Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Tabanan Vigilantism Case Serves as Alarm, Experts Warn of Dangers in Bounty Schemes for Catching Thieves

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Tabanan Vigilantism Case Serves as Alarm, Experts Warn of Dangers in Bounty Schemes for Catching Thieves
Image: Media Indonesia

The death of a man with the initials KD, who was beaten to death by a mob in Tabanan Regency, Bali, after allegedly stealing chickens, has been seen as a stark warning about the dangers of vigilante justice.

Amid a proposal by West Java Governor Dedi Mulyadi to offer prizes or a competition for residents who succeed in catching perpetrators of street crime such as muggers, bag snatchers and thieves, experts are reminding the authorities that such a policy must not spark collective violence in society.

Josias Simon, a criminology expert at the University of Indonesia, said mob justice is an extremely difficult situation to control once residents’ emotions have been ignited. Therefore, any policy encouraging public participation in crime prevention must be accompanied by efforts to prevent triggers of violence.

“Collective violence during mob justice is hard to avoid. That is why triggers of collective violence must be minimised, because there is no mechanism for examination and verification,” Josias told Media Indonesia on Monday (27/7).

According to him, unlike law enforcement officials who work based on procedures and evidence, members of the public have no mechanism to examine or confirm whether someone is truly a perpetrator of a crime. This means mere suspicion can quickly escalate into violence that costs lives.

This view, Josias continued, is reflected in the case in Tabanan, Bali, where a man accused of stealing chickens died after being attacked by residents. The incident shows that when a mob takes over the function of law enforcement, the risk of collective violence becomes very high.

“The impact of fear of crime on the ground certainly triggers mass punishment of criminals when the authorities respond slowly and the local government does not promptly facilitate the reduction of crime triggers, such as infrastructure,” he explained.

Furthermore, Josias said the proposal to reward residents who catch perpetrators of street crime such as muggers, theft and bag snatching must also be accompanied by a clear stipulation that citizens may only help secure suspects, not punish them.

“Law enforcement mechanisms must be instilled and reminded both before and during incidents, however risky that may be,” he said.

He also stressed that education about the importance of handing suspects over to the police must be an inseparable part of any policy involving public participation. Without such emphasis, the enthusiasm to assist the authorities could shift into justification for vigilante action.

Furthermore, Adrianus reminded that success in crime prevention is not only measured by the capture of perpetrators, but also by upholding the principle of the rule of law, namely that everyone has the right to a fair legal process without becoming a victim of mob justice.

“Local government strategies must be preventive, community-based, situational and collaborative. Combating street crime should involve law enforcement and other security forces routinely and actively, not merely as a formality,” he concluded.

The Ministry of Human Rights condemned the vigilante killing of a resident in Bali. It urged that the perpetrators be prosecuted and that the victim’s family receive protection.

Tabanan Police have named five suspects and questioned 18 witnesses in connection with the mob attack on the suspected chicken thief. Police have pledged to investigate the case transparently.

Deputy Speaker of the House of Representatives Sari Yuliati expressed concern over the death of the suspected chicken thief at the hands of a mob in Bali. She asked the police to investigate thoroughly and pushed for legal education.

Head of the Presidential Staff Office Dudung Abdurachman condemned the vigilante killing in Tabanan, Bali. He requested that the case be thoroughly investigated.

More from 27 July 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/tabanan-vigilantism-case-serves-as-alarm-experts-warn-of-dangers-in-bounty-schemes-for-catching-thieves-1785131431)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/915107/kasus-main-hakim-sendiri-di-tabanan-jadi-alarm-pakar-wanti-wanti-bahaya-sayembara-tangkap-begal), translated from Indonesian
Print