Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

The Argument Against Considering the Hijri New Year Prayer as a Forbidden Innovation

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Legal
The Argument Against Considering the Hijri New Year Prayer as a Forbidden Innovation
Image: Republika

As the Islamic community enters the new year 1448 Hijri, Muslims often observe the tradition of reciting prayers for the beginning and end of the year in congregation at prayer rooms, mosques, or study circles. Despite this, a minority of parties consider the tradition of reciting prayers at the start of the Hijri calendar to be a matter without foundation from the Prophet Muhammad SAW, or a bid’ah (innovation).

What exactly is the legal ruling on holding prayers to welcome the arrival of the month of Muharram or the Islamic New Year? Is it truly a forbidden innovation as prohibited by the Prophet?

Author at Rumah Fiqih Indonesia, Ustaz Firman Arifandi, explained that the tradition of reciting prayers to welcome the month of Muharram is not practised by Muslims without a basis. In principle, as long as it does not contradict the essence of the Qur’an, the Sunnah, scholarly consensus (Ijma), and the traditions of the companions (atsar sahabat), the matter cannot be deemed heretical.

According to him, there is a piece of evidence believed to be a practice of the Prophet’s companions through a narration from Abdullah bin Hisyam in al-Mu’jam al-Awsath by Imam Thabrani:

From Abdullah bin Hisyam, he said that the companions of the Messenger of Allah, peace be upon him, would learn the following supplication when entering a new year or month: ‘O Allah, bring it upon us with security, faith, safety, and Islam. Grant us the pleasure of the Most Merciful and protection from Satan.’ (Narrated by Thabrani, deemed Hasan by Al-Hafizh Al-Haitsami).

This tradition (atsar) is not found in any other narration except from Thabrani, and its chain is not found except through the aforementioned line of transmission, where Risydin bin Sa’ad is the sole narrator in that chain. Nevertheless, Imam Ahmad stated that this hadith was deemed hasan (good) by Al-Hafidz Al-Haitsamiy.

‘In establishing the status of a hadith or a companion’s tradition, scholars sometimes disagree. This is often part of the reason for differences of opinion (asbab ikhtilaf) in legal conclusions within fiqh,’ said Ustaz Firman, as quoted from Rumah Fiqih Indonesia.

More from 15 June 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-argument-against-considering-the-hijri-new-year-prayer-as-a-forbidden-innovation-1781520867)
Originally published by Republika (https://khazanah.republika.co.id/berita/tgo4p8483/dalil-ini-melawan-anggapan-doa-awal-dan-akhir-tahun-hijriah-sebagai-praktik-bidah-munkaroh), translated from Indonesian
Print