Supreme Court Uploads Full Ruling on Gibran’s High School Education Certificate
Jakarta (ANTARA) — The Supreme Court (MA) has uploaded the full text of Ruling Number 742 K/TUN/2026 concerning the cassation appeal filed by Subhan over the annulment of the equivalency certificate for Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s high school diploma.
The full ruling was sent to the referring court, and its finalisation was recorded on Tuesday (10 November). In the case, the Directorate-General of Primary and Secondary Education at the Ministry of Education and Culture was named as the defendant or respondent.
The ruling sets out the Supreme Court’s decision and reasoning on Gibran’s high school certificate. Among the key considerations for granting the applicant’s cassation appeal was the annulment of the certificate equivalising Gibran’s high school qualification.
The State Administrative Court therefore has corrective and remedial authority to halt the effects of the administrative violation.
The Supreme Court considered that the administrative violation concerned not merely the interests of political contestants, but also those of the entire Indonesian nation. Accordingly, everyone with the right to vote and stand for election should be entitled to bring a legal challenge.
The panel of Supreme Court justices also took into account a new legal fact: Constitutional Court Ruling Number 01/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026, dated 5 October 2026. The ruling was treated as a notorious fact; its legal reasoning had reviewed the disputed object in this case, changed the legal circumstances and had implications for the object’s continued existence, which the Supreme Court said had become contrary to the existing legal order.
In light of this new legal situation, the Supreme Court held that there were legal grounds to set aside the cassation respondent’s objections—raised in its capacity as the defendant—including that the claim was time-barred and that not all necessary parties had been joined. As court rulings form part of the legal system, substantive justice should take precedence over procedural justice, it said.
The Supreme Court would therefore examine the substance of the disputed object to give concrete effect to the Constitutional Court’s ruling of 5 October 2026, harmonise the legal system and implement the principle of ius curia novit (the court knows the law).
“Accordingly, the objections raised by the cassation respondent, formerly the defendant, have no legal basis,” an excerpt from the Supreme Court ruling said.
The court noted that the disputed certificate had been issued by the cassation respondent, the Director-General of Primary and Secondary Education, on the basis of a certificate of attendance, academic records, an explanation of grades and other documents that did not prove Gibran had completed a particular level of education. They only recorded his attendance at lectures.
“Specifically, no evidence was found showing that Gibran Rakabuming Raka held a diploma or certificate from abroad that could serve as the basis for equivalence with a senior high school, vocational high school or equivalent qualification,” the Supreme Court wrote.
The respondent’s decision to issue the certificate therefore violated the principle of formal due care.
“Based on the considerations above, the Supreme Court finds sufficient grounds to grant the cassation appeal and does not need to consider the other grounds for appeal,” the ruling said.
The Supreme Court said the Jakarta State Administrative High Court’s Ruling Number 130/B/2026/PT.TUN/JKT, dated 12 August 2026, which upheld Jakarta State Administrative Court Ruling Number 62/G/2026/PTUN.JKT, dated 12 May 2026, could not stand and had to be overturned.
The Supreme Court then adjudicated the case itself, granting the cassation appeal filed by H.M. Subhan.
It overturned the Jakarta State Administrative High Court ruling and declared null and void the Directorate-General of Primary and Secondary Education, Ministry of Education and Culture, certificate Number 9149/D.D1/KS/2019, dated 6 August 2019. It ordered the defendant to revoke the certificate.
The ruling was decided at a deliberation meeting on Friday, 30 October 2026, by Prof. Yulius, Chief Justice for State Administrative Matters at the Supreme Court, appointed by the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court to chair the panel, together with Maftuf Effendi and Heri Sugiharto as member justices.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/supreme-court-uploads-full-ruling-on-gibrans-high-school-education-certificate-1794340218)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5845459/ma-unggah-putusan-lengkap-mengenai-suket-pendidikan-sma-gibran), translated from Indonesian