Stop the violence
Stop the violence
The attack on the office of the United Nations Mission in East
Timor (UNAMET) in Dili on Wednesday, while deplorable, came as no
surprise to those who have closely followed events unfolding in
the territory these past few days. Many had predicted that
violence would erupt in East Timor during or after Monday's
ballot. All elements for an explosive eruption had existed before
Monday so much so that even the United Nations Security Council
had decided to strengthen UNAMET's presence after the ballot,
dubbed Phase II of the operation.
That UNAMET should be singled out for the attack by the pro-
Indonesia militia did not come entirely as a surprise either. The
world body has been widely criticized by die-hard pro-Indonesia
supporters, as well as their masters in Jakarta, for being biased
in favor of independence in East Timor. Journalists, both
Indonesians and foreigners, have also been at the receiving end
of the violent attacks, again, following accusations of their
perceived lack of impartiality.
The attacks against UNAMET and journalists were not totally
unprovoked, but where that provocation came from is debatable.
There has been a quiet but concerted campaign to turn public
opinion, in East Timor and in Jakarta, against the United Nations
and against the local and foreign media. Such a campaign may have
the desired immediate impact of intimidating UN officials and
journalists having to work in a very difficult territory. But in
the medium and long run, this approach would be
counterproductive, for it put the Indonesian government in an
even more difficult position. This campaign against UNAMET and
the media could be seen as a desperate attempt to shift the
blame, for any violence that would erupt, away from Indonesian
government hands.
UNAMET comprises people of diverse nationalities and
backgrounds that it would be difficult to conclude that as an
institution it has a hidden agenda in East Timor. Certain
individuals in UNAMET may have their preferences in the conflict,
and may have allowed their prejudices to influence their work,
but it is wrong to attribute this bias as a UN policy. Likewise,
most journalists covering the East Timor conflict are there to
record and report the truth. Some may have shown their bias in
their reports, but it is again wrong to generalize that every
journalist, or the media they represent, have a hidden agenda, or
that they are part of an international conspiracy against
Indonesia and its supporters in East Timor.
UNAMET and the media however can assist in lessening the
sentiments against them. UNAMET must treat seriously accusations
that some of its officials had behaved improperly, announce the
result of its investigations, and reprimand the culprits. The
media could also refrain from making controversial reports. Some,
for example, have erroneously if not prematurely reported that
the massive voters' turnout on Monday signified victory for the
proindependence camp. Such a prediction served no real purpose
other than antagonizing pro-Indonesia supporters. It would be
better to postpone such unnecessary remarks and let the current
United Nations ballot process run its full course.
The job, and responsibility, of maintaining security in East
Timor ultimately are in the hands of the Indonesian government as
stipulated in the agreement Jakarta signed with the United
Nations in May. This means that the Indonesian police and
military must simply do a better job than they have done so far
in safeguarding the lives of not only East Timorese, but also the
thousands of UN officials and hundreds of journalists currently
working in the territory.
Given the situation in East Timor, especially the hostility of
the proindependence camp against the Indonesian military, this is
a huge undertaking for Indonesia. Before Wednesday, the
government had completely ruled out the suggestion of bringing in
a UN peacekeeping force to East Timor, citing it as a violation
of its sovereignty. On Thursday, a change of heart was detected
with Minister/State Secretary Muladi suggesting that the option
should be considered in keeping with the developments in East
Timor. Where people's lives and the nation's reputation are at
stake, Indonesia must be prepared to swallow some of its national
pride and let in an international peacekeeping force into East
Timor, especially if it can no longer do its job alone.
More from 3 September 1999 โ
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/stop-the-violence-1447893297-1414446)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post