Striving for effective higher education
Striving for effective higher education
By Nirwan Idrus
The following article explores ways to improve higher
education. It is the first of two parts.
JAKARTA (JP): Millions of U.S. dollars have poured into
education in Indonesia, and quite a few million of it into higher
education. All of these have been loans or grants from overseas.
These have taken various forms, from direct infrastructural
development to teacher training.
The real question is: Have these dollars made any difference
to Indonesian education in general and higher education in
particular?
The truthful answer is: Nobody really knows. Why not? Well,
projects need to have regular and disciplined monitoring,
corrective actions and quality control, if not assurance. There
is no doubt that a number of these projects would vehemently
claim to have all these. There is also no doubt that the overseas
agencies financing them will vehemently support such a claim.
However, many universities and polytechnics around the country
are littered with equipment which is unserviceable and new
buildings which are in some dangerous ways inadequate for the
purposes they are built.
The quality of teaching, learning and research at public
universities and polytechnics is also questionable, despite the
many lecturers who were trained overseas, some for quite a few
years.
Can we therefore claim that all the money that was poured in
to Indonesian education in general and higher education in
particular made an impact?
The new government under President Abdurrahman Wahid appears
to be addressing some of these issues. Admittedly, a 32-year-old
problem cannot be resolved overnight or even in a year or two.
But let us hope that this is not used as an excuse for not
revolutionizing the education system in Indonesia.
Even the then minister of education and culture, Juwono
Sudarsono, in an interview with The Jakarta Post published on
Aug. 6, 1999, used that very word in describing what is needed in
Indonesia vis-a-vis education and higher education. Going by Pak
Juwono's wisdom and integrity, some of the criteria that must
have gained him his current ministerial position as defense
minister, only the second civilian to ever hold that post, his
words must be taken seriously.
In previous articles in this paper, this writer advocated a
number of potential avenues toward some solution. These include
separating the appointment of lecturers at public universities
from being a public service appointment; devolution all the way
to the students; making recruitment of university and polytechnic
staff as transparent as possible; advertising the positions of
vice chancellors, deans and heads of departments; instituting
performance measures and appraisals of all university and
polytechnic staff; considering the use of educational technology
and for the government to accelerate autonomizing or empowering
programs.
A caution was given then that the empowered would also need
some training. One cannot expect somebody who was trained to
carry out instructions without question for so long to suddenly
and without appropriate training be able to make acceptable
decisions.
Government Regulation no. 61/1999 went some way to accommodate
the latter, but it left out the most important level of
devolution, which is from the government to the institution. That
is, that the vice chancellor of a university or director of a
polytechnic is still appointed by the government, a practice that
has been entrenched in the system since the country's
independence. In line with Gus Dur's proclamation that his
government signals the second independence, this small amendment
to the regulation should be immediately made.
In order to make all the above work there is an underlying
requirement of the people involved. And that is for them to
change the paradigm, to embrace the new ways of doing things in
higher education. Such a paradigm was declared by the Ministry of
Education and Culture in December 1997.
The writer is an international higher education consultant
living in Jakarta. This article is his personal opinion.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/striving-for-effective-higher-education-1447893297-1296409)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post