Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Sufis, Not Traders, Were the Main Actors in Islamising the Archipelago, Says A.H. Johns

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Anthropology
Sufis, Not Traders, Were the Main Actors in Islamising the Archipelago, Says A.H. Johns
Image: Republika

Academic and historian Anthony Hearle Johns, better known as A.H. Johns, argues that Muslim merchants from the Middle East were unlikely to have been the main actors in the spread of Islam in the Indonesian archipelago. According to him, the more dominant role was in fact played by wandering Sufis who were active in preaching across various parts of the islands. Through an adaptive and peaceful missionary approach, these Sufis succeeded in Islamising many inhabitants of the archipelago, at least from the 13th century onwards.

According to Johns, the success of these Sufis in Islamising archipelago society was chiefly because they were able to convey Islamic teachings in an appealing manner. Rather than forcing people to abandon all their old customs, they emphasised that Islam had much in common with existing beliefs and traditions.

The book Jaringan Ulama Timur Tengah dan Kepulauan Nusantara Abad XVII–XVIII (The Network of Middle Eastern Ulama and the Nusantara Archipelago in the 17th–18th Centuries), written by Prof. Azyumardi Azra, explains that, to support his argument, Johns examined various Malay-Indonesian literature and historical sources using a Sufi approach. From this research, he concluded that many local sources link the arrival of Islam in the archipelago to wandering teachers bearing the characteristics of Sufis.

The characteristics of these wandering teachers were as follows:

“They were itinerant (Islamic) preachers who roamed throughout the world they knew, voluntarily living in poverty; they were often associated with trading or craft guilds, in keeping with the Sufi orders they followed; they taught a complex syncretic theosophy, generally well known to Indonesians, which they placed beneath (Islamic teaching), or which was a development of the core dogmas of Islam; they mastered magical arts and possessed healing powers; they were prepared to maintain continuity with the past, and used terms and elements of pre-Islamic culture within an Islamic context.” (A.H. Johns, Sufism as a Category in Indonesian Literature and History)

According to Johns, thanks to the authority, charisma and spiritual abilities they possessed, some of these Sufi teachers managed to marry daughters of the nobility. Through such marriages, their descendants not only inherited noble status but also acquired religious charisma, further strengthening their influence within society.

More from 13 July 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/sufis-not-traders-were-the-main-actors-in-islamising-the-archipelago-says-a-h-johns-1783900271)
Originally published by Republika (https://khazanah.republika.co.id/berita/ti343p430/bukan-pedagang-ah-johns-sebut-para-sufi-aktor-utama-yang-mengislamkan-nusantara), translated from Indonesian
Print