Tax Expenditure Transparency Improves, but Policy Consistency Remains Unproven
Indonesia has secured the top position in the 2026 Global Tax Expenditures Transparency Index, demonstrating significant improvements in the governance of government tax incentive reporting. However, at the same time, the consistency of fiscal policy remains untested, particularly regarding the utilisation of surging commodity prices to bolster state revenue.
According to the 2026 Global Tax Expenditures Transparency Index (GTETI) report, Indonesia achieved a score of 79.9, ranking first among 116 countries. This is an improvement from the previous year when Indonesia ranked second, placing it ahead of several developed nations including South Korea, Australia, Canada, and the United States.
The GTETI is a global comparative index that assesses the quality of transparency in reporting tax incentives or tax expenditures. The ranking is based on the regularity of publication, the quality of reporting, and the breadth of information presented in official government reports. The assessment is conducted through five dimensions: Public Availability, Institutional Framework, Methodology and Scope, Descriptive Tax Expenditure Data, and Tax Expenditure Assessments.
Indonesia achieved its highest score in the ‘Methodology and Scope’ indicator, with a rating of 19 out of 20. This ranking is supported by the improved quality of the Tax Expenditure Report (TER) published by the Indonesian Ministry of Finance. The report includes the types of incentives, policy objectives, beneficiaries, legal basis, and estimated values of tax expenditures.
In an official statement from the Ministry of Finance, this strengthened reporting is part of an effort to maintain the accountability of the State Budget (APBN) while ensuring that tax incentives can be monitored by the public. In 2025, tax expenditures for households and MSMEs reached approximately Rp 389 trillion, accounting for more than 70 per cent of total incentives provided.
The government maintains that these incentive policies have supported the economy. In the first quarter of 2026, the economy grew by 5.61 per cent, driven by domestic consumption, investment, and government spending. Investment, reflected in gross fixed capital formation, grew by 5.96 per cent, aligning with data from the Ministry of Investment and Downstreaming/Investment Coordinating Board, which showed direct investment realisation rising by 7.22 per cent.
Nevertheless, these administrative achievements are not yet fully reflected in the effectiveness of revenue policies. Amid high state expenditure needs, the government has delayed several additional revenue policies from the commodity sector. Plans to increase mineral royalties for copper, gold, silver, nickel, and tin have not yet been implemented. Similarly, the imposition of export duties on coal remains pending; currently, export duties have only been applied to gold since late last year, but their contribution to revenue remains limited.
Fiscal needs are rising significantly. Expenditure on energy subsidies and compensation as of the end of March 2026 surged by 266.5 per cent to Rp 118.7 trillion. Simultaneously, the state budget deficit is projected to approach the 3 per cent threshold of Gross Domestic Product (GDP).
Indonesia’s primary export commodity prices are currently strengthening. Gold prices rose by 73 per cent, copper by 40 per cent, and nickel by 9 per cent in the first quarter of 2026. This surge drove non-tax natural resource revenue to Rp 35.1 trillion, a 7.1 per cent increase compared to the same period last year.
Economist Dipo Satria Ramli of Core Indonesia noted that the delay in implementing windfall policies suggests the government has not been decisive enough in capitalising on the commodity price momentum. “When commodity prices surge, the state should be able to secure a larger share because these natural resources belong to the public. If the approach is too lax, potential revenue could be lost,” he said.
While utilising commodity windfalls is a reasonable way to strengthen short-term fiscal position, Dipo noted that such additional revenue would not be enough to offset surging state expenditures, such as the Free Nutritious Meal (MBG) programme. He argued that the government must urgently restructure spending priorities, stating that keeping the deficit below 3 per cent cannot rely solely on additional revenue. “Unproductive spending must be reduced so that fiscal space can be reallocated to social programmes and productive investment,”
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/tax-expenditure-transparency-improves-but-policy-consistency-remains-unproven-1780893577)
Originally published by kompas.id (https://www.kompas.id/artikel/transparansi-belanja-pajak-membaik-konsistensi-kebijakan-belum-teruji), translated from Indonesian