The Dialogue Between Rasulullah SAW and His Companions: A Strong Divider Between Truth and Falsehood After the Battle of Uhud
JAKARTA — The dialogue between Abu Sufyan and Rasulullah SAW and his Companions following the Battle of Uhud depicts one of the episodes in the struggle between truth and falsehood.
This explanation was given by the Secretary-General of the World Union of Muslim Scholars, Sheikh Ali Muhammad ash-Shallabi, quoted from his official website on Tuesday (15/9/2026).
The dialogue reveals the steadfastness and noble bearing of the Muslims amid an extremely difficult situation.
The event also carries a profound lesson about wisdom in confronting circumstances, the strength of creed (aqidah), and the influence of conscious and mature leadership.
Furthermore, the dialogue illustrates the psychological and moral dimensions of a confrontation.
All of this affirms that victory is determined not only by material strength, but also by faith, conviction and firmness of heart.
Al-Bara (may Allah be pleased with him) narrated: Abu Sufyan appeared and called out, ‘Is Muhammad among these people?’ The Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) said: ‘Do not answer him.’ He then asked, ‘Is the son of Abu Quhafah among them?’ He said: ‘Do not answer him.’
He then asked, ‘Is the son of al-Khattab among them?’ Abu Sufyan said: ‘These people have been killed; had they been alive, they would have answered.’ Umar (may Allah be pleased with him) could not contain himself and said: ‘You have lied, O enemy of Allah! Allah has preserved those who will humiliate you.’
Abu Sufyan then proclaimed: ‘May Hubal be exalted!’ The Prophet (peace be upon him) said: ‘Answer him.’ They asked: ‘What shall we say?’ He replied: ‘Say: Allah is Higher and More Exalted.’ Abu Sufyan said: ‘We have al-Uzza, and you have no al-Uzza.’ The Prophet (peace be upon him) said: ‘Answer him.’ They asked: ‘What shall we say?’ He replied: ‘Say: Allah is our Protector, and you have no protector.’
Abu Sufyan said: ‘Our day is a day for the day of Badr; the war has its ups and downs (as in the proverb of the bucket), and you will find mutilation (of the dead), which I did not command, nor did it displease me.’ [Recorded by al-Bukhari (4043) and al-Bayhaqi in Dala’il an-Nubuwwah (3/268)] In another narration, Umar said: ‘They are not equal! Our dead are in Paradise, and your dead are in the Fire.’
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-dialogue-between-rasulullah-saw-and-his-companions-a-strong-divider-between-truth-and-falsehood-after-the-1789487625)
Originally published by Republika (https://khazanah.republika.co.id/berita/tleso0320/dialog-rasulullah-saw-dan-para-sahabat-pemisah-kuat-antara-yang-hak-dan-batik-setelah-perang-uhud), translated from Indonesian