Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Taking responsibility

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Taking responsibility

We are saddened to hear of the death of Fahmi Achmad. We condemn
the murder of this innocent Indonesian and the killing of other
civilians in Iraq.

It is even more tragic since Fahmi was reportedly just days
away from returning to his family back home. Killed in an ambush
in Mosul, his death is another sad reminder of the senseless
violence the good people of Iraq are faced with daily as a result
of the quagmire brought about by the United States' invasion of
their country.

It is unknown if there are any Indonesian citizens left in
Iraq. Almost all were officially pulled out ahead of the U.S.
invasion last year. But with hundreds of thousands of Indonesians
living in the Middle East, it would erroneous to presume that a
few did not trickle into Iraq.

While we should not blame the Indonesian government for
Fahmi's death, all relevant authorities and related parties
should share some of the responsibility for this sad turn of
events.

Rather than pointing fingers at whose portfolio Fahmi fell
under -- the manpower ministry, the foreign ministry, the
Association of Labor Export Companies, the consulting firm who
employed him -- it would be wiser to reflect upon our respective
responsibilities to Fahmi and all Indonesians working abroad.

It is no secret that when it comes to the question of overseas
workers, a culture of negligence prevails. They are often
regarded as a nuisance and targets for extortion. Maybe this
stems from the fact that most are unskilled and barely literate
people who do not understand their rights.

These migrant workers significantly contribute to the economy
either by sending money to their loved ones or through taxation.
The value of remittances between January and April 2004 in fact
increased by nearly 450 percent to US$425.2 million compared to
the same period the previous year.

The sending of workers to the Middle East was "officially"
suspended last year because of the invasion of Iraq.
Traditionally Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Kuwait and
Jordan are the four countries in the region that employ the
largest number of Indonesian workers in the informal sector.

The state is obliged, as stipulated in Law No. 37/1999 on
foreign relations, to protect all Indonesians overseas, including
"in cases of war" and "threats that endanger Indonesian nationals
abroad".

We concede that Fahmi's death was more the exception than the
rule. Despite the official warnings made, Fahmi and his employers
choose to enter dangerous territory at their own accord. Money is
an incurable temptation.

But we should also ask why there seemed to be no updated
travel warnings on Iraq by Indonesian authorities for quite some
time.

In this case we would like to urge the ministries of foreign
affairs and manpower to take a page from their U.S. counterparts,
who persistently update and publicize security updates around the
world.

A brief peek at the website of some Jakarta-based embassies
reveal prominently displayed travel advisories and other updates
for its citizens. We would be hard pressed to find similar
information at either the Indonesian foreign or manpower
ministries' websites.

Public access to information, a novel concept for bureaucrats
here, has as much to do with protection as it does providing
legal counsel to Indonesians jailed abroad.

Many of the problems that occur could more than likely be
averted by greater focus and attention at the predeparture and
recruitment stage.

While we welcome the efforts of the Ministry of Foreign
Affairs to transport Fahmi's body home and ensure that
compensation is paid, it is no doubt a cold, empty comfort to his
grieving family. A truly concerted effort, not just rhetoric,
should be realized along with a comprehensive protection policy
that involves all.

Otherwise, we are all culpable.

More from 25 August 2004 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/taking-responsibility-1447893297-1492709)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print