Sharia Expert: Governance is Indonesia's Biggest Challenge in Global Halal Industry
Indonesia is considered to have great potential to become a major player in the global halal industry. However, the large Muslim population and domestic market are not enough to win global competition without improvements in governance and the strengthening of the halal industry ecosystem. Dr Any Setiantingrum, a Sharia economics expert at YARSI University, stated that Indonesia’s greatest challenge today is no longer creating demand, but rather building governance capable of increasing the competitiveness of the halal industry in the global market.
“If we want to be a major player in the global halal industry, we cannot rely solely on a large market. What must be strengthened is governance, transparency, institutions, and the ecosystem,” Any told Republika in Jakarta on Monday (29/06/2026).
According to Any, Indonesia needs to learn from several countries that have successfully utilised the halal industry as a national economic strategy. One such example is Thailand, which has managed to build a halal ecosystem despite not being a Muslim-majority country.
She assessed that the success of these nations is not determined solely by market size, but also by their ability to build integrated standards, research, certification, promotion, and policy support.
This view aligns with the State of the Global Islamic Economy (SGIE) Report 2025/2026. The report places Indonesia fourth in the Global Islamic Economy Indicator (GIEI), behind Malaysia, the United Arab Emirates, and Saudi Arabia. The SGIE also emphasises that the future competitiveness of the Islamic economy will be determined by the integration of halal standards, Sharia finance, trade, innovation, and supply chains, rather than just market demand.
In the halal food sector, Indonesia ranks third in the world, while Thailand holds the fourth position. In the halal cosmetics and halal pharmaceuticals sectors, Indonesia also remains in fourth place. Meanwhile, in the Sharia finance sector, Indonesia has not yet entered the global top five.
According to Any, these achievements show that while Indonesia possesses significant capital, it must still strengthen its industrial foundations to avoid falling behind other nations that are continuously improving.
She emphasised that the halal industry cannot rely solely on product certification. More importantly, an ecosystem must be built that connects business actors, Sharia financial institutions, certification bodies, academics, and the government into a single, mutually supportive system.
“If we only talk about halal certification, it is not enough. What is needed is an ecosystem that allows the halal industry to grow, remain competitive, and be trusted by the global market,” she said.
Any added that the strengthening of governance also needs to be supported by innovation and the use of technology, including artificial intelligence (AI), to increase transparency, strengthen supervision, and minimise conflicts of interest in the development of the halal industry.
Globally, the Islamic economy continues to show growth. The SGIE 2025/2026 noted that Muslim spending reached $2.60 trillion USD in 2024 and is projected to increase to $3.56 trillion USD by 2029. The value of global Sharia financial assets is also expected to increase from $5.99 trillion USD to $9.72 trillion USD during the same period. These conditions indicate that competition in the global halal industry will become increasingly intense, necessitating that Indonesia accelerates its competitiveness.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/sharia-expert-governance-is-indonesias-biggest-challenge-in-global-halal-industry-1782748414)
Originally published by Republika (https://sharia.republika.co.id/berita/theg3t490/pakar-syariah-yarsi-tata-kelola-jadi-pr-terbesar-industri-halal-indonesia), translated from Indonesian