Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Standardised Cigarette Packaging to Cause Fiscal Haemorrhage and Mass Layoffs

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Economy
Standardised Cigarette Packaging to Cause Fiscal Haemorrhage and Mass Layoffs
Image: CNBC Indonesia

Jakarta, CNBC Indonesia – The Indonesian House of Representatives (DPR RI) has highlighted the increasingly worrying state of the domestic tobacco and cigarette industry following pressure from various draft regulations. One of the main concerns is the draft Health Ministerial Regulation (RPMK) governing plain packaging requirements for tobacco products.

According to Mukhamad Misbakhun, Chairman of Commission XI of the DPR RI, the domino effect of this draft policy would primarily hit employment and state revenue. A fiscal haemorrhage would occur as an explosion of the black market drains tens of trillions of rupiah from the state budget (APBN) targets.

Misbakhun stressed that the regulation has exceeded the Health Ministry’s mandate and must be handled carefully, given its impact on a very large economic chain. He noted that the tobacco industry’s fiscal contribution currently reaches Rp 221.7 trillion, with some 6 million workers spanning the upstream to downstream supply chain.

“There will be 6 million unemployed, as previously mentioned. There will be structural poverty among domestic farmers,” Misbakhun said at the CNBC Indonesia Coffee Morning themed ‘A Deep Dive into the Plain Packaging Regulation for Tobacco Products’ on Thursday (9/7/2026).

He also said the tobacco industry is treated most unfairly, including the prohibition on openly advertising cigarettes.

“The industry treated most unfairly is the tobacco industry, partly because its products cannot be promoted,” said Misbakhun.

Misbakhun added that the tobacco and cigarette industry currently has to compete against illegal cigarette products sold at far cheaper prices. Like other industries, the domestic tobacco industry must also compete with imported cigarettes.

“If packaging is made plain, the market can shift. Lower-income consumers stop thinking and end up choosing cheap, illegal cigarettes. There will be shocks; eventually no one will want to invest in the cigarette sector, and the worst hit will be tobacco farmers, who will lose their livelihoods,” Misbakhun explained.

If this happens, communities dependent on the industry — around 6 million people — would be severely affected.

“There are 6 million people involved in the tobacco sector, from farming to trade, from upstream to downstream,” he said.

Therefore, the government is urged to exercise caution in determining policy, so that communities dependent on the tobacco industry can continue to make a living.

“These are the risks we must think through together. Don’t let a single interest — the desire of anti-tobacco groups to impose their will — dictate outcomes. What could happen? The birth of a black market in the industry, and the potential state losses could be enormous,” he said.

“I have never denied that cigarettes have a health aspect. But we must also consider citizens’ constitutional rights, the state’s constitutional rights, farmers we must protect, and state revenue we must safeguard — and give them the opportunity to support their families, pay for schooling, and so on,” Misbakhun added.

He therefore emphasised the importance of cross-ministerial harmonisation for a comprehensive Regulatory Impact Assessment, to balance the urgency of the nation’s fiscal health with industry protection. This includes realising inclusive dialogue and meaningful participation, so that no regulation may be enacted at the expense of ordinary people’s livelihoods.

Meanwhile, Decky Haedar Ulum, Director of Institutional Affairs and Industrial Relations Dispute Prevention at the Manpower Ministry, expressed hope that future policies concerning the cigarette industry would find a point of equilibrium.

This is necessary so that policies adopted do not backfire, especially if their impact extends beyond workers to many layers of society.

“Going forward, if the policy is implemented, it will need a roadmap and stages for upskilling workers’ capabilities, and that is not easy,” said Decky.

Amid restrictive regulatory challenges, the tobacco industry (IHT) faces not only the plain packaging discourse but also various other proposed restrictive policies, including tar and nicotine content limits and a ban on additives in tobacco products. The accumulation of these policies is considered to risk eroding the industry’s competitiveness, threatening the sustainability of the business ecosystem, and reducing excise revenues that depend on this sector.

More from 13 July 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/standardised-cigarette-packaging-to-cause-fiscal-haemorrhage-and-mass-layoffs-1783914678)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/news/20260713101645-4-750290/penyeragaman-kemasan-rokok-sebabkan-pendarahan-fiskal-dan-phk-massal), translated from Indonesian
Print