Tax Restitution: Restoring Rights, Building Trust
“Taxes are what we pay for civilized society.”
This remark by Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr. serves as a reminder that tax is not merely a citizen’s financial obligation, but the foundation for a state capable of providing education, healthcare, infrastructure, social protection, security, and various public services.
In Indonesia, the role of tax is increasingly strategic. Amidst substantial development needs and limited fiscal space, tax revenue forms the backbone of the State Budget (APBN). However, the success of a taxation system cannot be measured solely by the amount of revenue collected.
Tax is, in essence, part of the social contract between the state and society. Citizens surrender a portion of their income because they trust the state will manage it for the public interest. Conversely, the state is obliged to exercise its authority to collect taxes fairly, proportionately, and accountably.
Furthermore, Jean-Baptiste Colbert (1619-1683), Finance Minister to King Louis XIV of France, once likened the art of taxation to “plucking the goose so as to obtain the largest possible amount of feathers with the smallest possible amount of hissing”. In a modern context, this analogy needs to be read further.
The state’s financing needs should not be used as a reason to collect taxes excessively, to the point of reducing the ability of the public and businesses to conduct their economic activities. A successful state is not one that can collect the maximum amount of tax, but one that can collect tax appropriately – not less, but also not more.
From Adam Smith to Sumitronomics
More than two centuries ago, Adam Smith, in An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, formulated four maxims of taxation that remain a reference for modern tax administration today: equity, certainty, convenience, and economy. A good tax must satisfy fairness, provide legal certainty, be easy for the taxpayer to comply with, and be collected at the lowest possible administrative cost.
This principle was later enriched by Richard Musgrave, who explained that fiscal policy has three main functions: allocation, distribution, and stabilisation. Tax is not only an instrument for obtaining state revenue (budgetary function), but also a tool to improve income distribution, correct market failures, and maintain economic stability.
In the Indonesian context, the thinking of Prof. Sumitro Djojohadikusumo offers a highly relevant perspective. Sumitro never placed fiscal policy solely as an instrument of state financing. Instead, fiscal policy was viewed as an instrument of development that must enlarge national production capacity, encourage industrialisation, expand employment opportunities, and increase economic productivity.
This view carries a very important implication. The state will not obtain sustainable tax revenue if the productive sector loses its ability to grow. Tax revenue ultimately derives from economic activity. When investment increases, production grows, jobs are created, and corporate profits expand, the tax base will also develop naturally.
This is the essence of what I believe deserves to be called Sumitronomics: that fiscal success is not measured by how much revenue is collected today, but by the ability of fiscal policy to enlarge the economic capacity that will be the source of revenue in the future.
From this perspective, every tax policy should be evaluated based on one simple question: does the policy strengthen or weaken the ability of the productive sector to grow?
Restitution as Part of a Sustainable Tax System
The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), in various publications on modern tax administration, affirms that tax reform is no longer solely oriented towards increasing revenue. The focus has shifted towards building a sustainable tax system – one capable of maintaining a balance between the state’s fiscal needs, economic growth, and public compliance.
Such a system is built on three main pillars: First, the state obtains sufficient revenue to finance public services. Second, the business world retains room to grow so that the tax base continues to expand. Third, the public has trust in the tax administration so that voluntary compliance increases.
The OECD also shows that Indonesia’s tax-to-GDP ratio is still relatively low compared to many other countries. In Revenue Statistics in Asia and the Pacific 2026, Indonesia’s tax ratio was recorded at 11.8 percent in 2024, far below the Asia-Pacific regional average of around 19.7 percent, and the OECD average of around 34.1 percent.
The low tax ratio cannot be used as a reason to act arbitrarily by blurring the line between revenue that is the state’s right and funds that are legally the taxpayer’s right.
It is precisely Indonesia’s still-limited fiscal space that should serve as a basis for the government to build a taxation system capable of enlarging the tax base through economic growth and increased compliance, not by retaining funds that should actually be returned to taxpayers.
It is in this context that restitution is not merely an administrative issue, but one of the instruments for maintaining trust in the taxation system. This is an important point, because in a modern taxation system, trust is fiscal capital whose value is as important as the revenue itself.
Restitution Is Not an Anomaly, but a Consequence of the Modern Tax System
In a modern taxation system, restitution is not a deviation, but an almost unavoidable consequence. The mechanism of tax instalment payments, withholding by third parties, tax credits, the characteristics of Value Added Tax (VAT), export transactions subject to a zero percent rate, and large investments in the early stages of a project can naturally give rise to an overpayment position.
