Tax Court Moving Towards One-Roof Judicial System
The Tax Court is entering a significant phase in its institutional journey. By 31 December 2026 at the latest, the organisational, administrative, and financial management of the Tax Court must transition entirely from the Ministry of Finance to the Supreme Court. This deadline was established by the Constitutional Court through Decision Number 26/PUU-XXI/2023.
With the deadline only a few months away, there is a substantial amount of work to be completed. Law Number 14 of 2002 concerning the Tax Court still contains various provisions that place the Minister of Finance in a pivotal position regarding the Tax Court. Simultaneously, the Constitutional Court’s decision has already shifted the direction of the institution’s management towards the Supreme Court.
This situation cannot be allowed to persist without adjustment. Institutional change cannot be achieved merely by transferring administrative authority from one institution to another. The legal basis governing the Tax Court must also evolve alongside this change. Otherwise, the integration risks leaving a discrepancy between the norms in the law and the institutional design mandated by the Constitutional Court.
Ending the Dualism of Management
For over two decades, the Tax Court has operated under a split management structure. Judicial technical management falls under the Supreme Court, while organisational, administrative, and financial management remains under the Ministry of Finance.
This structure was part of the design of the Tax Court Law when it was established in 2002. As Indonesia’s judicial power system has moved towards a ‘one-roof system’, the organisational, administrative, and financial management of judicial bodies has been placed under the Supreme Court. The Tax Court has remained an exception to this construction.
The issue becomes particularly sensitive because the Ministry of Finance does not only perform administrative management functions. In many tax disputes, the Directorate General of Taxes is actually the party opposing taxpayers in the Tax Court.
This condition does not automatically imply that tax judges lack independence. Judges still possess the authority to examine and decide cases based on the law. However, from an institutional perspective, such a design can raise concerns regarding institutional independence and may affect public trust in the court.
A court requires adequate distance from the parties involved in litigation, not only when judges examine cases but also in terms of organisation, administration, and finance. Judicial independence cannot merely be discussed within the courtroom; the structure supporting the court’s work must provide the same guarantee.
At this juncture, Constitutional Court Decision Number 26/PUU-XXI/2023 is vital. The Court stated that the phrase “Ministry of Finance” in Article 5 paragraph (2) of the Tax Court Law contradicts the 194/1945 Constitution, unless it is interpreted as “the Supreme Court, to be implemented gradually no later than 31 December 2026.”
The legal direction is clear. The management of the Tax Court must be placed under a single roof with the management of other judicial bodies under the Supreme Court. The dualism of management that has characterised the Tax Court must end. Furthermore, the ruling does not stop at the question of who manages it; there is legal work that must follow this change.
When Old Norms Still Apply
The Tax Court Law still contains several provisions created based on the institutional construction existing before the Constitutional Court’s decision. This makes the integration agenda more complex than simply transferring authority from the Ministry of Finance to the Supreme Court.
Article 8, for instance, still regulates the appointment of the chairman, vice-chairman, and judges of the Tax Court by the President from a list of names proposed by the Minister after receiving approval from the Supreme Court. Provisions regarding ad hoc judges are also still linked to decisions by the Minister of Finance. Similarly, regulations regarding the position of the Tax Court secretariat still allow the Minister to regulate it through ministerial decrees.
These various provisions demonstrate that the issue of integration is much broader than Article 5 paragraph (2). Once organisational, administrative, and financial management is directed to the Supreme Court, the norms that still grant certain powers to the Minister of Finance need to be synchronised. We must ensure that even if the institutional structure changes, the norms governing the daily operations of the Tax Court do not continue to use the old design.
While the Constitutional Court’s decision is legally binding, building a new governance system solely by relying on the reinterpretation of a single article is insufficient to ensure the entire legal framework of the Tax Court follows the new direction.
Therefore, a revision of the Tax Court Law is becoming an unavoidable necessity. A revision should not merely involve replacing the nomenclature “Minister of Finance” with “Supreme Court”. What is required is a restructuring of provisions that are systematically related to the institutional design of the Tax Court.
The status of judges, the mechanism for appointment and dismissal, the secretariat, human resources, budgeting, and even procedural law need to be placed within a construction consistent with the one-roof judicial system.
The issue of time makes this need increasingly urgent. The 31 December 2026 deadline cannot be treated as a mere administrative target. This deadline is part of the ruling’s mandate and considerations that must be implemented.
If integration is carried out without legislative adjustment, the potential problems are not merely administrative. The legality of authority and institutional legitimacy [are at risk].
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/tax-court-moving-towards-one-roof-judicial-system-1788108926)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20260830232623-14-763487/pengadilan-pajak-menuju-satu-atap-peradilan), translated from Indonesian