Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Tempting Headlines, Disappointing Content: A Fiqh Perspective on Clickbait

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Anthropology
Tempting Headlines, Disappointing Content: A Fiqh Perspective on Clickbait
Image: Republika

Have you ever opened a news story because its headline was shocking, only to reach the end and wonder, “What was so sensational about it?”

This phenomenon has become increasingly familiar amid the rapid flow of digital information. Readers have only a few seconds to decide whether to read, scroll or click. In this attention economy, headlines are no longer merely labels for content; they are tools for winning clicks. Headlines are commonly tested in several versions, with the one that attracts the most clicks selected — though it is not necessarily the most honest.

This is how clickbait has grown: headlines or introductions deliberately designed to pique curiosity and make readers click. Human curiosity is readily stirred. Psychologist George Loewenstein explains that curiosity arises when we perceive a gap between what we already know and what we want to know.

The problem is not an engaging headline, but one that deliberately creates such a gap and fails to fulfil its promise in the article. This strategy becomes problematic when curiosity is no longer used to introduce information, but is instead cultivated through an impression that does not match reality.

In practice, curiosity can be exploited through headlines that deliberately omit important information or exaggerate an event. Readers end up clicking not because they have been given a clear picture, but because they are driven to seek an answer to the impression created by the headline.

The issue is particularly sensitive when religious values are involved. Imagine a headline that makes people think a religious scholar has declared something permissible or forbidden, when the original statement was lengthy and conditional. Such a headline can easily be screenshotted and shared in WhatsApp groups without anyone reading to the end. Its context is then lost, while the headline continues to circulate as “information”.

Can it be justified to attract readers with a headline that does not reflect the content of the article?

From the perspective of fiqh, the issue can be examined through the concept of tadlis: concealing a defect or presenting something in a way that creates a false understanding. A classical basis for this is a hadith recorded by Muslim. The Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) once passed a food seller, put his hand into a pile of food and found that the bottom was wet. He said: “Whoever deceives us is not one of us.”

There is also the case of tashriyah, recorded by al-Bukhari and Muslim: withholding a goat’s milk so that its udder appears full. A deceived buyer is given the right of khiyar — the choice to proceed with or cancel the sale. By analogy, a headline that promises more than its content resembles an udder made to look full. Readers may “pay” with their time and attention, while the media outlet receives clicks and advertising revenue. The difference is that disappointed readers cannot get their time back, especially if they have already shared the story without reading it to the end.

This analogy must, however, be applied professionally. Buying and selling have a different legal context from consuming news. Tadlis in a sale does not automatically carry identical legal consequences when applied to a news headline.

Not all clickbait is tadlis. The key criteria are intent and impact. An engaging headline that remains faithful to the content, does not falsify facts and does not distort context is a legitimate and safe craft. But when a creator knows that the impression produced by the headline differs from the content and still chooses it to drive traffic, the element of manipulation is difficult to deny. In such cases, the headline deserves to be judged forbidden and reprehensible.

The Qur’an reinforces this argument through the principle of qaulan sadidan — truthful and upright speech (QS Al-Ahzab: 70–71). The maxim “la darar wa la dirar” prohibits actions that harm others, including misleading them. Meanwhile, QS Al-Hujurat: 6 sets out the principle of tabayyun, or verification, which is often imposed on readers who share information without checking its accuracy. Yet information producers also have a duty not to deliberately lead people to false assumptions through headlines: even critical readers can be misled by headlines designed to deceive.

The Indonesian Ulema Council’s Fatwa No. 24 of 2017 on guidelines for conducting social interactions through social media affirms that spreading false information is forbidden. Article 1 of the Journalistic Code of Ethics also requires news to be accurate and free of bad faith. Both converge on one point: information is a trust.

Content creators should therefore review headlines before publication. Do they accurately reflect the story, preserve the context of statements and avoid steering readers towards a mistaken conclusion? These simple questions can be a first step towards balancing the need to attract attention with the responsibility to communicate honestly.

This is not a call for flat, boring headlines. Headlines may arouse curiosity and use strong language, as long as they do not alter the meaning of facts or turn readers into targets of a misleading lure. Clickbait may be a new term, but the issues behind it — honesty, trust and the prohibition on harming others — have long been discussed in Islam. This is where fiqh demonstrates its relevance to the latest communications technology.

Ultimately, the challenge of media ethics is not merely to get people to click, but to ensure readers still trust the outlet after they finish reading. A single headline may bring thousands of clicks and perhaps a short-term gain. But if readers repeatedly feel deceived, what is at stake is trust — all the more so when religion is involved. Media outlets should not sacrifice the much greater trust placed in them to safeguard the truth of information for the sake of a single click.

More from 3 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/tempting-headlines-disappointing-content-a-fiqh-perspective-on-clickbait-1793724693)
Originally published by Republika (https://retizen.republika.co.id/posts/791096/judul-menggoda-isi-mengecewakan-kacamata-fiqh-atas-clickbait), translated from Indonesian
Print