Sharia Supervisory Boards Face Tighter Rules, but Accountability Safeguards Lag
From 1 January 2027, members of Sharia Supervisory Boards (DPS) at Islamic financial institutions, both banks and non-bank institutions, will be required to hold professional qualification certificates. The policy, announced by the National Sharia Council of the Indonesian Ulema Council (DSN-MUI) at the 22nd annual DPS meeting in October, complements the Financial Services Authority’s (OJK) move in early 2025 to classify DPS members at Islamic commercial banks and Islamic banking units as key parties, requiring prospective members to pass a fit-and-proper test.
These two measures are welcome, as Sharia supervisors are now being selected and developed to increasingly high standards. To make this strengthening more comprehensive, one reasonable question must be asked: if losses result from a breach of Sharia principles, to what extent should the DPS share responsibility for them?
The situation is easy to imagine. A financing product is already in operation, but its contract then needs to be amended and some of its revenue must be transferred to a fund that cannot be recognised as income (TBDSP), as set out in DSN-MUI Fatwa No. 123/DSN-MUI/XI/2018.
The explanation to Article 45(1) of OJK Regulation No. 2 of 2024 refers to a similar measure as the receipt of non-halal income. The bank therefore loses revenue. Who bears the loss?
Responsibility and liability
Two terms that are often confused need to be distinguished. Responsibility is attached to a duty. Liability — the term used by Moegni Djojodirdjo in his book Perbuatan Melawan Hukum (Unlawful Acts) — is the obligation to compensate for loss. It arises only when there is fault, loss and a causal link between them, following the framework of Article 1365 of the Indonesian Civil Code.
The DPS’s responsibilities are already well defined. Article 20(1) of OJK Regulation No. 2/2024 states that the DPS supervises the board of directors’ policies and management of the company to ensure they comply with Sharia principles, and is responsible for that supervision.
The same regulation also provides for administrative sanctions, including a ban on holding office for key parties, if Sharia non-compliance is not addressed (Article 45(4)). What is still missing is a civil-liability standard. Such a standard would benefit everyone: DPS members would gain certainty, while banks and customers would have clear guidance.
Its status is now clear
The DPS’s position is now clearly established, following a long process. In the original wording of Law No. 21 of 2008 on Sharia Banking, the DPS was classified as an affiliated party providing services to a bank, alongside public accountants and legal consultants (Article 1, point 15(b)).
The P2SK Law subsequently changed this. It defines the DPS as a party whose duties and functions are to supervise whether a company’s activities comply with Sharia principles (Article 1, point 25), and groups it with commissioners and directors, separately from service providers. OJK Regulation No. 2/2024 implements that approach by designating the DPS as a key management party, like the directors and commissioners (explanatory note to Article 8(1)).
The Constitutional Court (MK), in Decision No. 42/PUU-XXIV/2026 of 16 March 2026, also rejected a petition challenging the appointment of DPS members by a general meeting of shareholders. Its reasoning, in fact, reinforced the DPS’s position.
According to the MK, the principles of prudence and good faith apply to all company organs or parts of them, including the DPS, and also extend to the interests of customers. The DPS’s position is now on a par with that of management. It is therefore reasonable for its liability rules to be aligned as well; this is the gap that still needs to be addressed.
Many rules, but no standard
The obligations surrounding the DPS are already well organised. Directors must follow up on DPS recommendations, and commissioners must ensure that they do so (Article 29(2) and (3) of OJK Regulation No. 2/2024). Minutes of DPS meetings must be documented, including any dissenting opinions and the reasons for them (Article 32(4) and (5)). Article 56 of Law No. 21/2008 has also provided from the outset that DPS members may be subject to administrative sanctions.
What is still needed, then, is a civil standard: when is the DPS considered negligent, and when has it acted properly? Since its position is now equivalent to that of commissioners, one might ask whether judges can simply borrow the rules that apply to commissioners.
Under Article 114(3) of the Company Law, commissioners who are at fault or negligent share personal liability for losses suffered by the company. Subsection (5) provides an exemption: commissioners are not liable if they can prove that they supervised in good faith and with due care, had no personal interest, and advised the directors to prevent the loss.
The Constitutional Court also referred to subsection (5)(a) in its reasoning. In my view, however, that is not enough. First, the Court’s reasoning explained why the petition was rejected; it did not create a new rule. Civil judges may refer to it, but are not required to follow it.
