Social Immunity and Indonesia’s Demographic Dividend at Stake
Jakarta (ANTARA) – A nation does not always weaken as a result of attacks from outside. Sometimes its decline begins within, when the generation expected to support its future starts to doubt whether the promised future is truly available to them.
The wave of demonstrations in France illustrates this problem. Protests believed to have begun with student concerns developed into demonstrations addressing more fundamental issues: the high cost of living, rising energy prices, wage inequality, difficulty securing housing, and declining confidence in public services. Similar concerns have emerged in several European countries, although their triggers and political dynamics may differ.
The important point is not simply the number of demonstrators involved, but the social message behind the protests: growing numbers of young people feel that education and hard work can no longer guarantee a better life today, let alone in the future. This should be a warning to be examined more deeply than as merely a disturbance to public order.
In biology, the body has an immune system that detects and controls threats. When pathogens enter the body, its defences activate the necessary response and regulate it so that healthy tissue is not damaged. A healthy body is not one free of threats, but one able to recognise them, respond proportionately and restore balance. Society has a similar mechanism. Criticism, demonstrations and the expression of public demands signal that problems require attention. Students questioning the quality of education are asking about investment in the future. Workers demanding fair wages are voicing the economic pressures in their lives, while young people unable to afford homes face barriers to the independent lives they aspire to build.
When these signals are heard and acted upon, tensions can be managed through dialogue and policy. But if complaints recur without a response or a resolution seen as adequate, dissatisfaction can build into a crisis of trust. This is where the analogy of social inflammation becomes relevant. In the body, inflammation is a necessary defence mechanism and a natural response. However, prolonged inflammation can damage the very tissue it is meant to protect. Likewise, criticism and demonstrations are legitimate parts of democratic life, but violence, looting, arson and damage to public facilities can turn grievances into actions that harm society itself.
The right to criticise must therefore be clearly distinguished from acts of violence. Criticism must not be treated as a threat simply because it makes those in power uncomfortable. Conversely, economic or political grievances cannot justify destruction or anarchy.
A more fundamental mistake would be to view demonstrations solely as a security issue. Law enforcement is necessary, but a security-focused approach without addressing the causes is like reducing a fever without looking for the source of infection. The symptoms may subside, but the illness remains and may flare up again.
Economic pressures may be an important factor in the unease among Europe’s younger generation. Rising food, energy and everyday costs, combined with difficulty accessing housing and job insecurity, are narrowing young people’s scope to build independent lives. Economic problems can ultimately become psychological and social problems.
The question is no longer simply how to meet monthly expenses, but why one should work hard when a decent life is becoming increasingly difficult to attain. If that question becomes a shared conviction, what is at risk is not only economic stability, but also confidence in institutions and public policy.
Indonesia should take this warning seriously. The demographic dividend is often presented as a key asset for progress. But a large working-age population does not automatically produce high-quality growth. This potential becomes an advantage only when supported by quality education, adequate healthcare, relevant skills, and ample decent employment opportunities. Without that support, the demographic dividend can turn into demographic pressure: the working-age population grows, but opportunities to progress do not keep pace. Competition for work intensifies, social mobility narrows and anxiety about the future spreads.
Indonesia need not wait for mass demonstrations to recognise these signs. Unemployment, precarious informal work, skills gaps, housing affordability, mental health and low information literacy are among the indicators that warrant attention. These problems do not always erupt into social unrest, but they can gradually erode young people’s optimism.
The state needs a social immune system that works before dissatisfaction develops into a crisis. Education must be the first line of defence. Schools and universities must do more than produce graduates with certificates. They should develop people who can think critically, understand science, use digital technology, communicate, collaborate and uphold integrity.
The development of artificial intelligence underscores this need. Education based solely on rote learning risks falling behind as technology changes the way people work. The ability to analyse problems, create, make ethical decisions and adapt will increasingly determine competitiveness.
However, quality education must be connected to broad and tangible employment opportunities. The state cannot keep asking young people to improve their skills if productive jobs are not available. The development of industry, the digital economy, the green economy, maritime sectors, food, healthcare, biotechnology and renewable energy should be planned as sources of job creation and pathways to social mobility.
Development should not be measured solely by economic growth or the scale of investment. Another important measure is the extent to which progress expands people’s opportunities—particularly those of young people—to live decently and fulfil their potential.
Public trust must also be nurtured. An immune system that is too weak fails to confront threats, while an excessive response can attack the body’s own tissues. Democracy faces a similar dilemma: a repressive state risks deepening distrust, while a society that condones violence may damage the institutions meant to protect it.
Balance must be maintained through open dialogue, fair law enforcement, responsive public services and accountable policies. Young people must have room to criticise without fear of being silenced, while also understanding that freedom of expression comes with responsibility.
We are reminded of a saying popularly attributed to Ir Soekarno: “My struggle was easier because I was driving out the colonisers, but yours will be harder because you are fighting your own people.” Although the primary source for this attribution needs verification, its message is worth reflecting on. Today’s struggle is not only to preserve formal independence, but also to address inequality, expand opportunity and ensure that institutions serve the public interest.
The nation’s problems will not be solved by setting young people against the state, let alone by silencing criticism. The courage to address shortcomings from within is a measure of a nation’s maturity. Criticism should be treated as input for improving policy, not as a reason to turn against those who voice it.
The lesson from Europe is not how to prevent young people from taking to the streets, but how to prevent the problems driving them there from being left unaddressed. Demonstrations are often a symptom, not the disease itself. The underlying causes may include narrowing opportunities, growing difficulty meeting basic needs, or a loss of trust in institutions.
Indonesia still has an opportunity to strengthen its social immunity through quality education, decent jobs, affordable housing, strong literacy and policies that genuinely listen to public concerns.
When young people lose hope, it is not only their future that is weakened, but also the nation’s social immunity. A state that ignores the anxieties of its younger generation is gambling with something far more valuable than public order today: the trust that determines whether the future can be sustained.
Independence gave the Indonesian nation the right to determine its own destiny. But independence does not automatically guarantee that every generation will have the opportunity to live decently. Our task is to ensure that independence delivers quality education, dignified work, justice and hope for all Indonesians.
Young people must not inherit independence as a source of historical pride while losing the future as a lived reality. A great nation is not merely one that has won its independence, but one that can make every generation believe that the future is worth building together.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/social-immunity-and-indonesias-demographic-dividend-at-stake-1792482851)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5798817/imunitas-sosial-dan-pertaruhan-bonus-demografi-indonesia), translated from Indonesian