SOE Restructuring is Not Just About Efficiency, But Governance and Safeguarding National Interests
The restructuring of State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs) is not merely a matter of reducing costs, simplifying organisational structures, or merging several companies into a single business group. Behind every restructuring lies business interests, national interests, asset management, business sustainability, and, in certain sectors, a direct connection to public services.
Therefore, restructuring should not be evaluated solely by the scale of efficiency achieved, but also by whether the process is conducted under legitimate authority, through good governance, and while maintaining national interests. This has become increasingly relevant following the enactment of Law Number 16 of 2025 regarding the Fourth Amendment to Law Number 19 of 2003 concerning SOEs, which altered various provisions regarding the institutional management of SOEs, the separation of supervisory and operational functions, asset management, and SOE restructuring.
Thus, restructuring needs to be understood not just as a corporate action, but as a policy that carries consequences for the national interest.
The legal framework for SOEs provides restructuring objectives that are far broader than mere efficiency. Article 72 of the SOE Law, as amended, states that restructuring aims to improve performance, add company value, undertake rehabilitation, or facilitate the rescue of SOEs.
This means that efficiency is only one instrument to achieve a larger goal: creating healthier and more valuable companies. Reducing operational costs, simplifying organisations, or merging business units may indeed result in short-term savings, but they do not necessarily improve competitiveness or corporate sustainability if not supported by adequate analysis.
Consequently, the success of restructuring should be measured by its ability to sustainably enhance the performance and value of SOEs, rather than just the magnitude of savings achieved.
Legality is also a foundation that cannot be ignored. Restructuring can take various forms, ranging from financial, organisational, and operational restructuring to changes in the relationships between SOEs. Each form of restructuring has a different basis of authority and mechanism. Article 72 of the SOE Law distinguishes restructuring for performance improvement, value addition, rehabilitation, and rescue. For restructuring aimed at rehabilitation, the decision rests with the Head of the SOE Management Agency (BP BUMN), taking into account the principles of benefit and/or cost, whereas restructuring for rescue is determined by the SOE Rescue Committee, considering the principle of benefit.
These provisions demonstrate that restructuring is not an action that can be taken based solely on practical considerations; there must be a clear link between the restructuring objectives, the decision-making authority, and the mechanisms used. Legality in this context is not merely an administrative formality, but a guarantee that decisions arise from authority explicitly granted by law.
In addition to legality, good corporate governance must be an integral part of the entire restructuring process, from the planning stage to implementation. The SOE Law establishes Good Corporate Governance as a fundamental principle of SOE management. Furthermore, Article 62A of the amended SOE Law emphasises that SOE assets must be managed based on the principles of good corporate governance. Asset management is carried out by the Board of Directors, respecting the limits of authority regulated by legislation, the articles of association, and decisions from the General Meeting of Shareholders (RUPS) or the Head of the BP BUMN.
This provision is particularly crucial when restructuring involves the transfer of assets, business mergers, partnerships, guarantees, or other forms of transactions that impact company wealth. In such situations, asset valuation, transaction objectives, approval mechanisms, the parties benefiting, and the basis for decision-making must all be accountable. Restructuring must not only result in a simpler organisational structure while leaving behind issues in asset management and governance.
National interests must remain a primary consideration in every SOE restructuring. Unlike private companies that are solely profit-oriented, SOEs have broader objectives as regulated by the SOE Law, namely supporting national economic development, providing revenue for the state, generating profit, and, in certain conditions, providing public benefits. Therefore, the success of restructuring cannot be judged solely on profit and loss statements. A business unit may not generate significant commercial profit but may hold a strategic function for public service or national economic resilience. Similarly, assets that appear unproductive may not necessarily be transferable without considering their strategic function. Restructuring is indeed necessary when a company’s structure is no longer effective, but such changes must be able to reconcile business interests with national interests so that the original purpose of the SOE’s establishment is preserved.
Asset management is one of the most sensitive aspects of restructuring. Restructuring may involve transfers, partnerships, guarantees, consolidation, or changes in the control of certain assets. Article 62A of the SOE Law, as amended by Law Number 16 of 2025, allows SOE assets to be transferred, pledged, and/or partnered with third parties, while still requiring the application of good corporate governance principles. This provision also provides exceptions for certain assets that belong to production branches vital to the state and control essential public needs.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/soe-restructuring-is-not-just-about-efficiency-but-governance-and-safeguarding-national-interests-1788436981)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/kolom/d-8647149/restrukturisasi-bumn-bukan-cuma-soal-efisiensi-tapi-tata-kelola-jaga-kepentingan-negara), translated from Indonesian