Students Tested in Defending Ideas, Debate Becomes Foundation for Service in Tourism Villages
The ability to present ideas critically and defend solutions based on community needs is an essential skill for students before embarking on community service programmes. It is not enough to possess good ideas; students are also required to communicate their concepts coherently to ensure successful field implementation.
This was evident during the final round of Genera-Z Berbakti 2026, a call-for-proposal programme by Bakti BCA that brought together eight student teams from various universities. In the Head-to-Head stage, finalists tested each other’s proposals through argumentation to compete for the chance to implement programmes in four tourism villages under the auspices of Bakti BCA.
One of the panelists, scientist and social entrepreneur Tri Mumpuni, stated that the ability to present ideas systematically is a crucial aspect of designing community empowerment programmes. “Students must be able to present ideas in a coherent, clear, and structured manner so that their ideas are easily understood. After successfully identifying the root problems to be solved, they must be able to formulate solutions critically into real work programmes that can be implemented in the village,” said Tri.
Ghifari, a representative from Padjadjaran University, admitted that the competitive atmosphere of the round motivated him to present his best arguments. “My competitive spirit was certainly piqued, so I wanted to give my best. I am confident and happy to engage in head-to-head sessions to test the strength of our proposals against opposing teams,” he said.
Miki, representing IPB University, assessed that the primary focus should not be on the opponent, but rather on the team’s confidence in their formulated solutions. “I do not want to think too much about who the opponent is. Regarding the content of the arguments, I am very confident that the solution our team has formulated is the best choice and is ready to be applied,” he remarked.
A similar experience was shared by Rifki from UIN Sunan Gunung Djati Bandung, who endeavoured to control his nervousness when performing before the panelists. “Before stepping forward, I told myself to be strong and to show my best, to present what I truly want to present with a calm feeling, and of course, to overcome my fears,” he said.
Meanwhile, Uzi from Gadjah Mada University acknowledged that the debate atmosphere differed from the discussions he usually participates in. “I was selected for this round because I have a habit of debating and expressing opinions in small discussions. However, the atmosphere now is very different,” he noted.
Through this selection process, the four best teams will gain the opportunity to run service programmes in the Terong Creative Tourism Village, Belitung Regency; the Gunung Padang Site Tourism Village, Cianjur Regency; the Patakbanteng Tourism Village, Wonosobo Regency; and the Kakaskasen Dua Tourism Village, Tomohon City.
Hera F. Haryn, Executive Vice President of Corporate Communication and Social Responsibility at BCA, expressed hope that the spirit shown by the finalists would continue when collaborating with local communities. “We hope they can maintain this spirit, particularly when implementing programmes and collaborating with the communities in the tourism villages supported by Bakti BCA,” said Hera.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/students-tested-in-defending-ideas-debate-becomes-foundation-for-service-in-tourism-villages-1783342382)
Originally published by Republika (https://news.republika.co.id/berita/thr611522/mahasiswa-diuji-pertahankan-gagasan-debat-jadi-bekal-pengabdian-di-desa-wisata), translated from Indonesian