Second, borrowing the commissioners’ rules to protect DPS members is readily acceptable. Borrowing them to impose personal liability for compensation is much more difficult. A burden this serious should be stated clearly in legislation; interpretation alone is not enough. Gustav Radbruch warned that legal certainty, justice and utility are often in tension.
Without a written standard, both certainty and justice are undermined: a DPS that has worked diligently can easily be blamed, while clear negligence may be difficult to pursue. The need is even more pressing after Law No. 4 of 2026 expanded the activities of Islamic commercial banks, broadening the DPS’s area of oversight and the challenges of ensuring compliance.
Who bears what?
To avoid misdirecting claims, the chain of responsibility must be set out. For customers, the point of recourse is the bank. Article 236(3)(l) of the P2SK Law requires financial-sector businesses to be responsible for losses caused by the fault or negligence of their directors, commissioners, employees or third parties working for them, supported by Article 1367 of the Civil Code.
Customers do not need to prove who was negligent within the bank. The gap is inside the company, when the bank or its shareholders seek to recover losses from the party at fault. For commissioners, the route is clear (Article 114(3) and (6) of the Company Law).
For the DPS, no standard has been set out. The principle is simple: liability should follow authority. The DPS’s authority is to supervise, advise, provide Sharia opinions and report. The management of the bank rests with the directors (Article 92(1) of the Company Law), who are also required to follow up on DPS recommendations.
Accordingly, if the DPS knows, or should know, of a breach but fails to advise or issue a warning, it should share responsibility for the consequences. If advice is given but not followed, primary liability rests with those who hold management authority.
Safeguards that need to be put in place
Using Lawrence M. Friedman’s framework, the legal structure is already in place and functioning: the OJK as regulator, and the DSN-MUI as both fatwa authority and DPS development body. What needs to be completed is the substance of the law, and its legal culture then maintained. The necessary provisions could be introduced through amendments to the Sharia Banking Law or the draft Sharia Economy Bill listed in the 2025–2029 National Legislation Programme.
Three measures would be sufficient. First, legislation should clarify that the DPS’s parity of status under the P2SK Law also applies to liability within the company, given that the Company Law currently recognises only three company organs.
Second, it should establish the DPS’s liability for company losses resulting from its fault or negligence, together with grounds for exemption modelled on Article 114(5) of the Company Law: acting in good faith and with due care, having no conflict of interest, and having provided written advice or a warning. One additional requirement specific to the DPS could be added: reporting to the OJK if a significant breach is not addressed (Article 21(3) of OJK Regulation No. 2/2024).
Third, a presumption of due care should apply specifically to Sharia opinions. An opinion based on a DSN-MUI fatwa and produced through a documented process should be presumed to have been given with due care unless the claimant proves otherwise. This protection is reasonable because the law itself provides that Sharia principles are determined by fatwas issued by the MUI (Article 26(2) of Law No. 21/2008). The idea is similar to the business judgment rule for directors, whose spirit is reflected in Article 97(5) of the Company Law.
As for legal culture, the foundations have already been laid. The required meeting minutes, together with external reviews of Sharia governance (Article 40 of OJK Regulation No. 2/2024), need only be given evidentiary weight. The OJK and DSN-MUI, long-standing partners, could set the standards, including through certification materials.
One more step
The rules governing the DPS have been tightened, and that is progress. Its duties have been defined, its suitability is tested, and its competence will soon be certified. Only one step remains: safeguards on liability commensurate with its authority. It must be emphasised that these safeguards would protect DPS members who do their jobs properly. Clear boundaries would mean they need not fear being blamed for decisions beyond their authority.
At the same time, clear negligence would not go unaddressed. With these safeguards, customers would remain protected through the bank’s responsibility, banks would know when they could seek recovery from a negligent party, and scholars and Sharia experts would not hesitate to serve as DPS members. Such certainty is what sustains trust, the greatest asset of Islamic finance. Wallahu a’lam bish-shawab (God knows best).
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/sharia-supervisory-boards-face-tighter-rules-but-accountability-safeguards-lag-1794156647)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20261108230638-14-783335/dps-sudah-diperketat-pagar-tanggung-gugatnya-belum), translated from Indonesian