Shadow Cabinet Minister: Public Taxes Used Recklessly
The Shadow Cabinet has highlighted various economic problems and budget policy issues under the administration of President Prabowo Subianto. Bhima Yudhistira, Shadow Cabinet Minister for Finance and Budget Governance, said state funds are frequently squandered.
He noted that these funds come from the public’s taxes, and argued there is no accountability in budget management under the Prabowo government.
“Starting with populist programmes without any studies or pilot projects, such as free nutritious meals and the Red and White Village Cooperatives,” Bhima said when contacted on Saturday, 18 July 2026.
He said Purbaya Yudhi Sadewa, as Minister of Finance, should first verify the feasibility of every programme promoted by the government. This is because, he argued, these programmes use people’s taxes and proceeds of state debt.
“If a programme is not viable, don’t be a yes-man minister,” said the Executive Director of the Center of Economic and Law Studies.
Bhima stressed that a finance minister should have the courage to freeze budget lines for programmes that are not feasible. This includes, he said, not using surplus budget funds (Saldo Anggaran Lebih) for the Himbara banks, given that fiscal problems still involve much unfinished business.
“As finance minister, one should know the correct rules of the game,” he said.
Economic problems in the Prabowo era, he argued, also tend to be cannibalistic or substitutive towards the people’s economy. Bhima cited the free nutritious meal project, which he said has displaced the role of canteens and micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs) around schools.
Another example is the Red and White Village Cooperatives programme, which he said effectively acts as a retail outlet. These government-created cooperatives, Bhima said, compete with local shops and distributors of subsidised goods.
“The economic pie is not growing; instead, state capture by elites is taking place, producing policies that contradict Article 33 of the 1945 Constitution,” Bhima said.
Another problem, he said, is the lack of creativity by the treasury in managing people’s taxes. He judged this condition risky because it triggers contraction in the economy of the lower classes.
“There has been no significant change in tax policy; there is no courage to pursue big players through progressive taxes such as a windfall profit tax and a wealth tax,” he said.
Meanwhile, he said, the state appears to be punishing ordinary people and MSMEs through adjustments to income tax (PPh). Bhima pointed to last year’s tax buoyancy of -0.12, meaning that for every one per cent of economic growth, tax revenue fell by 0.12 per cent.
“If Purbaya continues collecting taxes this way, the middle class and small entrepreneurs will scream, while the tax ratio remains low or even declines,” he said.
In addition, he highlighted a number of economic policies that need correcting. First, ending budget waste, starting with freezing the budget for the free nutritious meal (MBG) project.
The programme, a Prabowo campaign promise, is considered to have strayed from its goal of reducing stunting. Bhima said that if the programme’s aim were to improve children’s nutrition, the budget allocation should be phased.
“It only needs Rp 10 trillion per year, not Rp 268 trillion,” he said.
He added that the government should also restore regional budget efficiency measures. Bhima argued the efficiency cuts have instead triggered extreme local tax collection from the public.
Another point, he said, is that the government needs to reform public transport and energy subsidies, as people are entitled to these basic services at decent quality.
The next improvement the government must make relates to resolving the high-speed rail problem. Bhima said the government should not use state fiscal funds to settle the issue, as this adds to the burden on taxpayers’ money.
“Also cancel counter-productive regulations, implement progressive taxes, close tax leaks, ensure the public receives tax benefits from tax compliance, and refrain from interfering in monetary affairs,” Bhima said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/shadow-cabinet-minister-public-taxes-used-recklessly-1784422289)
Originally published by Tempo (Indonesian) (https://nasional.tempo.co/read/2114350/menteri-kabinet-bayangan-pajak-rakyat-dipakai-sembarangan), translated from Indonesian