The 4% Rule: How to Calculate Your Ideal Retirement Fund and Its Limitations
The 4% rule is a retirement fund withdrawal strategy that suggests an individual withdraw a maximum of 4% of their total retirement assets in the first year, then adjust that amount for inflation each subsequent year. The concept aims to ensure retirement funds last for at least 30 years, assuming the portfolio is invested in a specific composition rather than just ‘conservatively’. For instance, if someone has a retirement fund of Rp2 billion, the relatively safe annual withdrawal would be around Rp80 million, or about Rp6.6 million per month.
The concept was first introduced by William P. Bengen, a now-retired American financial planner, through research published in the Journal of Financial Planning in October 1994. Bengen analysed US stock and bond market data dating back to 1926 and found that a withdrawal rate of around 4.15%—not exactly 4%—was the safe limit based on the worst-case scenarios in US market history. His portfolio assumption was also specific: 50% stocks (S&P 500) and 50% intermediate-term government bonds. The ‘4%’ figure is a rounding that later became popular among the public and media. In subsequent, more sophisticated research over the years, Bengen revised his figure upwards. He later stated that a more appropriate number is around 4.7%, even approaching 5% with certain diversification strategies. Bengen also emphasised that inflation is the greatest threat to retirement funds, as it can erode purchasing power far faster than many people anticipate.
The calculation principle is simple: the ideal retirement fund equals 25 times annual expenses. First, calculate monthly expenses based on a realistic current lifestyle. For example, if monthly expenses are Rp7 million, annual expenses are Rp84 million. Applying the 4% rule, Rp84 million divided by 4% equals a target retirement fund of Rp2.1 billion. The higher the lifestyle, the larger the fund that must be prepared.
Despite its popularity, many financial planners stress that the 4% rule should be considered a starting point, not a definitive formula. Ronald Palastro, Founder & CEO of Cobblestone Wealth Advisors, called the rule ‘simple and dangerous’, noting that withdrawing 4% during a year when both stock and bond markets crash makes recovering losses extremely difficult. He argues modern retirement products and software have far surpassed this simplification. Sean Lovison, a CFP and founder of Purpose Built Financial Services, recommends a more adaptive ‘dynamic guardrail strategy’ that automatically adjusts withdrawal amounts based on market conditions and personal financial situations, rather than using a fixed annual figure.
Global investment firm Charles Schwab Investment Management asserts that retirement withdrawal rates must be tailored to the length of retirement, asset composition, and individual risk profiles. They recommend evaluating withdrawal rates at least once a year and adjusting them to changing market conditions and personal circumstances.
The 4% rule’s advantages include its simplicity, ease of calculation, and provision of a concrete retirement fund target. Its limitations are that it does not specifically account for taxes, does not anticipate spikes in healthcare costs, relies on historical US market data rather than Indonesian market data, and is less suitable for very long retirements of 40 years or more. The safe withdrawal figure also fluctuates annually according to market conditions.
In the Indonesian context, the 4% rule was not designed for local investors. Formal sector employees need to account for Jaminan Hari Tua (JHT) and Jaminan Pensiun (JP) benefits from BPJS Ketenagakerjaan as a foundation, which reduces the amount that must be saved independently. Indonesia’s inflation rate also differs from that of the US, requiring adjustment to the assumed inflation figure.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/the-4-rule-how-to-calculate-your-ideal-retirement-fund-and-its-limitations-1781675521)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/mymoney/20260617121258-72-743342/4-rule-cara-hitung-dana-pensiun-ideal-dan-batasannya), translated from Indonesian