Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Tensions Flare as Prosecutor and Roy Suryo’s Lawyer Clash During Jokowi’s Testimony

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Tensions Flare as Prosecutor and Roy Suryo’s Lawyer Clash During Jokowi’s Testimony
Image: detikcom

The trial of Roy Suryo, who is accused of defaming former president Joko Widodo (Jokowi) over his diploma, became heated while Jokowi was testifying. The prosecutor and Roy Suryo’s lawyer shouted at each other, prompting the judge to suspend the hearing.

The hearing was held at the East Jakarta District Court on Thursday (5 November 2026). It resumed with questions from Roy’s lawyer to Jokowi.

Roy’s lawyer, Refly Harun, initially asked Jokowi what actions by Roy he considered to be attacks on his reputation or defamatory. Jokowi answered the question.

The judge interrupted Jokowi, saying the prosecutor had already asked the question and Jokowi had explained the matter. Jokowi said he had repeated his explanation because Refly had asked him.

“Let me put it this way. The prosecutor asked about this earlier, and the footage was played. Is that everything, and is it correct, Witness?” asked presiding judge Christina Endarwati.

“Yes. Since I was asked, I repeated it,” Jokowi replied.

The judge told Roy’s lawyer not to repeat questions. The prosecutor also asked whether the prosecution could raise an objection when Roy’s team repeated a question.

“We respect the instruction not to interrupt. That is why we did not interrupt earlier, so if the panel of judges considers it sufficient, then it is sufficient. We were simply seeking to clarify,” Roy’s lawyer said.

“Your Honours, may we ask what was meant by ‘interrupting’? Are we not allowed to object if a question is repeated? With your permission,” the prosecutor said.

“I was the one who interrupted just now. The question had already been asked, and the prosecution had even shown all the footage from those minutes. Is that right?” the judge said.

“It was shown, Your Honour,” the prosecutor replied.

The prosecutor asked the judge to require Roy’s lawyer to address the prosecution through the bench. The judge then asked Jokowi to say if Roy’s team had asked something already covered by the prosecutor.

An argument broke out, with the prosecutor and Roy’s lawyer shouting at each other. Roy’s lawyer asked the judge to remove a prosecutor he said was disrupting the hearing.

The prosecutor asked the judge to remind Roy’s lawyer to remain polite. The judge then suspended the hearing.

“Then remove the person who is disrupting the hearing!” Roy’s lawyer shouted.

“With your permission, Your Honours, please remind him not to raise his voice like that. He should be more polite,” the prosecutor said.

“You’re the one disrupting it!” Roy’s lawyer retorted.

“Please address the panel of judges, Your Honours,” the prosecutor interjected.

“You’re the one disrupting it!” Roy’s lawyer said.

“That’s enough,” the judge said.

“This is outrageous, absolutely unacceptable! We have never disrupted him!” Roy’s lawyer said.

“They interrupted too, Your Honours,” the prosecutor said.

“Please, keep order,” the judge said.

“Yes. And it’s not just in this hearing; it was the same at Dr Tifa’s hearing!” Roy’s lawyer said.

“Recess. We’ll suspend the hearing,” the judge said.

“Yes. It’s the same person, Your Honour!” Roy’s lawyer added.

The judge asked those in the public gallery not to make noise and urged both Roy’s lawyer and the prosecutor to remain calm so the hearing could proceed in a more orderly atmosphere.

“And those in the public gallery, please calm down and don’t make noise. Keep your voices down. Speak calmly so the atmosphere is more comfortable,” the judge said.

“The public prosecutors should be maintaining proper conduct. There are rules,” Roy’s lawyer said.

“Your Honours, with your permission. We have been speaking through the panel of judges all along. The advocate has been addressing us directly,” the prosecutor replied.

The judge reopened the hearing after the suspension and instructed both the defence and prosecution teams to maintain order.

“Enough! I’m reopening the hearing. The suspension is lifted. Just a moment. The defence team, please keep your team under control. And the prosecution team—Mr Marcelo, is that you? Which one is Mr Marcelo? Marcelo Bela? Please keep your team under control too. Both the defence and prosecution should maintain order,” the judge said.

The hearing then continued, and Roy’s lawyer resumed questioning Jokowi.

“Right. We’ll ask our questions. If you feel something has already been explained, just say it has been explained; there is no need to interrupt. That’s the most important thing. All right, we’ll continue,” Roy’s lawyer said.

Roy Suryo is accused of defaming Jokowi. Prosecutors say he spread false information about Jokowi’s diploma.

He is charged under Article 433(1) in conjunction with Article 441(1) of Law No. 1 of 2023 on the Criminal Code. In the alternative, he faces charges under Article 35 in conjunction with Article 51(1), and Article 32 in conjunction with Article 48(1), of the Electronic Information and Transactions Law No. 11 of 2008, as amended by Law No. 1 of 2026 on Criminal Penalties.

More from 5 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/tensions-flare-as-prosecutor-and-roy-suryos-lawyer-clash-during-jokowis-testimony-1793865225)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8739577/panas-jaksa-dan-pengacara-roy-suryo-saling-bentak-saat-jokowi-bersaksi), translated from Indonesian
Print