Supreme Court Ruling, the Ethics of Power and the Constitution
The Supreme Court’s ruling concerning Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s education-equivalency certificate has revived a fundamental question in our constitutional life: how does a state governed by the rule of law reconcile legal certainty, the ethics of power and democratic legitimacy?
Public debate is natural, but any assessment must be grounded in verified facts, constitutional procedures and respect for everyone’s right to fair treatment.
On 30 October 2026, in case No. 742 K/TUN/2026, the Supreme Court granted an appeal concerning the education-equivalency certificate, overturned the judex facti ruling and decided the case itself, granting the claimant’s entire claim.
This information appeared in media reports citing the Supreme Court’s Registrar’s Office website. At the time of writing, the full reasoning of the ruling still needs to be read carefully to establish the scope of its orders, the grounds for overturning the earlier decision and its precise legal consequences.
Reading a ruling in full is an intellectual duty before drawing political conclusions.
One point must be made clear from the outset. A dispute over the validity of an administrative document is not the same as proof that its holder has committed a crime or engaged in misconduct.
Any procedural error by a government institution, if established, must be distinguished from the knowledge, actions and personal responsibility of the person who used the document.
Conversely, public office must not be a reason to evade legitimate explanation and scrutiny. These two principles must go hand in hand.
In a state governed by the rule of law, court rulings must be respected and acted upon by the relevant officials in accordance with their terms and the limits of their authority.
The Government and election-management institutions have a responsibility to explain clearly how the document was issued, verified and used.
Such transparency is not a form of punishment; it is essential to enabling the public to distinguish facts, allegations and interpretations.
Ethics Beyond Formalities
This is where MPR Decree No. VI/MPR/2001 on the Ethics of National Life becomes relevant. The decree, which is listed as in force in the MPR’s legal documentation database, regards political and governmental ethics as foundations for clean, open, accountable and honest government.
Government ethics also call on state officials to be prepared to resign if they believe they have violated established principles and values, or are considered unable to fulfil the trust placed in them by society, the nation and the state.
That call carries a strong message: power cannot be defended solely by arguing that an action has not been proven unlawful.
Public officials are also expected to answer questions about propriety, integrity and trust. However, the ethical principle of readiness to resign is not the same as a legal rule automatically requiring dismissal. Ethics guide moral responsibility; the Constitution sets out the grounds and procedures for removing someone from office.
This principle applies universally, not only to one figure or one administration. The standards of honesty and openness expected of a vice-president also apply to ministers, MPs, heads of state institutions and other public officials.
Ethics lose their educative force if they are invoked only against those with different political views.
Ethical responsibility also requires distinguishing between systemic failures, institutional negligence and an individual official’s actions.
If the issue stems from a state agency’s issuance or verification of the document, institutional accountability must be examined transparently.
Conversely, if there is an allegation that someone knew a statement was false and used it nonetheless, that allegation must be tested against evidence that can withstand scrutiny.
This approach prevents ethics from turning into prejudice. Instead, it makes ethics a demand to tell the truth, disclose relevant information and submit to a fair examination.
The Constitution’s Clear Limits
The 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia provides a specific mechanism for removing the president and/or vice-president. Article 7A sets out limited grounds, including certain violations of law, disgraceful conduct, or no longer meeting the requirements to serve as president and/or vice-president.
Article 7B governs the process: the House of Representatives (DPR) submits its opinion subject to strict support requirements; the Constitutional Court examines and decides on that opinion; and, if the process continues, the People’s Consultative Assembly (MPR) makes a decision in accordance with the constitutional quorum and approval thresholds.
Accordingly, the Supreme Court’s ruling in an administrative dispute does not, by itself, remove the vice-president from office. Nor can MPR Decree No. VI/MPR/2001 on ethics be used to create a shortcut that bypasses Articles 7A and 7B.
On the other hand, the existence of strict procedures does not mean that relevant legal facts cannot be examined. The procedures are strict precisely so that serious allegations are tested against evidence and legal reasoning, rather than decided by momentary pressure.
One academic debate worth examining concerns the relationship between an administrative defect at the nomination stage and the phrase ‘no longer meets the requirements’ in Article 7A.
Is the requirement in question a constitutional condition or one set out in legislation? Could another education document legally satisfy the requirement?
What effect does an administrative court ruling have on an election decision that has already become final and on an officeholder who has already taken up the post? These questions require careful examination of the documents and the law, not oversimplification.
The phrase ‘disgraceful conduct’ should not become a catch-all for political disagreement. MPR Decree No. VI/MPR/2001 can provide a values-based framework for discussing the ethics of state officials, but conduct must still be proven and assessed constitutionally by the competent institution before it can qualify as grounds for removal.
Ethical assessment should help clarify the law, not replace evidential standards. This is where the principle of due process of law must be consistently upheld. The DPR’s right to express an opinion is the starting point for constitutional oversight, not a substitute for judicial examination.
The Constitutional Court’s role is to assess whether the DPR’s opinion has been established on the grounds specified by the Constitution. The MPR may decide on removal only after those stages have been completed.
This separation of powers is not merely procedural complexity. It protects public office from being destabilised by short-term political pressure, while ensuring that those in power are not immune from accountability when the evidence and constitutional requirements are genuinely met.
Safeguarding Public Trust
In these circumstances, the national interest is not served by either of two extreme positions: treating the court ruling as meaningless, or assuming that a single administrative ruling has resolved every issue concerning a constitutional office.
Both risk obscuring the division of authority among state institutions.
The available institutional path is to ensure that the full text of the ruling is accessible, seek explanations from the relevant institutions that can be tested, and assess proportionately whether there are further legal implications.
If there is an allegation of personal unlawful conduct, it must be examined through the appropriate channels. If an ethical issue arises, space for public accountability should be opened without disregarding the presumption of innocence or the right to respond.
For the MPR, the case is also a reminder of the importance of putting MPR Decree No. VI/MPR/2001 into practice as a guide to ethical public life, rather than treating it as a text recalled only when controversy arises.
Civic and constitutional education must teach that the law sets limits on authority, while ethics guide how power is exercised. They are not opponents, but two pillars of trust in the republic.
Ultimately, the measure of our democratic maturity is not how quickly we pass judgement in public, but how steadfastly we respect court rulings, demand openness, protect individual rights and abide by constitutional procedures.
Power derives legitimacy through elections, is exercised within the limits of the law and is sustained through integrity. The Supreme Court ruling, the ethics of power and the Constitution should be understood together at this intersection.
Measured transparency can offer a way out of polarisation. The public is entitled to know exactly what the court overturned, to whom its orders are addressed and what administrative action must follow.
At the same time, the public needs an explanation of the differences between administrative disputes, disputes over election results and the constitutional procedures for removing public officials.
Such institutional literacy is important so that debate does not stop at choosing whether to support or oppose a particular figure, but develops into scrutiny grounded in documents and legal reasoning, and respectful of everyone’s rights.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/supreme-court-ruling-the-ethics-of-power-and-the-constitution-1793598685)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/kolom/d-8734421/putusan-ma-etika-kekuasaan-dan-konstitusi), translated from Indonesian