trade surplus.

In GDP calculations, imports reduce the contribution of domestic demand. But because most of these imports consist of raw materials and capital goods, they are in fact investment in future growth. In other words, the 5.3% figure reflects a domestic engine that is running, while the external sector has yet to provide a boost. If exports follow, there will be more room for growth.

Kaldor’s framework also helps us see where the next opportunities lie. There are at least three, all grounded in one belief: an engine that is already running needs the right fuel.

First, bring domestic investors along for the ride. The Ministry of Investment and Downstreaming/BKPM recorded investment realisation growth of around 7.6%, with foreign investment up by more than 27%. This reflects global confidence in Indonesia’s prospects.

Almost a quarter of investment is now flowing into basic metals, a sign that downstreaming is beginning to take shape. Domestic investment is still lagging, but there is an encouraging signal: Bank Indonesia data show investment credit growing by more than 20%, usually seen as an indicator of business confidence in the future.

Domestic businesses appear to be preparing to expand. The policy task is to ensure that this readiness translates into new factories and machinery, through regulatory certainty, simpler licensing and lower logistics costs.

Second, broaden industrial linkages. Albert Hirschman emphasised the importance of intersectoral connections, or forward and backward linkages. He argued that development rarely proceeds evenly, and that the resulting imbalances can generate the next impetus for growth. Strong upstream industries create opportunities for suppliers and processors in related sectors.

The growing basic-metals industry is a good starting point. The next step is to ensure that downstreaming extends to more labour-intensive finished-goods industries, so that Kaldor’s growth engine also becomes an engine for job creation.

This is where the employment component of Bank Indonesia’s PMI merits attention. Its index remains slightly below 50, at 49.58, meaning factories are increasing production but have not yet added many workers. This is not a failure, but an early stage: if the expansion continues, employment is generally expected to follow, particularly if it is accompanied by skills training suited to industry needs.

Third, maintain momentum as temporary support fades. School holidays, transport discounts, industrial incentives and government priority programmes all helped drive the economy this quarter. With industrial foundations strengthening and inflation under control, there is now room for a gradual shift from temporary support towards demand that can grow on its own.

Consumer credit growth of only around 5% indicates that households remain cautious, making the restoration of consumer confidence the next task. This transition needs to be communicated clearly so that households and businesses can plan ahead with confidence.

Six decades after Kaldor delivered his lecture, his ideas appear alive in the third-quarter data: manufacturing is expanding, production capacity is increasing and investment is flowing into strategic sectors. Hirschman, whose views are often described as possibilism, reminds us that positive change often comes through routes we do not expect.

Both thinkers convey a similar message: good growth is growth that builds the capacity to grow again. From this perspective, remaining shortcomings, such as domestic investment not yet growing as quickly as foreign investment, are better seen as room for progress.

Our task is to keep the growth engine running, bring more domestic investors along and create more jobs. With these foundations, we have good reason to be optimistic.

More from 3 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-economy-is-growing-steadily-time-to-strengthen-its-foundations-1793710296)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20261103184234-14-782030/ekonomi-tumbuh-stabil-saatnya-memperkuat-fondasi), translated from Indonesian
Print