Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Subway project

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Subway project

Unlike Mr. Pienandoro (Letter: April 8, 1997), I am heartened
by the news that Professor Habibie has said that the subway
project will not start this year. Why? Because it indicates that
perhaps he and his colleagues are having second thoughts about
the viability of this project. Some weeks ago you published a
letter of mine in which I advocated an overground rather than an
underground solution to the problem of traffic congestion on the
Blok M-Kota main traffic artery.

There can be no argument that it would be far quicker and far
cheaper to build an overhead electrical railway link than to
embark on an immense costly and time-consuming tunneling project.
After all, it is not just a question of boring one tunnel from
Point A to Point B; there have to be two tunnels to accommodate
trains running North-South and vice versa. There would also have
to be at least half a dozen stations en route for passengers to
get on and off the trains, which would involve a vast amount of
extra excavation, to say nothing of providing the extra tunneling
needed for escalators allowing access to and from the stations.

On the other hand, an overhead system could be constructed
using steel girders or concrete structures, such as are used for
flyovers, of which there are many in Jakarta. Accessing and
exiting would be by stairways, such as those used now for
pedestrian crossings over major traffic lanes.

Surely this is the easiest way to achieve the MRT of Mr.
Pienandoro's dream. The vast sums of money that would be saved
could then be devoted to improving East-West road links from
outlying areas to Central Jakarta, and providing the double-
decker buses to service them. Mr. Pienandoro refers to the tram
fares in London and New York, but trams disappeared from the
streets of those cities decades ago. But he is right in saying
that fares, for the London underground railways (I know nothing
of fares on New York's subway) are not cheap -- but then, neither
are the fares for surface transport (i.e. buses), which, in both
cases, are calculated according to the distance of the journey.
The minimum in London (bus and underground) is 40 pence (Rp
1,600), even for just one short ride.

RB SAWREY-COOKSON

Jakarta

More from 14 April 1997 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/subway-project-1447899208-1546311)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print