Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Sovereign Waqf Assets: Protecting Endowments, Not Nationalising Them

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Economy
Sovereign Waqf Assets: Protecting Endowments, Not Nationalising Them
Image: Republika

Waqf possesses a unique characteristic not fully found in other philanthropic instruments. It transforms private wealth into long-term social capital, preserving the principal asset while channelling its benefits to society in a sustainable manner. In the history of Islamic civilisation, waqf has supported education, healthcare, places of worship, water services, trade, and the protection of vulnerable groups. Today’s challenge is not proving the potential of waqf, but building a system capable of converting that potential into tangible, measurable, and intergenerational benefits.

It is within this context that the idea of a sovereign waqf asset deserves development. Although not yet an explicit nomenclature in Indonesia’s positive waqf law, the term can be used as an academic and policy construct. It should not be interpreted as the nationalisation of waqf assets by the state. Rather, a sovereign waqf asset is more accurately defined as an asset or portfolio of strategic significance to society, strongly protected, managed professionally and independently, and directed towards generating public benefit on a national or even global scale.

The word ‘sovereign’ in this concept must be placed on the sovereignty of the trust, not the sovereignty of the bureaucracy. Waqf assets must be sovereign from takeover by personal interests, political pressure, management conflicts, investor interests, or short-term fiscal needs. The principal of a waqf must not be treated as free wealth that can be used to cover deficits, pay debts, serve as general collateral, or be transferred with changes in power. The state has an interest in protecting and developing the waqf ecosystem, but that protection does not grant the right to control the benefits of the waqf beyond its original deed.

This distinction is crucial because a sovereign waqf asset is not the same as a sovereign asset or a sovereign wealth fund. State assets fall under a public ownership regime and can be used according to the government’s mandate. Sovereign wealth funds are also managed to achieve investment, development, stabilisation, or intergenerational goals set by the state. Conversely, waqf assets are wealth bound by a specific purpose. The manager does not have the freedom to change the beneficiaries simply because another programme is deemed more attractive. Investment professionalism can be learned from large investment institutions, but their ownership philosophy cannot be copied.

From an economic perspective, the primary strength of a sovereign waqf asset lies in its ability to form perpetual social capital. Wealth that previously provided limited benefits to its owner can be transformed into productive assets for education, health, research, food security, social housing, business financing, environmental conservation, and community empowerment. With proper management, the benefits do not cease when the initial funds are spent, but are continuously generated through rental income, investment returns, dividends, royalties, business profits, or increased service capacity.

However, preserving the principal of a waqf is not enough by merely maintaining its nominal value. Cash waqf that does not grow will lose its purchasing power due to inflation. Land left without legal certainty faces the risk of disputes. Buildings that are not maintained remain recorded as assets, but their economic capacity continuously declines. Therefore, protecting the principal must encompass real value, legality, physical condition, productivity, and the sustainability of benefits. A manager who distributes all income without setting aside maintenance costs and risk reserves is effectively consuming the rights of future generations.

Furthermore, the productivity of waqf should not be narrowly defined as financial profit. Waqf hospitals, schools, libraries, places of worship, water sources, and conservation areas may not yield high commercial returns. Yet, these assets can generate far greater social value. The performance of each asset must be assessed according to its mandate. Commercial properties can be measured by income and occupancy rates, while healthcare facilities should be judged on quality, affordability, and the number of beneficiaries. True productivity is the asset’s ability to generate the best benefits in accordance with its deed, not the ability to maximise profit at the expense of the beneficiaries.

Consequently, a strategic waqf portfolio must be built in a balanced manner. Some assets can be used to provide direct services, others to generate income, and still others to maintain liquidity and portfolio resilience. Over-reliance on land creates capital development problems. Concentration in financial instruments can distance waqf from the real sector. Investing in large projects without feasibility studies increases the risk of failure. Diversification is not merely about spreading funds, but about assembling a combination of assets that matches the time horizon, needs of the beneficiaries, risk tolerance, and objectives of the waqf.

The sharpest criticism of the sovereign waqf asset concept is the potential for covert nationalisation. In the name of efficiency, community assets could be centralised under a single manager, donor deeds could be standardised, and local trustees could lose their authority. This risk must be acknowledged, not denied. National integration should be applied to standards, data, supervision, competency, and investment infrastructure, not through the forced transfer of all assets. Every asset must retain its clear legal identity, bookkeeping, designated purpose, and beneficiaries. Another risk is mission drift, where social objectives shift because the manager becomes too focused on asset growth. The larger the portfolio, the greater the temptation to measure success solely by investment returns.

More from 4 August 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/sovereign-waqf-assets-protecting-endowments-not-nationalising-them-1785819143)
Originally published by Republika (https://analisis.republika.co.id/berita/tj87n1368/sovereign-waqf-asset-bukan-nasionalisasi-wakaf), translated from Indonesian
Print