Stepping Down for the Sake of the Law
By Ahmadie Thaha, Columnist
REPUBLIKA.CO.ID — In the middle of the sea, a ship’s captain sometimes makes a decision that passengers find hard to understand. He steps down from the bridge, not because the vessel is certain to sink, but so that the entire crew can work to save the ship without the shadow of debate about himself hanging over them.
If the ship ultimately survives, everyone will be grateful. If it turns out the ship is indeed leaking, the cause can be sought later. But in the world of seafaring, keeping the ship afloat is often more important than keeping a captain standing on the bridge.
That metaphor came to mind when I read the news that Febrie Adriansyah had resigned from his post as Deputy Attorney General for Special Crimes (Jampidsus). He assumed the position on 10 January 2022, having served five months earlier (29 July 2021) as Head of the Jakarta High Prosecutor’s Office (Kajati DKI).
Febrie’s resignation was announced by the Head of the Attorney General’s Office Legal Information Centre in the early hours of Saturday, with a very careful choice of words: “accepted the resignation”, “safeguarding integrity”, “objectivity” and “neutrality”.
That choice of words is itself a message. In institutional communication, diction often speaks louder than lengthy sentences.
Over the past several days, public attention has been focused on the search of Febrie’s private residence in Sentul, the seizure of cash and gold bars by National Police investigators, and the swirl of speculation filling social media. Now, in the midst of an ongoing investigation, he has chosen to relinquish his post.
What is striking is that the Attorney General’s Office did not announce that Febrie had been dismissed. Its official statement instead read that the Attorney General had accepted his resignation. In the language of state administration, that choice of words is no small matter.
It indicates that, to this day, there has been no official statement naming Febrie a suspect or declaring that he has committed a criminal act. Legally, the presumption of innocence still applies.
Even more interesting is the reason given by the Attorney General’s Office. The resignation was described as a form of commitment to safeguarding the integrity, objectivity and neutrality of the law enforcement process while the police investigation proceeds.
That sentence deserves to be underlined. What is being protected, according to the Attorney General’s Office, is not in the first instance a person’s name, but the honour of the legal process itself. For if the process is trusted, the final outcome will be more readily accepted, whoever is ultimately found to be right or wrong.
In a state governed by law, justice must not only be done, it must also be seen to be done, free of any shadow of conflict of interest.
The Attorney General’s Office’s stance is also noteworthy in that it chose not to engage with the substance of the case. There is no statement that Febrie is guilty. Nor is there any objection to the investigation being conducted by the National Police. What was conveyed instead was an appeal to respect the legal process and continue to uphold the presumption of innocence.
A day before resigning, Febrie himself appeared before journalists. Strikingly, he did not begin by defending himself, but spoke about the institution he led.
Nearly all of the opening of his press conference consisted of affirmations that the Round Building (Gedung Bundar) continues to function, that inquiries, investigations, prosecutions and the execution of evidentiary items remain in accordance with procedure, and that the quality of every case must be testable, both materially and formally, before the courts.
Indeed, he said, that very morning he had received instructions to expedite the completion of case files for a number of matters in which the detention periods were limited and which had drawn public attention.
In other words, the first message he wished to convey was not “I”, but “the Attorney General’s Office continues to work”. Those words now feel like a pause before a major decision.
Only after speaking about the institution did Febrie address the matter of himself. He confirmed that the house in Sentul searched by investigators was indeed his private residence, and asserted that its ownership history could be traced back to the very beginning.
However, regarding the cash, gold bars and various items found in the house, he stated that those items did not belong to him.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/stepping-down-for-the-sake-of-the-law-1783831857)
Originally published by Republika (https://analisis.republika.co.id/berita/ti1oa0415/mundur-demi-hukum), translated from Indonesian