Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

The bare-bones budget

| Source: The Jakarta Post

The bare-bones budget

The draft 2001 state budget will impose contractive pressures
on the economy in the fiscal year beginning in January despite
deficit spending of Rp 52.11 trillion (US$5.9 billion) because
more than 78 percent of the Rp 295.11 trillion total spending
will fail to generate any new purchasing power.

Indeed, with the almost Rp 70 trillion to be spent on
subsidies and foreign debt service and with Rp 163.4 trillion in
taxes being withdrawn from the economy, public sector spending
will be unable to provide any stimulus to the economy.

The question then is how private investment, which has
remained on the sideline waiting for more stable political and
security conditions, can be expected to generate the 4.5 percent
growth targeted for next year.

But that is only one of the vulnerabilities of the 2001 budget
which will for the first time be based on the calendar year,
instead of the April- March fiscal year used since 1969. It is
misleading to compare next year's budget to the current one which
runs only for nine months from April to December. But even if the
current budget is annualized, the 12.3 percent nominal spending
increase planned for the 2001 budget will still be only about 5
percent in real terms (adjusted for inflation).

Another weakness of the budget is the sharp rise in inflexible
spending, notably interest expense for Rp 642.54 trillion in
treasury bonds issued to recapitalize banks and to finance the
government bank deposit guarantee. This means that the Rp 55.8
trillion budgeted for the bond interest charge for 2001 is
vulnerable to variations in the rupiah exchange rate and
inflation. The interest expense could still rise if the central
bank's benchmark interest rate, to which the bond interest rate
is pegged, turned out to be higher than the average 11 percent
projected for the whole year. The benchmark rate is now 13.60
percent and the rupiah exchange rate is hovering at Rp 8,700 to
the dollar, much weaker than the Rp 7,300 envisaged for 2001.

Another noteworthy entry in the budget is the abrupt expansion
in appropriations for provinces and districts in correlation with
the implementation of regional autonomy and the new inter-
governmental fiscal relations beginning in January. The transfer
of Rp 75 trillion, more than 25 percent of total spending, to
provinces and districts will help to appease separatist
sentiments in restive provinces. The formidable challenge,
though, is how to ensure that this significant spending power
will be properly accounted for and proportional to the transfer
of responsibility for public services to local administrations.

On the revenue side, the Rp 163.4 trillion receipts expected
from domestic taxes seem too optimistic in view of the shoddy tax
administration and fragile economic recovery. Likewise, targeting
Rp 5.0 trillion revenues from sales of state companies and Rp 27
trillion from asset recovery by the Indonesian Bank Restructuring
Agency to cover 62 percent of the budget deficit is quite a tall
order. Both targets set for the current budget remain largely on
paper and we do not foresee any significant improvement in
security, political conditions and political leadership next year
to promote higher performance in those areas.

The government expects to cover the other 32 percent of the
deficit with new foreign loans of Rp 35.9 trillion, but the blunt
reality is that the budget will actually suffer the rigors of a
debt trap in that principal and interest payments on outstanding
foreign debts will total the equivalent of Rp 37.47 trillion,
ending up with a net outflow of Rp 1.6 trillion.

The government apparently prefers to err on the conservative
side by projecting an average oil price at $22/barrel next year,
compared to $33 at present. But we cannot help but suspect that
the real reason behind the too conservative projection is that
the government wants to have a broader latitude and full control
of the use of any windfall oil profits without having first to
ask for House approval.

So all in all, however one assess the budget, the spending
plan is not only quite austere but also highly vulnerable to
various variables both in the economic, security and political
arenas. This makes it even most imperative that the budget
proposal be subjected to the healthy rigors of democratic debates
and tailored to popular demands for greater transparency and less
corruption.

More from 3 October 2000 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-bare-bones-budget-1447893297-1298135)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print