Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

State Schools Should Not Be a Burden on Families

| Source: Antara (Indonesian) Translated from Indonesian | Social Policy
State Schools Should Not Be a Burden on Families
Image: Antara (Indonesian)

Surabaya (ANTARA) – There is a widespread practice in schools that needs to be addressed. Education requires funding, but the costs of running state schools must not simply be passed on to parents.

The issue has resurfaced in Surabaya, East Java. On 20 October 2026, the city administration reiterated its ban on charges of any kind at state primary and junior secondary schools, including for workbooks, uniforms, books and facility maintenance. The policy is due to take effect in November 2026.

Ten days later, reports emerged of an alleged request for a Rp300,000 contribution from parents at SDN Manukan Wetan IV for a farewell event and batik clothing for teachers.

These two developments show that shifting costs to families concerns not only ceremonial events, but also learning needs and schools’ operating costs.

The issue should not end with a reprimand for the headteacher. It is an opportunity to reform education funding, clarify the government’s responsibilities and ensure that every child has equal access to learning.

The right to education

The ban on charges is not merely an administrative policy. It stems from children’s right to free basic education, which should be the state’s responsibility.

Article 34(2) of Law No. 20 of 2003 on the National Education System mandates that the central and regional governments ensure the provision of compulsory basic education without fees.

This principle was reinforced by Constitutional Court Decision No. 3/PUU-XXII/2024, delivered on 27 May 2025. The Court affirmed that the guarantee covers basic education institutions run by both the government and the community.

More specifically, Article 9(1) of Minister of Education and Culture Regulation No. 44 of 2012 prohibits basic education institutions run by the central and regional governments from charging education fees.

The regulation also distinguishes compulsory, binding charges from contributions, which must be voluntary, non-coercive and not set at a particular amount or time.

That distinction matters because the term used does not necessarily reflect what is happening in practice. A request for money may be called a shared contribution or participation, but if an amount and deadline are set and parents feel obliged to pay, it has the characteristics of a charge.

Minister of Education and Culture Regulation No. 75 of 2016 on School Committees also stipulates that fundraising by committees must take the form of assistance and/or contributions, not charges. Article 12(b) expressly prohibits school committees, whether acting individually or collectively, from charging students or their parents or guardians.

Agreement at a parents’ meeting does not automatically make a collection a contribution. Consent must be given without pressure or consequences for children whose families do not pay.

The alleged Rp300,000 contribution at SDN Manukan Wetan IV highlights the importance of this principle. Families should not be required to pay for batik clothing for teachers or a farewell event.

For families on limited incomes, additional expenses can compromise other necessities. Free education means more than the absence of school fees; it also means protection from additional costs with no clear basis or accountability.

School funding

The ban on charges must be accompanied by the government’s capacity to meet schools’ needs. It is unfair to prohibit schools from collecting money from parents without providing adequate funding for learning facilities and their maintenance. Every school needs realistic planning.

Funding instruments are available through the state budget (APBN), regional budgets (APBD) and the School Operational Assistance programme (BOSP). In 2026, BOSP is governed by Minister of Primary and Secondary Education Regulation No. 8 of 2026, which has been in force since 6 February 2026. The funds support schools’ non-personnel operating costs.

The 2026 BOSP technical guidelines allow funding for needs often cited as reasons for charging families. Library development and the procurement of books for primary and secondary education receive a minimum allocation of 10 per cent of the funding ceiling. Facility maintenance may be funded up to a maximum of 20 per cent, in accordance with the rules.

The 2026 BOSP guidelines also list the purchase of workbooks as an eligible book expenditure that schools can plan for. This does not justify requiring pupils to buy workbooks; rather, it provides a mechanism for schools to procure them using their budgets. Teachers can also prepare their own exercises, provided they follow the curriculum and their workload is taken into account.

However, BOSP funds have restrictions and are not intended to cover every investment need or medium- and large-scale building repairs. Needs that cannot be met through BOSP must be identified for funding through the APBD or other government sources, in line with the relevant authorities’ responsibilities. The limits of one budget line must not be used to shift responsibility to parents.

Surabaya has room to strengthen these efforts. In the revised 2026 regional budget, agreed with the Regional House of Representatives (DPRD) on 10 September 2026, regional spending rose by Rp151.63 billion, from Rp12.73 trillion to Rp12.88 trillion. Education was among the priorities for budget adjustments.

The city administration has also redirected the unspent portion of a scholarship allocation originally planned for 24,000 recipients. An assessment found that only about 13,000 recipients were needed, so the remaining funds were reassigned to other education needs.

Planning must be based on data. The condition of classrooms, toilets, desks and chairs, books, learning equipment and the needs of pupils with disabilities should be regularly assessed. The Education Office must conduct on-site inspections to ensure budgets address actual needs.

Shared oversight

The next challenge is ensuring that the ban on charges does not remain merely a mayoral instruction, but becomes standard practice in every school. Surabaya’s experience shows that public complaint channels can reveal problems missed by routine monitoring.

A report through the Lapor Cak Eri hotline prompted action on the alleged charges at SDN Manukan Wetan IV, and the Education Office subsequently followed up.

Reports that pupils at SDN Rangka 6 were made to wash carpets and prayer garments and paint the school should also be evaluated. Keeping the school clean can teach responsibility and mutual cooperation, but activities must be age-appropriate and safe, and must not turn pupils into substitutes for school maintenance staff.

Oversight must be transparent and continuous. Schools should disclose their activity plans and use of funds. Parents are entitled to know where funding comes from, how BOSP is allocated and which needs remain unmet.

The Education Office should inspect the sale of books, procurement of uniforms, farewell events, facility maintenance and the way schools communicate with parents.

Complaint channels must be accessible, protect the confidentiality of those reporting concerns and ensure that children do not suffer because their parents have raised criticism. Headteachers should prevent disagreements from developing into social pressure or bullying.

School farewells can be restored to their purpose as a way to recognise pupils’ learning journeys. A simple celebration at school is more meaningful than an event that entails substantial expense.

Graduation is not a competition in extravagance, still less a reason to add to families’ costs. Parents’ involvement need not take the form of money. Supporting children’s learning, communicating with teachers and taking an interest in their development are also valuable contributions.

The success of the policy should not be measured only by a decline in schools collecting contributions. It should also be judged by the quality of learning, the condition of facilities, teachers’ professionalism and disparities in educational opportunity. Surabaya’s policy could become a model if supported by adequate funding, consistent oversight and transparent budgets.

Education is a long-term investment in Indonesia’s Golden 2045 vision. The ban on charges is therefore not simply an effort to reduce parents’ expenses, but a means of safeguarding fairness in access to education.

State schools should be places where children grow with equal opportunities, not places where learning needs turn into bills for families. Children’s futures should be shaped by the quality of education and the opportunities provided by the state, not by how much money their parents have.

More from 1 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/state-schools-should-not-be-a-burden-on-families-1793501476)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5824403/sekolah-negeri-bukan-beban-keluarga), translated from Indonesian
Print