SUSTAIN: Coal Export Duty a Fair Solution to Plug Budget Deficit
Jakarta, CNBC Indonesia — SUSTAIN Lead Researcher Adila Isfandiari said imposing an export duty on coal is the most rational, fair and urgent fiscal option for closing the gap in the state budget. She said it would be better targeted than forcing tax increases on the retail and household consumption sectors, which could weaken the purchasing power of lower- and middle-income groups and hinder economic growth that remains dependent on consumption.
The Indonesia Sustainable Welfare Foundation (SUSTAIN) said the Finance Ministry’s plan to raise an additional Rp50 trillion in state revenue could readily be met by introducing a coal export duty. Based on the Energy and Mineral Resources Ministry’s Coal Reference Price (HBA) for the first period of November 2026 and a strengthening price trend driven by global geopolitical developments, SUSTAIN estimates that an export duty could generate up to Rp97.40 trillion in additional annual revenue.
The estimate assumes that 65% of Indonesia’s total coal production is allocated to export markets and an exchange rate of Rp18,000 per US dollar.
The policy would target export markets so as not to increase the burden on coal supplied for domestic needs. Adila stressed that seeking state revenue by broadening retail taxes under current economic conditions would be counterproductive to the domestic recovery.
“The government should collect revenue from sectors enjoying a windfall from high coal prices, rather than burdening people’s everyday shopping baskets. A duty on coal exports is the most readily available and fairest fiscal instrument for addressing the budget deficit. The regulatory plan was delayed earlier this year. The current strengthening in coal prices gives the government reason to implement it,” Adila said in a statement on Wednesday (4 November 2026).
SUSTAIN’s calculations show that during 2022–2024 alone, assuming an exchange rate of Rp15,000 per US dollar, there was scope to raise an additional Rp84.5 trillion to Rp353.7 trillion annually through progressive levies on production or exports. With market coal prices currently at around US$140–150 per metric tonne, the additional revenue from a coal export duty would be nearly twice the Rp50 trillion deficit-related requirement the government is seeking to meet.
SUSTAIN therefore urged the government to take two steps. First, it should review plans to broaden taxes on everyday retail goods, which could trigger inflation, reduce household consumption and raise living costs.
“Second, the government should promptly issue regulations for a fair coal export duty with progressive rates, so state revenue rises when commodity prices strengthen. The additional revenue could be allocated to priority spending and social protection,” Adila concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/sustain-coal-export-duty-a-fair-solution-to-plug-budget-deficit-1793793045)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/news/20261104174310-4-782367/sustain-bea-ekspor-batu-bara-solusi-adil-tambal-defisit-anggaran), translated from Indonesian