Students and the Temptation of Transactional Politics: A Sociological Reflection
Recently, social media has been stirred by a circulating video that has left many students dismayed. In the video, the Chairperson of the Student Executive Board (BEM) of the Faculty of Law at Bung Karno University (UBK) admitted to receiving a sum of money following a political meeting. This admission has triggered various reactions, ranging from disappointment to public outrage.
According to the admission in the video, the funds received were reported to be only about 20 per cent disbursed, with individuals receiving 2 million rupiah each, intended for various operational needs such as command vehicles (mokom), distribution to seniors, and even friends in other faculties. Regardless of the veracity of all the information circulating, this case is interesting to read as a broader social phenomenon rather than merely an individual issue.
For some, this case might be viewed merely as a lapse in judgement by a campus activist. However, viewed through a sociological lens, this event invites us to ask further: has there been a cultural shift in student movements that makes transactional practices increasingly acceptable?
Historically, student movements have been known for their strength in solidarity. Students take to the streets, voice aspirations, and criticise policies not for material gain, but due to a shared awareness of fighting for the public interest. In the view of Émile Durkheim, solidarity is the glue that keeps a group united through shared values and goals. This solidarity has been the source of the moral strength of student movements for decades.
Problems arise when material interests enter spaces previously built on the basis of idealism. When money becomes the primary consideration, the orientation of actions can slowly shift. Students no longer move due to shared ideas, but because of interests that need to be fulfilled. Consequently, the bonds of solidarity previously built on trust and shared values begin to erode.
Durkheim also explains that every group possesses norms and social sanctions that function to maintain the behaviour of its members. In student organisations, shame, criticism from peers, and commitment to struggle values should serve as social controls to prevent deviation. However, when morally questionable practices begin to be considered commonplace, the function of social control weakens. Something once considered improper can slowly be accepted as normal.
This case is also interesting when read through the thought of Pierre Bourdieu. According to Bourdieu, an individual possesses not only economic capital in the form of money, but also social and symbolic capital. Holding the position of BEM Chairperson, organisational networks, and the identity of a student activist constitute social and symbolic capital that generates trust from the community. This capital is what makes the student voice often considered to have more moral legitimacy than other groups.
The problem arises when this social and symbolic capital is exchanged for economic gain. In Bourdieu’s terms, this process can be called the conversion of capital. The public trust built through organisational activities then risks being transformed into a tool for obtaining specific advantages. What is lost is not just the reputation of an individual, but also the legitimacy of the student movement as a whole.
Such practices do not arise in a vacuum. They grow within an organisational culture that is becoming accustomed to informal lobbying, power relations, and non-transparent resource distribution. In political sociology, such a condition is known as patronage, which is a relationship built on the exchange of benefits and loyalty. When patronage enters student organisations, support is no longer provided based on shared ideas or visions of struggle, but because of the benefits obtained from that relationship.
This is where the greatest irony of campus life lies. The campus should be a space for learning the values of democracy, integrity, and social responsibility. However, when practices resembling transactional politics begin to be considered normal, student organisations risk transforming into miniatures of the very practical politics they often criticise.
Therefore, this widely discussed case should not stop at the debate over who is right and who is wrong. More importantly, it should serve as a subject for collective reflection. Students need to ask themselves again: is the campus organisation still a space for the struggle of ideas, or is it slowly turning into an arena for the exchange of interests?
If idealism is the greatest capital held by students, then preserving it is a shared responsibility. For when public trust is lost, it is not just the name of one organisation or one individual that collapses, but the legitimacy of the student movement itself.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/students-and-the-temptation-of-transactional-politics-a-sociological-reflection-1782471186)
Originally published by Republika (https://retizen.republika.co.id/posts/766801/mahasiswa-dan-godaan-politik-transaksional-sebuah-refleksi-sosiologis), translated from Indonesian