The Busy Bureaucracy Trap: Advanced Technology, Yet Bureaucracy Remains Busy
When I first saw the Wujing (Chinese Armed Police) officers standing at various crowded points in Beijing some time ago, I wondered what they were actually doing. They barely moved. Standing in place, observing the situation, without appearing to serve anyone or handle any specific incident. If using the standard measure of busyness we use in bureaucracy, it would be difficult to say they were working.
Yet, that is precisely their function. They do not need to do anything because their very presence is part of the job. Their presence reduces the possibility of something occurring that requires intervention. There is a simple lesson there: in a mature system, success is not always visible as activity. Sometimes, success is seen in the absence of intervention. This logic is interesting when applied to the Indonesian bureaucracy.
We are accustomed to viewing busy employees as productive employees. Every activity must be recorded, reported, and verified. One example is the daily logbook. Essentially, recording activities is a sensible instrument to ensure work is progressing. The problem arises when easily recorded activities become the primary measure of productivity.
Employees record what they do, superiors verify, and then the activity is approved through various levels. This cycle continues incessantly. As a result, working time can be absorbed by various internal activities that do not directly provide additional benefits to service users.
A paradox emerges at a certain point. Employees who complete work quickly, simply, and automatically may actually have fewer activities to record. Conversely, employees who must perform extensive verification, meetings, form-filling, re-checking, and reporting will appear far busier. Busyness can eventually transform from a consequence of work into the goal of work itself. The problem becomes more interesting when technology is adopted to resolve work.
Indonesia is moving towards the digitalisation of public services. Various applications are being built to accelerate processes, reduce manual labour, and improve service quality. However, digitalisation does not always mean simplification. We often merely move manual work onto a computer screen.
In the past, the public filled out paper forms; now they fill them out electronically. Previously, documents were physically transported; now they are uploaded. Previously, signatures were made with pens; now they use electronic signatures. The medium has changed, but the process has not necessarily changed.
If employees still have to enter the same data into multiple applications, re-verify data that is already available, print documents generated by the system, and then re-upload them to another system, then we have not actually automated the process. We have only moved manual labour into the digital world.
This issue is complicated by the fragmentation of innovation. On one hand, every institution is required to build increasingly integrated services. On the other hand, every unit is encouraged to have its own flagship innovation. Consequently, a paradox arises where the overall system seeks integration, but the organisational assessment system provides incentives for fragmented innovation.
Every unit builds its own applications, channels, dashboards, or service mechanisms. Each appears innovative. However, for the user, more innovation can simply mean more applications, accounts, and processes to face. Technology does not always reduce bureaucracy; sometimes it only makes bureaucracy appear more modern in appearance.
This brings us to a more fundamental question: why is bureaucracy not always brave enough to implement full automation? The answer may not solely be resistance to technology. Automation has a simple consequence: the reduction of the need for humans within an organisation.
If a service that previously required ten people can then be run by two people because most of the processes are automated, that is an economic success. But organisationally, that success presents a new problem. What happens to the other eight people? What happens to the organisational unit? Does the organisation receive an award for successfully becoming more efficient? Or is it instead ‘punished’ through staff reductions, structural cuts, the merging of units, or even the more extreme dissolution of the organisation because it is deemed no longer necessary?
This is where the paradox of incentives arises. Bureaucracy is asked to be efficient, but achieving efficiency can reduce the very reason for the organisation’s existence. It is no wonder that automation is often carried out half-heartedly. Applications are available, but manual processes are maintained. Data is available digitally, but must still be re-entered. Services are online, but only accessible during working hours. Systems are built, but when a slight exception occurs, manual processes involving physical activity return.
This is where the idea of organisational preservation becomes important. If an organisation has successfully automated most of its processes, what should be done with its employees? The answer does not always have to be staff reduction or organisational downsizing. Rather, there needs to be a different phase when an organisation has reached a certain level of maturity, involving appreciation that the organisation has become mature and present.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-busy-bureaucracy-trap-advanced-technology-yet-bureaucracy-remains-busy-1790135560)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20260923093219-14-770106/the-busy-bureaucracy-trap-teknologi-maju-birokrasi-tetap-harus-sibuk), translated from Indonesian