Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

TAUD Strongly Criticises Prosecutors' Cassation Appeal in Delpedro et al. Case

| Source: CNN Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Legal
TAUD Strongly Criticises Prosecutors' Cassation Appeal in Delpedro et al. Case
Image: CNN Indonesia

The Advocacy Team for Democracy (TAUD) has strongly criticised the cassation appeal filed by the Attorney General’s Office in the case of four political detainees, Delpedro Marhaen and his associates. Advocate Gema Gita Persada stated that this legal manoeuvre threatens the continuity of democracy. “The filing of a cassation appeal in this case demonstrates a lack of commitment to the sustainability of democracy, while also being a misguided response to a legal product that has set a positive precedent for protecting freedom of expression and public participation,” Gema said in a written statement quoted on Wednesday (8/4). According to him, prosecutors should not have appealed the acquittal obtained by Delpedro and his associates. He reminded that the new Criminal Procedure Code (KUHAP) stipulates that an acquittal is a form of legal protection for citizens against unfounded prosecution. Although judicial practice allows for cassation appeals against acquittals in certain circumstances, such steps should be taken very sparingly and only if there is a clear and fundamental error in the application of the law, not merely due to dissatisfaction with the court’s decision. As law enforcers, Gema said, prosecutors should be able to assess the quality of a good and progressive legal product for the future enforcement of the law. The acquittal in this case not only restores the rights of the defendants but also strengthens the principle of due process of law and emphasises the importance of fact- and law-based proof, rather than political pressure. “The habit of continuously challenging acquittals through legal remedies without strong grounds risks creating adverse effects on the criminal justice system,” Gema stated. “Such practices can erode legal certainty, weaken public trust in the independence of judicial institutions, and create a chilling effect on society in exercising their constitutional rights to express opinions and participate in democratic life,” he added. Gema further noted that filing a cassation appeal against an acquittal in a case laden with political overtones from the outset risks prolonging legal uncertainty for the defendants. This not only causes personal harm but also reveals a tendency to use criminal law as an instrument of repression against civil liberties. “The cassation step in this case risks diminishing the meaning of the legal victory achieved by the defendants through a long and open trial process. That victory is not merely an individual triumph but a win for the rule of law and the protection of freedom of expression,” he emphasised. On that basis, he urged the Attorney General’s Office to reconsider this legal action. Additionally, TAUD called on the Supreme Court (MA) to examine and decide the cassation petition in this case objectively, independently, and based on the principles of human rights protection, particularly freedom of expression and the right to a fair trial. The Attorney General’s Office explained the reasons for filing the cassation appeal in the Delpedro et al. case, even though the new KUHAP prohibits it. Head of the Legal Information Centre of the Attorney General’s Office, Anang Supriatna, clarified that the incitement case was transferred to the court on 9 December 2025, so the applicable procedural law is the old KUHAP. Based on the transitional provisions as per Article 361 letter c of the new KUHAP, he explained, criminal cases that have been transferred to the court and where the examination process has begun shall continue to be examined, tried, and decided based on the provisions of Law No. 8 of 1981 on Criminal Procedure (old KUHAP), except for the Review process which follows the 2025 KUHAP provisions. “Thus, for the case of Delpedro Marhaen Rismansyah et al., which was acquitted (vrijspraak) during the examination period, the legal remedy still refers to Law No. 8 of 1981 on Criminal Procedure (old KUHAP), so cassation is pursued for that case,” Anang said when confirmed via written message on Tuesday (7/4). The Attorney General’s Office has officially filed a cassation appeal against the acquittal obtained by Delpedro and three of his colleagues, who are political detainees previously prosecuted for incitement related to demonstrations in August last year. The three individuals are Muzaffar Salim from the Lokataru Foundation, admin of @gejayanmemanggil Syahdan Husein, and Riau University student and admin of Aliansi Mahasiswa Menggugat, Khariq Anhar. “Date of application: Monday, 16 March 2026. Cassation applicant: Tri Yanti Merlyn Christin Pardede (Public Prosecutor),” as stated on the Central Jakarta District Court (PN) Case Tracking Information System (SIPP) page quoted on Tuesday (7/4). In response to the move, Delpedro accused the Public Prosecutor (JPU) of overriding the law by filing a cassation appeal against the acquittal in case number 742/Pid.Sus/2025/PN Jkt.Pst, handed down by the panel of judges at the Central Jakarta District Court on 6 March 2026. “The cassation filed by the Public Prosecutor is a form of disrespecting the court’s decision and overriding the law,” Delpedro said when confirmed via written message on Tuesday (7/4).

More from 8 April 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/taud-strongly-criticises-prosecutors-cassation-appeal-in-delpedro-et-al-case-1775620408)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260408095500-12-1345463/taud-kritik-keras-kasasi-jaksa-di-perkara-delpedro-dkk), translated from Indonesian
Print