Syekh Ahmad Khatib al-Minangkabawi: Rooted in Tradition, Answering the Times
Every time the era changes, fiqh faces the same question: should change be answered by abandoning tradition, or by returning to the answers of the past? That question is now drawing closer. Artificial intelligence is changing the way humans acquire knowledge. The digital economy is giving rise to new transactions. Medical technology presents questions about life and the human body. Changes in family structures and environmental issues also require religious answers.
Amidst rapid change, we need scholars who are not only capable of finding scriptural evidence but also of understanding reality. For understanding reality without roots in tradition can cause ijtihad to lose its scholarly discipline. Conversely, maintaining tradition without the ability to read change can cause fiqh to lose its capacity to provide answers. It is at this point that Syekh Ahmad Khatib al-Minangkabawi is important to revisit.
Syekh Ahmad Khatib al-Minangkabawi demonstrated that adhering to a school of jurisprudence does not have to mean becoming frozen. Engaging in ijtihad also does not have to mean severing ties with turāth (Islamic intellectual heritage). There is a path that brings the two together: being firmly rooted in tradition while still being able to read reality.
Syekh Ahmad Khatib al-Minangkabawi was born in Minangkabau in 1860 and later settled in Mecca until his death in 1916. He was known as a Shafi’i scholar who held an important position in the environment of Masjid al-Haram. His scholarship was not limited to fiqh. He also mastered farā’iḍ (the science of inheritance distribution), astronomy, arithmetic, mathematics, and a number of other Islamic disciplines. He produced various works in Arabic and Malay and became part of a scholarly network connecting the Haramain with the Nusantara.
However, what is interesting is not only the breadth of his knowledge, but how he used that knowledge when dealing with societal issues. Syekh Ahmad Khatib al-Minangkabawi was a Shafi’i faqīh (expert in fiqh). But his loyalty to the school did not stop him from thinking. His various works and fatwas show attention to concrete societal issues, such as Minangkabau inheritance law, the emergence of paper money, Sufi practices, and other socio-religious matters.
There is a principle to be learned: al-iltizām bi al-madhhab lā yusāwī al-jumūd al-fiqhī—commitment to a school is not identical to jurisprudential rigidity. The school actually provides tools so that ijtihad does not become a baseless free opinion, among others through qiyās (legal analogy), tarjīḥ (choosing the stronger opinion), and the tools of usul fiqh. Therefore, renewal does not always have to begin with abandoning the school. Renewal can be born from a deep mastery of the school. Syekh Ahmad Khatib al-Minangkabawi provides an example that ijtihad can be carried out from within tradition.
One important lesson from Syekh Ahmad Khatib al-Minangkabawi is understanding reality before establishing a ruling. In the matter of Minangkabau inheritance, for example, he dealt with customs and social practices living in society. Custom cannot be sufficiently viewed from theory. It must be understood as a social reality. However, understanding reality does not mean submitting to reality. Fiqh al-wāqi’ (fiqh of reality) does not make social facts the highest judge over law. Reality is understood so that law is not misapplied.
Therefore, the relationship between custom and sharia cannot be sufficiently answered with ‘custom is accepted’ or ‘custom is rejected’. There is a process of understanding reality, identifying the issue jurisprudentially, reading the texts and tradition of the school, then applying the law. The message is simple: do not rush to judge something before understanding what is actually happening.
Another example is when fiqh encountered paper money. In his time, paper money was a new phenomenon different from the gold and silver widely discussed in classical fiqh. A jurist cannot simply ask, ‘Is paper money mentioned in earlier books?’ The more important question is: what is the essence of paper money? How does it function? What gives it value? To what can it be analogised? And what is the relevant ’illat (reason or legal cause)?
This is where qiyās and ta’līl (tracing legal reasons) meet with an understanding of economic change. This lesson is close to our lives. Today money is no longer only in paper form. There is electronic money, digital wallets, cashless transactions, digital assets, and various new economic instruments. A jurist cannot provide a correct answer if he does not understand how these instruments work. This means that before speaking about law, the object must first be understood.
The thought of Syekh Ahmad Khatib al-Minangkabawi can also be read through the perspective of maqāṣid al-syarī’ah (the objectives of sharia). However, we need to be careful not to immediately label him a ‘maqāṣid scholar’ in the contemporary theoretical sense if there is no basis that he explicitly built such a theory. What is more accurate is that in his ijtihad practice there is a maqāṣidī dimension, among others attention to the protection of rights, property, religion, prevention of harm, justice, and public interest.
Maqāṣid must not become a reason to abandon the process of istinbāṭ (deriving or establishing law). Public interest must proceed together with texts, usul fiqh, qiyās, understanding of reality, and consideration of legal consequences. Syekh Ahmad Khatib al-Minangkabawi is more accurately read not as a modernist who abandoned tradition and not as a muqallid (blind follower).
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/syekh-ahmad-khatib-al-minangkabawi-rooted-in-tradition-answering-the-times-1787467842)
Originally published by Republika (https://retizen.republika.co.id/posts/777877/syekh-ahmad-khatib-al-minangkabawi-berakar-tradisi-menjawab-zaman), translated from Indonesian