Socialist versus Neoliberal: Which Delivers Welfare Faster?
In debates over Indonesia’s economic policy, the term ‘neoliberal’ is often used pejoratively. Privatisation, trade liberalisation, subsidy cuts and an expanded role for the private sector are frequently criticised as forms of neoliberalism that favour capital owners over the wider public. The term is even used as a political label to reject policies without first assessing their economic benefits and effects.
Under President Prabowo Subianto’s administration, economic discourse emphasising the state’s role, economic sovereignty and social justice has gained prominence. An approach that could be described as socialistic is increasingly visible in public debate, particularly in discussions of government policies that expand state involvement in economic activity. This shift in emphasis is notable: it reflects a move from market mechanisms towards state intervention as a tool for development, although in practice the two approaches continue to be used together.
President Prabowo has openly criticised neoliberal thinking. In a speech at the St Petersburg International Economic Forum on 20 June 2025, he criticised the dominance of the neoliberal free-market philosophy over several decades, linking it to unequal distribution of the benefits of economic growth. He proposed a middle path combining elements of capitalism and socialism: allowing room for creativity, innovation and private initiative while retaining the government’s responsibility to tackle poverty and protect the public.
This orientation is reflected in policies such as the Free Nutritious Meals programme, the strengthening of village cooperatives, downstream processing of natural resources, and an expanded state role in economic development. Although these policies have different characteristics and mechanisms, they all illustrate the importance of government in the national development strategy. However, a socialistic economic approach should be distinguished from socialism as an ideology. The Prabowo administration officially uses the concept of Pancasila Economics; it has not declared that Indonesia follows a socialist system.
This shift in economic discourse raises a more fundamental question than the choice of ideology alone. Is a socialistic approach better able to accelerate improvements in public welfare than a neoliberal one? Will a larger state role produce higher and more evenly distributed welfare in a shorter time? Or can freer market mechanisms speed up welfare gains through investment, innovation, productivity and rising incomes? These questions matter because economic debates often become trapped in a state-versus-market dichotomy, as if the two were mutually exclusive. The more fundamental development challenge is not to decide which ideology is best, but to identify the policies that can deliver the greatest welfare gains in the shortest time with the resources available, without undermining economic sustainability.
Same goal, different mechanisms
Conceptually, both socialistic and neoliberal approaches can aim to improve social welfare, although they differ in their views of the most effective means of achieving it. The neoliberal approach emphasises markets, competition, private ownership and freedom to conduct business as drivers of economic activity. The prospect of profit is expected to encourage individuals and companies to invest, innovate and raise productivity, while competition directs resources towards activities that generate greater added value. In this framework, economic growth and rising incomes are the main routes to welfare.
Government is still needed to provide a legal framework, protect property rights, maintain macroeconomic stability and ensure fair competition, but direct involvement in production and resource allocation tends to be limited. The neoliberal approach therefore treats market mechanisms as the main instrument for creating prosperity, although it does not necessarily rule out government intervention.
By contrast, a socialistic approach places greater emphasis on collective responsibility and the state’s role in ensuring that the benefits of development are widely shared. Welfare is not left entirely to individuals’ ability to earn income through the market; it is also considered a social responsibility to be fulfilled through public policy. The government provides education and healthcare, social protection and basic infrastructure, and redistributes resources to reduce inequality and expand economic opportunities.
Such intervention is not necessarily intended to replace the market. It can instead correct market failures and ensure that people’s basic needs are met. In a broader sense, this approach treats the distribution of welfare as a central development objective, rather than merely a by-product of economic growth. Its success, however, depends heavily on the government’s ability to fund and deliver its social responsibilities effectively.
The differences between the two approaches become clearer when economic growth is distinguished from public welfare. Growth in gross domestic product (GDP) per capita can increase people’s ability to meet their needs, but does not automatically show how the gains are distributed. A country may record strong growth while most additional income accrues to a particular group. Conversely, a country with more moderate growth may achieve broader improvements in quality of life if education, healthcare and social protection are delivered effectively.
In his 1999 work, Amartya Sen’s capability approach explains that development is not simply about higher incomes, but also about expanding people’s abilities and freedoms to live lives they value. From this perspective, welfare cannot be measured solely by national income; it also depends on how effectively an economic system converts available resources into a better quality of life. The approach that produces the fastest economic growth, therefore, may not be the one that improves social welfare most quickly.
The experience of advanced economies and the strength of the public sector
The Nordic countries—Sweden, Denmark, Norway and Finland—offer useful lessons about the relationship between government, markets and public welfare. They have extensive welfare systems, strong education and healthcare services, and relatively large government roles in the economy. At the same time, they retain market mechanisms, private ownership, business competition, open trade and productive business sectors. They are therefore better described as social democratic welfare states than as socialist countries in the sense of state ownership of all means of production.
Their experience shows that extensive social services need not conflict with productivity and economic competitiveness. High-quality education and healthcare can strengthen workforce productivity, while social protection can reduce household economic risks and widen people’s opportunities to take part in productive activity.
