SPKS Warns of Risk of Farmers Leaving RSPO Certification
JAKARTA – The Indonesian Palm Oil Farmers Union (SPKS) has criticised the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO) certification and credit-trading system, saying it has yet to deliver adequate economic benefits to independent oil palm smallholders.
Despite growth in the number of farmers and the area of certified plantations, problems including credit uptake, low group revenues and limited access to physical supply chains remain unresolved.
SPKS says the RSPO should not continue to expand certification without first ensuring that the market can absorb the products and credits farmers generate. Certification must not be reduced to meeting standards and increasing the number of certified members while farmers bear the costs, obligations and risks without certainty of economic returns.
The SPKS 2026 study, released on its official website on 2 November 2026, illustrates the problem. From 2023 to 2024, the number of farmer groups selling RSPO credits rose by 36 per cent, from 85 to 116. However, the volume of credits sold increased by only 9 per cent, from 261,792 tonnes to 284,188 tonnes.
Over the same period, total group revenues fell by 7 per cent, from US$7 million to US$6.5 million. Average revenue per credit-selling group dropped by about a third, from US$82,400 to US$56,000, while average credit sales per group declined by around 20 per cent, from approximately 3,080 tonnes to about 2,450 tonnes.
SPKS chairman Sabarudin said the figures pointed to a fundamental problem in the RSPO certification market. “The RSPO cannot keep celebrating growth in the number of farmers and the area of certified plantations if, at the same time, farmer groups’ incomes are falling. Farmers have spent money, effort and time meeting RSPO standards. But when the credits they generate are not adequately taken up, they bear the risks of a system that is supposed to benefit them. This shows that certification growth has not been matched by market responsibility,” he said.
The issue is also reflected in the RSPO’s 2024 Annual Communications of Progress (ACOP) data. Around 68 per cent of independent smallholders’ sales, equivalent to 1.3 million tonnes of fresh fruit bunches (FFB), still rely on the credit mechanism rather than the physical sale of certified products.
Meanwhile, a study commissioned by the RSPO found that 29 of the 84 farmer groups surveyed in Indonesia did not have access to an RSPO-certified palm oil mill in their area.
For SPKS, this shows that the RSPO certification system has not succeeded in connecting some farmers to certified physical supply chains. Many still sell FFB as conventional produce, while receiving certification benefits separately through credit sales under the Book and Claim model.
Under this model, companies can buy credits as part of their sustainability commitments without purchasing physical products from the farmers who generated them. SPKS questioned how far this mechanism truly benefits farmers if it is not accompanied by certainty that credits will be taken up and access to physical markets.
Farmers have met the standards, but the link between their certification and real demand from companies remains weak. Alongside market uptake, SPKS also highlighted a lack of transparency in credit prices and trading. RSPO data received by SPKS showed a price of about US$7.5 per credit.
“There must not be information imbalances in credit trading that work against farmers. Farmers have the right to know how much buyers pay for credits, what intermediaries receive and how much net income reaches the group. The RSPO must ensure credit trading is transparent and not allow farmers to be in a weak position in transactions,” Sabarudin added.
Risk of farmers leaving certification
SPKS also warned of another risk: farmers dropping out of certification. Maintaining a certificate requires recurring costs and work, including audits, management of the group’s internal control system and compliance with farm standards. If group revenues fall and credit-sale proceeds do not match these burdens, farmers have less reason to maintain their certificates.
Groups that choose not to renew their certificates will lose the investments made over the years by farmers, support organisations and the RSPO.
SPKS said headline certification growth could obscure this problem. Adding new groups cannot be considered a success if previously certified groups do not remain in the system. SPKS is therefore asking the RSPO to track and publish data on farmer groups whose certificates have been suspended, revoked or not renewed, including the reasons.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/spks-warns-of-risk-of-farmers-leaving-rspo-certification-1793631097)
Originally published by Republika (https://ekonomi.republika.co.id/berita/tnvlno451/spks-peringatkan-risiko-petani-keluar-dari-sertifikasi-rspo), translated from Indonesian