Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Stop the violence

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Stop the violence

As we enter the last five days of the election campaign, it is
disturbing to think just how ugly the violence and disruptions
may get. The current trend is very discouraging. Some people have
even suggested halting the campaign altogether, fearing the
possibility of massive riots.

In spite of assurances by the military that it has everything
under control, campaigning in Jakarta and many other cities
across Indonesia has become so violent that people are beginning
to question whether it is worth carrying on at all, given the
cost in lives and the massive disruptions to people's lives, and
whether anything can be done at all to avert more violence and
disruptions.

The General Elections Institute had recorded 60 deaths from
campaign-related activities by Friday. Most died in traffic
accidents while taking part in campaign convoys. The official
figure does not say how many died or were injured in clashes
between rival political parties contesting the election.

Some analysts are already proclaiming the 1997 election
campaign as the most violent in the history of the New Order
government. The increasing violence to some extent reflects the
quality of the general election, and therefore of our democracy.
It is difficult for anyone to seriously claim that, in terms of
democracy, this election will be better than the previous one in
1992. What few significant political messages there have been
during the campaign have been drowned out by the amount of
violence and disruptions. The discussions, the method most
encouraged by the government in place of political rallies, have
been so dull that supporters prefer to roam the streets.

While there is a dearth of political substance in this year's
campaign, ample theories have been put forward to explain why it
has been so violent. As experts debate these theories, it is
worthy to note that the violence has taken place in spite of
tighter campaign rules. Before the campaign began, the government
introduced new regulations which the minority parties said were
too restrictive for them to be able to effectively convey their
political messages. Yet, violence occurred nevertheless.
Introducing more restrictive campaign rules is therefore not the
answer. This is a matter to ponder when the authorities prepare
the rules for the next election.

Of more urgent concern is the remaining five campaigning days.
Can anything be done to contain the violence?

Some of the outbursts we have seen were spontaneous and the
behavior of supporters, some people would argue, was therefore
beyond the control of the political groups. This may be true to
some extent, but if we accept this argument entirely, it says a
lot about the effectiveness of the leaders of the political
groups.

Surely Harmoko and Ismail Hasan Metareum, the chairman of
Golkar and the United Development Party (PPP) respectively,
command strong influence and could prevail over their supporters.

Megawati Soekarnoputri, who, in spite of her exclusion from
the election, clearly commands the loyal support of many members
of the Indonesian Democratic Party (PDI). She made a statement
before the campaign began, calling on her supporters to stay away
from the campaign. Her statement was effective initially, but
many of her supporters have since been campaigning for PPP,
contributing to the clashes and disruptions.

If these three leaders were to issue a statement in the
remaining few days of the campaigning period, if they were to
call on their supporters for restraint, then they could at least
minimize the likelihood of the campaign getting even uglier than
it already is. A lot more is at stake now than simply winning a
few more votes in the May 29 election. These leaders can distance
themselves, and thereby their supporters, from the violence and
the massive disruptions. They can call the shots.

More from 19 May 1997 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/stop-the-violence-1447893297-1541199)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print