Southeast Asia's role in eradicating terrorism
Southeast Asia's role in eradicating terrorism
Jusuf Wanandi, Member, Board of Trustees, Centre for Strategic
and International Studies (CSIS), Jakarta
There are two more problems that have to be faced by the
region. Protests and anti-U.S. sentiment among people in East
Asia, particularly before and during the Iraq War, could be
worrying if they persist due to problems that may arise in the
aftermath of the war.
First, all governments in East Asia do appreciate having good
relations with the U.S. as part of their national interest. While
they oppose the war for basic principles such as the right to use
force and out of humanitarian concerns, they make sure that
popular opposition has been peaceful, restrained and balanced.
In Muslim countries such as Indonesia, the war has not been
considered an Islamic solidarity issue; Saddam Hussein has never
been considered a Muslim leader while he has abused his own
people and neighboring countries.
Being more pragmatic and less obsessed with international
norms and institutions, they should be able to adjust to U.S.
policies rather quickly. However, it would be wise for the U.S.
to see this trend and make efforts to overcome them.
One effort critical to Muslims everywhere is the move on the
resolution of the Israel-Palestine conflict, and to ensure the
success of the peace roadmap. There is no other problem which
Muslims identify with more than the Israel-Palestine conflict.
The other challenge for East Asia is facing the future
strategic adjustment of U.S. military presence, based on reforms
in U.S. military positions and capabilities due to technological
advances and experience gained from the Iraq War.
The U.S. has to be careful in its planning and consultation is
needed to ensure that these strategic adjustments do not
destabilize East Asia. Most East Asians are conservative and pro-
status quo, so dramatic changes will tend to be destabilizing to
them. Discussion on the South Korean adjustment has already
started, and if the nuclear standoff with the North Koreans can
be solved , then there is no need for maintaining the U.S. Army
in Korea or having land troops in Okinawa in the future. Instead,
naval bases in Japan will become more important.
Traditionally, the real big question for the long term outlook
of Asian-Pacific security is future relations between the U.S.
and China. This question, at least for the short and medium term,
has been somewhat subdued because of enormous changes in China's
economic and social development, the threat of international or
global terrorism and the danger of nuclear proliferation in the
Korean Peninsula.
China's phenomenal economic growth and peaceful change of
leadership have given the country the necessary self-confidence
to see its national interest in a stable relationship with the
U.S. in East Asia. For the U.S., the intensive economic relations
have become an important part of the relationship in general.
China has been cooperative from the beginning due to threats
from terrorism originating from Central Asia. Intelligence
cooperation has been reestablished between the U.S. and China.
Even more important is the role that China is playing on the
denuclearization of the Korean Peninsula, which they both see as
an urgent matter.
Further, the war in Iraq has given China an additional reason
not to challenge the U.S. unnecessarily in the Pacific.
The main problem between the U.S. and China is the relations
and tension between China and Taiwan. The issue has become less
explosive due to the integration of Taiwan's economy into
China's, with more than US$100 billion worth of investments, and
up to 2 million Taiwanese living on the mainland.
Exchanges between political leaders are also happening more
frequently, so the peaceful absorption of Taiwan into China is
happening slowly but surely. Only one uncertainty could upset the
balance -- Taiwan's volatile domestic politics. In this respect,
China can do something by being more flexible toward Taiwan's
political needs.
Japanese-U.S. relations have had both a positive and negative
impact on the region's strategic development. Negative, because
Japan's economic and political malaise as well as its
deflationary problems, have obscured Japan's role in the region
in strategic terms, although it is still the world's second
largest economy and will remain so for some time to come.
There is a lot of pessimism about Japan both inside and
outside the country, resulting in her world-class economic and
technological capabilities being easily overlooked. Apart from a
psychological problem, it is also a problem of its political
leadership. Japan's inward-looking culture is also not helping.
The U.S. seems to be not paying enough attention to this very
debilitating factor in the credibility of its relationship to the
region. On the positive side, Japan is slowly but surely becoming
a normal country, thanks in part to the Korean Peninsula crisis.
Although some of her neighbors are still unhappy with those
developments, Japan has become more acceptable to East Asia. And
it is a better proposition that Japan, in the context of the U.S.
alliance, will gradually play a more normal role, than being
forced to do so alone because of sudden pressure.
The main problem facing East Asia is the nonproliferation
issue, both on the Korean Peninsula and the impact on East Asia
from South Asia's nonproliferation problem between India and
Pakistan.
The most urgent and dangerous security problem is nuclear
proliferation in the Korean Peninsula, given that North Korea's
regime is not living up to the Agreed Framework of 1994.
While one can argue about the inclusion of the regime in the
U.S.' "axis of evil", they have indeed not lived up to the
agreement and have conducted other nuclear production activities
through an uranium enrichment process.
Initially all the neighbors hoped for a peaceful and
diplomatic solution for the denuclearization of North Korea for
their own valid reasons. But after the U.S. could concentrate on
the issue after the Iraq War, there has been a greater
convergence of opinions.
China is more willing to pressure North Korea, and the visit
of South Korea's President Roh Moo Hyun to Washington has greatly
helped convince him of the need to use the stick in the form of
imposing possible sanctions, rather than the carrot. Japan has
always had more reason to be willing to put the pressure on North
Korea since it feels more threatened. But at this stage no
military action will be entertained by Washington.
A more concerted effort from the country's important neighbors
to cooperate with the U.S. can be expected and multilateral and
bilateral approaches are going to be applied.
The region and the international community, including the
Association of Southeast Asian Nations, should assist by
providing political support to these efforts by the U.S. and the
immediate neighbors of Korea in Northeast Asia.
Another nonproliferation issue that will have an impact on
East Asia's security is the standoff between the two nuclear
powers in South Asia, namely India and Pakistan. The impact of a
conflict between the two would be felt by East Asia but the
region does not have a credible instrument to do much about the
standoff. The worry would be greater if Pakistan's nuclear
weapons fell into the hands of extremists. That is why the role
of the U.S. to stabilize tensions in the subcontinent has been
well-appreciated by East Asia.
The article is a condensed version of the writer's
presentation at the Asian Security Conference in Singapore, held
from May 30 to June 1. The event was organized by the London-
based International Institute for Strategic Studies.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/southeast-asias-role-in-eradicating-terrorism-1447893297-1328206)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post