Some Mataram Primary Pupils in Years 4 and 5 Still Unable to Read, Promotion System Under Scrutiny
Some Year 4 and 5 primary school pupils in Mataram, West Nusa Tenggara, have been found not to have mastered basic reading skills. The Mataram Education Department suspects this is linked to a previous system in which pupils tended to be promoted automatically, without sufficient consideration of whether they had met learning targets.
Mataram Education Department head Yusuf said the findings had drawn the authorities’ attention. The city government has also recorded ten schools as having low literacy and numeracy levels, according to education report cards.
“They are classified as ten high-performing schools and ten education units with low literacy and numeracy. We are encouraging those education units whose report cards show low results,” Yusuf said when contacted on Tuesday (20 October 2026).
Yusuf said pupils who cannot read are not found only in Years 1 to 3; some in Years 4 and 5 have yet to master the basic skill.
“There are some in the middle years, in Years 4 and 5. In the past, the system was to keep promoting them,” he said.
In response to the findings, Yusuf has urged schools to provide additional support and dedicated tutoring for pupils who are falling behind. Teachers have also been asked to give them extra attention so they can develop their reading and numeracy skills.
Yusuf also supports tighter criteria for promotion to the next year. In his view, pupils who have not met academic standards or character-development targets should not be pushed through to the next year.
“Children who cannot read and write or count properly should not be promoted if they have not met the promotion criteria,” he said.
“I strongly agree, for the sake of the quality of education we provide to children and to improve education standards. Critical issues must be given proper emphasis,” he added.
Earlier, Toni Toharudin, head of the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education’s Basic and Secondary Education Policy Agency, responded to proposals that pupils should no longer be promoted automatically from 2027. He said the mechanisms for strengthening the policy were still being drafted.
“At present, the strengthening of these mechanisms is still being prepared,” Toni said, as quoted previously by detikEdu.
Toni said discussions and preparations for the policy were targeted for completion in 2027. The ministry was also making room for dialogue with stakeholders about how it would be implemented.
“Throughout the process, we continue to make room for dialogue with stakeholders and take into account the readiness of schools, teachers, pupils and parents,” he added.
Toni explained that the proposal to strengthen promotion mechanisms was initially recommended by the National Education Council. He stressed that the government already had a promotion system in place, which remained in force.
“We should clarify that mechanisms for deciding whether a pupil advances or repeats a year already exist and remain in effect,” he said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/some-mataram-primary-pupils-in-years-4-and-5-still-unable-to-read-promotion-system-under-scrutiny-1792489857)
Originally published by detikBali (https://www.detik.com/bali/nusra/d-8715846/siswa-kelas-5-sd-di-mataram-belum-bisa-baca-sistem-naik-kelas-disorot), translated from Indonesian