Shadow Cabinet's Feri Amsari: Incompetent Ministers Risk Public Humiliation
Feri Amsari, the Minister of State Secretary of the Shadow Cabinet, has stated that ministers in the government of President Prabowo Subianto who lack capability will be vulnerable to harsh criticism and public humiliation when they exchange ideas with Shadow Cabinet ministers in open forums.
The Shadow Cabinet was formed by a Civil Society Coalition as a form of substantive opposition to monitor and critique the running of government objectively, using an evidence-based approach.
The initiative was proposed by a number of figures, including Feri Amsari and Ahmad Jilul QF. The Shadow Cabinet’s structure consists of 15 ministerial positions filled by academics, activists and non-partisan professionals.
Feri explained that every minister in the Red and White Cabinet will have a counterpart from the Shadow Cabinet whose task is to test and compare the government’s ideas and policies.
“If the government has a finance minister, then there will be an opposition shadow finance minister, and so on, and they will debate policy ideas openly,” said Feri, quoted from the Mahfud MD Official YouTube channel on Tuesday, 4 August 2026.
According to him, the forum will become a space for proving each minister’s abilities. Officials who do not master their field will struggle to defend their arguments before the public.
“If there is a minister who is not competent, they could be finished and humiliated in front of the public. So it is impossible, within this parliamentary-style concept, to have someone who is not an expert, because they would be embarrassed in front of the forum,” he said.
Feri stressed that a minister needs more than just intelligence. They are also required to be able to present and defend their ideas openly.
“Not only clever, they must also be able to explain their ideas. To give an example, if Mr Purbaya met Bhima Yudhistira, what would their ideas be?” he said.
List of the Shadow Cabinet’s 15 ministers
The Shadow Cabinet’s selection committee announced the 15 names filling the ministerial posts on Monday, 27 July 2026 in Jakarta.
They come from academic, research and expert circles in various fields, with the task of overseeing the relevant ministries in the Red and White Cabinet.
The full list is as follows:
- Minister of State Secretary: Feri Amsari, shadowing State Secretary Prasetyo Hadi, Presidential Chief of Staff Dudung Abdurachman, and Head of the Government Communication Body Muhammad Qodari.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/shadow-cabinets-feri-amsari-incompetent-ministers-risk-public-humiliation-1785819096)
Originally published by VIVA.co.id (https://www.viva.co.id/berita/nasional/1918788-feri-amsari-soal-kabinet-bayangan-jika-ada-menteri-tak-becus-bisa-habis-dipermalukan-di-publik), translated from Indonesian