Supreme Court’s Full Ruling on Cancellation of Gibran’s High School Equivalency Certificate
The Supreme Court (MA) has published the full text of its cassation ruling cancelling the education equivalency certificate issued to Indonesian Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka.
According to the Supreme Court’s ruling directory, the cassation reasoning in a case brought by claimant M Subhan also cited a Constitutional Court (MK) ruling relating to Gibran’s diploma.
Ruling No. 742/K/TUN/2026, dated 30 October 2026, in Subhan’s case against the Director General of Primary and Secondary Education, states: “1. Grants the claimant’s lawsuit in its entirety; declares invalid the Certificate of the Director General of Primary and Secondary Education of the Ministry of Education and Culture of the Republic of Indonesia No. 9149/D.D1/KS/2019, dated 6 August 2019.”
The ruling continues: “3. Orders the defendant to revoke the Certificate of the Director General of Primary and Secondary Education of the Ministry of Education and Culture of the Republic of Indonesia No. 9149/D.D1/KS/2019, dated 6 August 2019.”
The cassation panel was led by Yulius, the Supreme Court’s junior chief justice for state administrative affairs, alongside two fellow judges, Maftuh Effendi and Hari Sugiharto. The ruling was issued on Friday, 30 October.
The Supreme Court ruling overturned Jakarta’s High Administrative Court ruling No. 130/B/2026/PT.TUN.JKT of 12 August 2026, which had upheld Jakarta’s State Administrative Court ruling No. 62/G/2026/PTUN.JKT of 21 May 2026.
In its ruling, the cassation panel also considered the Constitutional Court case concerning Gibran’s diploma, which was brought by Denny Indrayana and others.
The Constitutional Court did not admit Denny Indrayana and his co-claimants’ application. However, in its reasoning, it said that the proceedings had not established evidence of a diploma or equivalent document showing completion of high school or an equivalent level of education.
“The new legal fact in the form of Constitutional Court Decision No. 01/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026, dated 5 October 2026, constitutes a notorious fact which, in its legal reasoning, examined the object of the dispute in question and brought about a change in the legal circumstances. This has implications for the existence of the disputed object, which is now contrary to the existing legal order,” the cassation panel said in its opinion.
On the basis of the Constitutional Court ruling, the Supreme Court considered it legally justified to set aside the respondent’s earlier objection, on the grounds that court rulings form part of the legal system. The Supreme Court therefore examined the substance of the disputed object and applied a concrete systematisation of Constitutional Court Decision No. 01/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026.
“Considering the above, the Supreme Court finds sufficient grounds to grant the cassation application without needing to consider the other grounds for cassation,” the ruling said.
Earlier, before the complete text of the ruling had been published, Minister of Primary and Secondary Education Abdul Mu’ti declined to comment in detail when asked by reporters about the cancellation of Gibran’s education equivalency certificate.
Abdul Mu’ti said his ministry had not yet begun any further legal process in response to the ruling, including on the order concerning the certificate’s destruction.
“There has been no further legal process,” he said after an internal meeting with parliamentary leaders at the parliamentary complex on Friday, 6 November.
Mu’ti also gave a brief response when asked whether the ruling had been discussed internally at his ministry.
“Not yet, not yet,” he said.
The Supreme Court’s cassation ruling reinforces the Constitutional Court’s earlier finding that it had not found documentary evidence of Gibran’s high-school-equivalent graduation in Singapore or Australia.
Gibran had previously responded to the Constitutional Court ruling concerning the controversy over his diploma. He said that if he had not graduated from high school, he would not have been able to attend university.
“If I hadn’t graduated from high school, I wouldn’t have been able to go to university. I completed my bachelor’s degree in Singapore,” said the eldest son of former president Joko Widodo on Wednesday, 7 October.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/supreme-courts-full-ruling-on-cancellation-of-gibrans-high-school-equivalency-certificate-1794307867)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261110160059-12-1425494/putusan-lengkap-ma-soal-pembatalan-suket-penyetaraan-sma-gibran), translated from Indonesian