Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Small Island in Eastern Indonesia Becomes Hope for the Vatican, Here is Why

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Social Policy
Small Island in Eastern Indonesia Becomes Hope for the Vatican, Here is Why
Image: CNBC Indonesia

Amidst the shrinking interest in becoming a priest in Europe and North America, an island in Indonesia is becoming one of the world’s primary suppliers of Catholic priest candidates. That island is Flores, in East Nusa Tenggara (NTT), a nation with the world’s largest Muslim population.

According to a report by The Economist, there were approximately 4,150 seminarians in Indonesia in 2024, with the majority located in Ledalero. By comparison, Ireland has only 104 seminarians. This shift is occurring amidst global inequality. The global Catholic population has reached 1.4 billion, more than double the figure from 1970, yet the number of priests has remained relatively stagnant at around 400,000.

In the last 50 years, the number of priest candidates in Europe and North America has plummeted. Causes include the declining prestige of the profession due to child abuse scandals and the rise of secularism. Currently, about 60% of seminarians originate from Africa and Asia, where Catholicism is still growing and the priesthood is still respected.

Pope Francis, several months before his death, mentioned that interest in the priesthood in several countries was nearly extinct. He referred to ‘an island in Indonesia’ as a rare source of hope. Flores and similar Catholic enclaves are now producing enough priests to serve local dioceses while also being sent abroad, from Angola to Austria. They are described as ‘reverse missionaries’.

Their presence is also visible in the leadership of the Church. Asia now has 36 cardinals, the second highest after Europe. According to The Economist, their presence has the potential to influence internal Church debates regarding relations with other religions.

This issue is not without controversy. Last July, Pope Leo [sic] marginalised members of the ultra-conservative Society of St Pius X after the group ordained a bishop without Vatican approval. The group believes the Church has deviated from traditional doctrine, particularly through the promotion of interfaith dialogue.

Why Flores? Of the approximately 2 million residents of Flores, about 85% are Catholic, and over 10% are Muslim. The island has around 2,700 churches. Catholicism was brought to eastern Flores by the Portuguese in the 16th century and was later strengthened by the Society of the Divine Word (SVD) missionaries, the order that continues to manage Ledalero today.

Catholicism flourished in Flores, partly because missionaries generally accommodated local traditions and customs. Interreligious relations are also relatively harmonious due to intermarriage and family ties, further strengthened by the principle of Pancasila.

Economic and educational factors also play a role. The seminary is known for its quality, offering subjects such as Latin, Arabic, German, and English. Some parents send their children to the seminary not necessarily to become priests, but to seek a better education. Seminarian Edy Soge (30) noted that life in the seminary is akin to entering the middle class on an island where many residents are still poor.

Ledalero, which has existed since 1937, resembles a small university more than a strict religious institution. Discussion is encouraged, and lay female students also attend lectures on philosophy and religious education.

Students typically undergo about eight years of education. The first four years are dominated by philosophy, with theology accounting for only about one-third. This is followed by one to two years of pastoral service and two final years of theology.

Not all seminarians end up becoming priests. Soge mentioned that out of 62 seminarians in his cohort, 48 have left or resigned, partly due to the desire to live with partners. The rule of celibacy is one of the primary reasons.

One of the instructors at Ledalero, Bastian Limahekin (51), questioned how long Flores can continue to be a source of missionaries. In his view, more options for a better life are now available, such as studying mathematics or economics, and secularism will eventually arrive in Flores.

Young priests must also be prepared to face cultural changes. In Flores, priests are respected as local figures, whereas in Europe, they may face indifference or even hostility. Fransiskus Carli Kau (30), for example, has been assigned to Ireland and has begun studying the local culture through YouTube and via Indonesian priests already stationed there.

Last August, a major earthquake struck Flores, killing more than 130 people. The ceiling of the main hall at Ledalero collapsed just as Soge was about to make his perpetual vows, resulting in the ceremony being held in an emergency tent.

More from 3 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/small-island-in-eastern-indonesia-becomes-hope-for-the-vatican-here-is-why-1791035516)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/news/20261003172702-4-773073/pulau-kecil-di-timur-indonesia-jadi-harapan-vatikan-ini-alasannya), translated from Indonesian
Print