Supreme Court Rejects Prosecutors' Appeal, Sentences in Australian Shooting Case Revised
The Supreme Court has issued a ruling on the cassation appeal in the case of the shooting of Australian citizens Zivan Radmanovic and Sanar Ghanim in Badung Regency, which resulted in Radmanovic’s death in 2025. The court rejected the cassation appeal filed by the prosecutors. Meanwhile, the appeals submitted by two of the defendants, Mevlut Coskun and Paea-I-Middlemore Tupou, were also rejected but with amendments to the sentencing. All three defendants are Australian nationals.
Based on cassation ruling Number 1167 K/PID/2026, decided on Friday, 3 July 2026, the Supreme Court sentenced defendant Mevlut Coskun to 16 years in prison. The second defendant, Paea-I-Middlemore Tupou, was sentenced to 17 years in prison. In a separate ruling, Number 1163 K/PID/2026, the Supreme Court sentenced Darcy Francesco Jenson to 18 years in prison. Darcy was found guilty of violating Article 459 in conjunction with Article 21 paragraph (1) letter b of the National Criminal Code and Article 459 in conjunction with Article 17 paragraph (1) letter b in conjunction with Article 21 paragraph (1) letter b of the National Criminal Code.
With these rulings, the sentences for the three defendants changed from the appellate court’s decision. Darcy, who was previously sentenced to 17 years, now faces 18 years in prison, while Coskun’s sentence was reduced from 18 years to 16 years, and Tupou’s from 18 years to 17 years.
Rahul Singh, the legal counsel for Coskun and Tupou, stated that they respect the Supreme Court’s decision, although they regret the length of the sentences imposed on their clients. He noted that the sentences had been reduced from the 18 years handed down by the High Court. Singh acknowledged that the length of the sentence is entirely the authority of the panel of judges and that the legal advisory team cannot intervene. Nevertheless, his team will still coordinate with their clients to consider the possibility of filing an extraordinary legal remedy in the form of a judicial review.
Despite disappointment over the length of the sentences, Singh assessed that, in substance, the defence’s arguments were accepted by the Supreme Court. He explained that from the outset, the legal advisory team argued there was a difference in criminal qualification between Coskun and Tupou. The cassation ruling showed that Coskun was charged under Article 17 of the National Criminal Code concerning attempt, while Tupou was charged under Article 20 concerning participation. Singh stated this meant they succeeded in convincing the panel that Coskun and Tupou had different criminal qualifications, a point they had raised since the plea, the appeal memorandum, and the cassation memorandum.
The public prosecutor has not yet provided a further response regarding the cassation ruling, stating they are still waiting for the official copy of the decision from the court. The legal counsel for Darcy Francesco Jenson has also not yet provided a response despite being asked for confirmation.
The case originated from the shooting of two Australian citizens at a villa in the Munggu area, Mengwi District, Badung, in the early hours of 14 June 2025. In the incident, one victim, identified as ZR, died from gunshot wounds, while the other victim, SG, survived despite sustaining gunshot injuries. Police subsequently arrested three Australian nationals, Darcy Francesco Jenson, Mevlut Coskun, and Paea-I-Middlemore Tupou, who were charged with playing different roles in the series of shootings. At the Denpasar District Court trial, Darcy was sentenced to 12 years in prison, while Coskun and Tupou were each sentenced to 15 years. Both the prosecutors and the defendants then filed appeals. The Denpasar High Court subsequently increased the sentences for all three, with Darcy receiving 17 years and Coskun and Tupou each receiving 18 years. The case then proceeded to the cassation level at the Supreme Court, which ultimately handed down sentences of 18 years for Darcy, 16 years for Coskun, and 17 years for Tupou.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/supreme-court-rejects-prosecutors-appeal-sentences-in-australian-shooting-case-revised-1783504263)
Originally published by detikBali (https://www.detik.com/bali/hukum-dan-kriminal/d-8565382/ma-tolak-kasasi-jaksa-vonis-3-terdakwa-penembakan-wn-australia-berubah), translated from Indonesian