One important characteristic of these countries is the substantial share of economic resources managed through the public sector. This can be seen in government expenditure as a proportion of GDP, using the general government expenditure indicator, which covers spending at all levels of government. According to the OECD Economic Surveys: Indonesia 2024, Indonesian government expenditure in 2023 was about 16.7 per cent of GDP. OECD data for the same period put expenditure at about 48.6 per cent of GDP in Sweden, 50.1 per cent in Denmark, 53.0 per cent in Finland and 63.2 per cent in Norway.
Government expenditure in these Nordic countries was therefore roughly three to almost four times Indonesia’s share of GDP. The difference illustrates the fiscal resources they use to provide public services and social protection and to carry out other government functions. However, the share of government expenditure is also affected by income levels, demographic structures, social security system design and the characteristics of each economy. It cannot be treated directly as a measure of government quality or efficiency.
A comparison with the United States, often associated with a more liberal, market-oriented economic model, is also instructive. OECD data show that US government expenditure in 2023 was around 31.6 per cent of GDP, nearly twice Indonesia’s share. This demonstrates that even in a more market-oriented economy, the government manages significant fiscal resources.
The size of government’s fiscal role is not, by itself, enough to classify a country as socialistic or neoliberal, since government spending also includes defence, administration, interest payments on public debt and other obligations. Nevertheless, the figures show that fiscal capacity is an important dimension of a state’s ability to perform economic and social functions. For Indonesia, the comparison highlights how limited its fiscal space is, even relative to an advanced economy that relies more heavily on market mechanisms.
Indonesia’s relatively small public sector is closely linked to the government’s ability to raise revenue. The OECD (2024) recorded Indonesian government revenue in 2023 at around 15 per cent of GDP, far below the levels in advanced economies with extensive welfare systems. This limited revenue-raising capacity constrains the government’s ability to expand education, healthcare, social protection and infrastructure without increasing pressure on the deficit or public debt.
The challenge of building a welfare state in Indonesia is therefore not just a matter of economic orientation; it also depends on the state’s ability to mobilise fiscal resources sustainably. Yet raising more revenue must take account of the effects on investment, business activity, tax compliance and household purchasing power. Strengthening fiscal capacity should therefore involve broadening the tax base, improving compliance and tax administration, and growing productive economic activity—not merely raising tax rates.
Government expenditure alone cannot be equated with the strength of the public sector, let alone its efficiency. The state also shapes the economy through state-owned enterprises (SOEs), public ownership of assets, regulation, and its ability to direct investment and economic activity. Indonesia, for example, has SOEs that play important roles in energy, banking, transport and infrastructure. The state’s influence over economic activity may therefore be greater than its relatively small share of government expenditure in GDP suggests.
On the other hand, large state-owned assets and extensive commercial activity do not automatically produce higher welfare. SOE performance should still be assessed in terms of productivity, capital-use efficiency, service quality, economic benefits and the fiscal risks they create. The strength of the public sector should therefore be understood as a combination of fiscal and institutional capacity, regulatory capability, and the effective management of state assets and economic activity.
Public-sector efficiency as a determining factor
The experience of advanced economies with strong social welfare systems shows that their success depends not only on the scale of government spending, but also on public institutions’ ability to manage resources effectively. Nordic countries generally have professional public administrations, relatively effective tax systems, accountable governance and high-quality public services. These conditions enable their governments to manage large budgets while maintaining public trust in state institutions.
Even so, high-quality public services are not necessarily the same as high technical efficiency, since efficiency must be assessed by comparing service outcomes with the resources used. The experience of these countries nevertheless shows that institutional capacity is important to sustaining a welfare state. The success of a socialistic economic model cannot be explained solely by the size of government’s role, but also by its ability to perform that role productively.
In public economics, efficiency concerns how well resources used (inputs) are converted into services (outputs) and development benefits (outcomes). Two countries may allocate the same share of GDP to education but achieve different learning outcomes because of differences in governance, teachers’ capabilities, oversight systems and the accuracy of budget allocation. Similarly, high health spending does not necessarily lead to better public health if services are poorly organised or administrative costs are too high.
Afonso, Schuknecht and Tanzi (2005) found differences in public-sector efficiency across countries, showing that the scale of government spending cannot be used as the sole measure of public-policy success. In development, what matters is not only how much is spent, but also how much welfare improves for each unit of resources used. The more efficient the public sector, the greater the government’s potential to improve welfare without a proportionate increase in the fiscal burden.
Public-sector efficiency becomes even more important when the government adopts an economic approach that expands the state’s social responsibilities. The provision of education, healthcare, social protection, subsidies and infrastructure investment requires sustainable financing and an effective delivery system.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/socialist-versus-neoliberal-which-delivers-welfare-faster-1792641062)
Originally published by unand.ac.id (https://www.unand.ac.id/berita/kepakaran/2144-ekonomi-neoliberal-sosialistik-kebijakan.html), translated from Indonesian