Stability, growth, reform: WB
Stability, growth, reform: WB
World Bank, Jakarta
Indonesia experienced another year of modest growth amidst a
hesitant global recovery, and a deteriorating investment climate.
Significant progress was made in democratization, macroeconomic
stability and fiscal sustainability, but growth did not pick up
and progress in poverty reduction stalled. Growth remained
largely consumption driven, as investors increasingly felt the
pinch of a cooling investment climate and a weak legal system.
The Bali bombing threatened to sink hopes for higher growth,
but that risk has been mitigated thanks to the remarkable resolve
the government has shown in the aftermath of the tragedy. The
swift action on security, a fiscal stimulus, and acceleration of
structural reforms are likely to limit the damage of the attack.
That same resolve should now be used to pursue the reforms that
can accelerate growth; create jobs, and further reduce poverty.
The government must move now, before the elections distract
politicians, or tempt them into taking popular, but harmful
measures such as those recently taken in trade. The government
should stay the course on macroeconomic policies, maintain fiscal
sustainability, revamp the investment climate and rebuild the
broken institutions in the legal system.
Since the beginning of the Megawati administration, financial
markets have been generally supportive of macroeconomic
stability. Political stability, sound macroeconomic policies, and
structural reforms strengthened the rupiah and stock market, and
allowed interest rates to fall without re-igniting inflation.
Credit agencies also upgraded Indonesia's debt, although it
remains well below investment grade. Although the Bali bombing is
still clouding Indonesia's economic outlook, financial markets
returned to pre-attack levels within a month. Much of this was
due to the government's quick actions fin security and the
acceleration of reforms soon after the attack.
Stronger financial markets and macroeconomic performance did
not translate into higher growth. The modest 3.4 percent growth
expected for 2002 has, as before, been largely fueled by
consumption, supported by large formal sector wage increases and
credit from a recovering banking system. A slower recovery of the
world economy in the aftermath of Sept. 11 and a stronger rupiah
limited trade's contribution to growth.
Investment failed to recover, in part because enterprises are
still deeply in debt, but more importantly because the investment
climate is deteriorating. Red tape and corruption in key
government services, sharp increases in legal minimum wages and
uncertainty in labor regulations, excessive taxation by some
Local governments, a looming power crisis, and a Weak legal
system make Indonesia an unattractive place to invest in. Added
security concerns after Bali will not help either, and some long-
time investors Have already called it quits. For 2003 the
government expects GDP to grow by 4 percent, one percent less
than before the Bali bombing. This is at the high end of most
forecasts, but at the bottom of the league of Asia's former
crisis countries.
Poverty reduction showed mixed results in this modest growth
environment. Poverty has come down strongly from its crisis peaks
of 27 percent of the population in 1999 to 16 percent in February
2002, because of recovering wages and relatively modest food
price increases resulting from a stronger Rupiah.
But poverty rose in the year up to February 2002, largely due
to a spike in food prices during the floods in early 2002, which
affected large parts of the country. With so many Indonesians
close to the poverty line, small price changes in key food items
can have large impacts on poverty. The slowdown in growth as a
result of the Bali bombing may keep as much as 1 million people
more in poverty than without the attack. Indonesia did less well
in improving non-income measures of poverty? such as health and
education outcomes.
The relatively successful decentralization, which makes local
governments responsible for most of health and education could
improve this if poor regions receive a high enough share of the
resources transferred by the center. Modest growth was not enough
to make ardent in unemployment. Official numbers show
unemployment of some 8.4 percent of the labor force, but over
three times as many are underemployed, and some 2-2.5 million
people enter the labor market each year. Many of them fail to
find jobs.
Despite modest growth, the government has managed an
impressive fiscal consolidation. Even with the post-Bali fiscal
stimulus taken into account, the deficit for 2003 will be lower
than that of 2002, continuing the downward tread of the last
three years. Lower deficits, a stronger Rupiah, a higher nominal
GDP and debt buy-backs also pushed down government debt to GDP.
The ratio is likely to hit 72 percent by the end of 2002, over 20
percentage points down from 2 years ago.
The reduction in the budget deficit was primarily due to a
reduction in fuel subsidies, which declined from over 5 percent
of GDP in 2000 to well below 1 percent in 2003. They are now
largely restricted to those for kerosene, the fuel of the poor.
The government has reduced the impact of price increases for fuel
and utilities on the poor. In addition to limiting price
increases for kerosene and low capacity power supply, it has
funded a compensation program that targets low income Indonesians
with extra rice distribution, education grants, and health cards.
Nevertheless, the price increases remain controversial.
The budget deficit also fell because central government
development spending declined over the last few years, but much
of the tab was picked up by regional governments, which spent
more. For 2003, the approved budget aims for a deficit of 1.8
percent of GDP, half a percentage point higher than originally
planned because of the Bali stimulus. This deficit would require
$6.3 billion in foreign financing, of which, some $2.4-2.8
billion would have to come from aid disbursements of CGI members.
The above article is taken from the executive summary of World
Bank Brief of the Consultative Group on Indonesia (CGI). The
group will meet in Bali next week.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/stability-growth-reform-wb-1447893297-1347493)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post