In other words, the existence of restitution does not indicate a flaw in the taxation system. Restitution is precisely a correction mechanism so that the state does not retain funds that are not legally its right. In simple terms, restitution can be an instrument to ensure the state does not wrong its citizens who are taxpayers.
Therefore, the measure of a tax administration’s success is not the decreasing amount of restitution paid. A more appropriate measure is the increasing accuracy of tax collection, the faster return of overpayments, and the lower compliance cost borne by taxpayers.
Restitution and Business Liquidity
In April 2026, a discourse emerged from the Chair of Commission XI of the Indonesian House of Representatives (DPR RI) regarding the possibility of withholding restitution under conditions of fiscal pressure, with the argument that such a step could strengthen state revenue.
This discourse then sparked debate because, on the other hand, restitution is a taxpayer’s right under the taxation system, so withholding restitution should be a last resort when a fiscal crisis occurs, and not a primary strategy for resolving the state’s fiscal problems.
From a business perspective, restitution is not merely a refund of funds. Restitution is part of working capital. Imagine a manufacturing company with an excess VAT payment of Rp500 billion. These funds could be used to purchase raw materials, pay suppliers, expand, increase production capacity, buy new machinery, or recruit additional workers.
If these funds are held up for nine or ten months due to lengthy administrative processes, what is lost is not merely the interest on the money. What is lost is the opportunity to create added value: company liquidity is reduced, investment is delayed, demand for capital goods weakens, employment opportunities do not increase, and production grows more slowly. Ultimately, the tax base that is the source of future state revenue also shrinks.
This is what distinguishes a short-term from a long-term perspective. In the short term, withholding restitution may improve the government’s cash position. However, in the long term, delays in restitution can actually reduce state revenue through weakened economic activity.
This perspective is very much in line with the thinking of Prof. Sumitro Djojohadikusumo. For Sumitro, the success of fiscal policy never stops at the ability to collect revenue. Fiscal policy must be an instrument for enlarging national production capacity.
This means that funds returned to productive companies are not a loss to the state. These funds will be transformed back into investment, production, corporate profits, employment opportunities, and ultimately into new tax objects. From the Sumitronomics perspective, fast restitution is not a fiscal cost. It is a state investment to expand the tax revenue base in the future.
Learning from International Practice: Fast for the Compliant, Firm for the Risky
The debate over restitution is not unique to Indonesia. Almost all countries face the same dilemma: how to return taxpayers’ rights quickly without opening up room for abuse that could harm state revenue. International experience shows that the best solution is not to choose between service or oversight. Both must go hand in hand.
Singapore is one of the most frequently cited examples. Through the Inland Revenue Authority of Singapore (IRAS), tax administration is built on risk-based compliance. Taxpayers with a good compliance record receive relatively fast service, while audit resources are focused on transactions and taxpayers with a high-risk profile.
A similar approach is applied by the Australian Taxation Office (ATO). By utilising third-party reporting, data analysis, and real-time compliance, most low-risk applications can be processed more simply, while oversight is directed at transaction patterns that genuinely require deeper examination.
The Netherlands has even developed the concept of horizontal monitoring, a partnership between the tax authority and taxpayers built on transparency and openness. In this approach, compliance is not enforced solely through audits, but also through intensive communication and legal certainty.
Meanwhile, Estonia demonstrates how digitalisation can transform the face of tax administration. Cross-agency data integration allows administrative processes to be carried out almost automatically, so that processing times become much shorter without reducing the quality of oversight.
These four countries have different economic characteristics. However, there is one common principle. They do not treat all taxpayers as potential violators.
Instead, they use data to identify who is genuinely high-risk, so that oversight can be carried out more effectively and compliance costs for compliant taxpayers can be reduced. This approach is what the OECD has widely recommended as the direction for modern tax administration.
In Indonesia, Minister of Finance Regulation (PMK) Number 28 of 2026 is not merely a change in restitution administrative procedures. This regulation reflects a change in the philosophy of Indonesian tax administration.
Its focus is shifting from an approach reliant on audits towards a risk-based approach, from an administration oriented solely towards control towards one that also places service as part of a strategy to improve compliance.
However, the key lies in the implementation of this policy and how quickly the tax authority can execute it in accordance with the spirit of the transformation being pursued. In this regard, coretax is one of the determining factors, because the main requirement for this change in perspective is high-quality data, so that risk analysis is more accurate and restitution to taxpayers, particularly business actors, can be accelerated.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/tax-restitution-restoring-rights-building-trust-1786780261)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20260815134544-14-759654/restitusi-pajak-mengembalikan-hak-membangun-kepercayaan), translated from Indonesian