Silmy’s Challenge: Indictment Is Vague and Copied from Another Defendant’s
Soesilo Aribowo, a lawyer for Silmy Karim, a former Deputy Minister of Immigration and Corrections for the 2025–2026 period, said that the indictment brought by the Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) prosecutors against his client in a case involving alleged extortion and acceptance of gratuities was vague. He said it had simply been copied from the indictment of another defendant.
Soesilo made the remarks at a hearing to read out an objection, or exception, at the Corruption Court at the Central Jakarta District Court on Thursday (5 November).
“The description of the conduct is essentially identical, word for word, to another indictment (Case Indictment No. 85), including the total amount and the breakdown of the proceeds,” Soesilo said as he read out the objection on Thursday (5 November).
Soesilo pointed to references to “Defendant II”, “Defendant IV” and “Defendant V” before other people’s names in the indictment, despite Silmy being tried alone. Those labels were only removed through a correction at the 29 October 2026 hearing.
Soesilo also objected to the tempus delicti—the period in which the alleged offence was said to have occurred—being set from 2021, when Silmy only became Director General of Immigration on 4 January 2023. Before that, he was president director of state-owned steelmaker PT Krakatau Steel (Persero) Tbk.
The indictment also, he said, placed conduct dating from 2021 at the Ministry of Immigration and Corrections.
“Yet the ministry was only established on 21 October 2024,” Soesilo said.
According to Soesilo, the indictment also failed to describe how Silmy allegedly forced anyone to act.
“The indictment names 10 applicants who were allegedly forced, but does not explain when, how or by whom. It does not describe the deputy minister’s authority that was allegedly abused,” he said.
Soesilo further said that the figures in the indictment indicating the proceeds of the alleged crimes could not be traced. He said the alleged Rp1.2 billion benefit to Silmy was inconsistent with the receipt scheme described in the indictment.
“Meanwhile, the total of Rp168 billion does not match the Rp82 billion in benefits attributed to the parties said to have profited,” he said.
As for the second charge, Soesilo said a Rp2.56 billion payment described as “Deputy Minister of Immigration and Corrections Operational Funds” had been alleged without identifying its giver or source.
“Meanwhile, shares worth Rp31.3 billion are alleged on the basis of the phrase ‘reasonably suspected’,” he said.
Two objections were read out at Thursday’s hearing: one by Silmy’s lawyers and another by Silmy himself.
In his personal objection, Silmy said that the measures he introduced at Immigration were digitalisation reforms intended to close off opportunities for extortion and illicit levies.
Silmy said online and digital systems had cut off income opportunities for agents handling matters for foreign nationals. He said the main vulnerability had been agents acting as intermediaries between foreigners and immigration officers.
“That is where opportunities arose for manipulation, fraud and profiteering. With a digital system, that space is tightly closed, unless the parties work together to circumvent it,” Silmy said.
He outlined reforms at Immigration, including online visa and residence permit services through the Molina application, which has no field for an agent or intermediary; an increase in the number of autogates from 17 to 173; expansion of electronic passport services from 52 offices to all 126 immigration offices; and improvements to the M-Paspor application to reduce the role of brokers.
“I built a system to close off opportunities for illicit levies, but now I am sitting here as a defendant over the very levies that the system was designed to prevent,” he added.
Silmy acknowledged that misconduct by individuals could still occur in a large organisation such as Immigration, but rejected accusations that he had ordered, organised or forced such practices.
He also stressed that he had never been caught in a KPK sting operation. He said he had gone to the KPK voluntarily and co-operated with investigators.
“I went to the KPK building on my own to co-operate on 3 June 2026,” he said.
In his view, the impression that he had been caught in the act was then used as a basis for charging him with extortion and gratuity offences.
“A few days after I was detained, reports about the seizure of items from my home made it seem as if those items came from criminal activity, strengthening that impression,” he said.
In his petition, Silmy asked the judges to accept his objection in full and declare the KPK prosecutors’ indictment null and void.
He also asked the judges to order prosecutors to release him from detention and restore his rights and good name.
Silmy is being prosecuted over an alleged extortion scheme involving residence permits for foreign nationals, said to have generated Rp168.9 billion.
Prosecutors allege that he acted together with Saffar Muhammad Godam, acting Director General of Immigration for 2024–2025; Jaya Saputra, Director of Residence Permits; Bagus Bramantyo and Tessar Bayu Setyaji, sub-division heads in the Directorate of Residence Permits; Ronald Arman Abdullah, head of the Central Jakarta Immigration Office in 2024–2025 and the West Jakarta office in 2025–2026; Juniadi Sri Priambudi, head of the Limited Stay Permit (ITAS) status-change team; and Gusti Bernardiansyah, a staff member in the Residence Permit Sub-Directorate.
Silmy is also charged with accepting Rp2.5 billion in cash and shares worth Rp31 billion as gratuities.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/silmys-challenge-indictment-is-vague-and-copied-from-another-defendants-1793890311)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261105203356-12-1423895/perlawanan-silmy-dakwaan-jaksa-kabur-disalin-dari-terdakwa-lain), translated from Indonesian