Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Seeking a Middle Ground for Coal in the Sharia Financial Sector Dilemma

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Finance
Seeking a Middle Ground for Coal in the Sharia Financial Sector Dilemma
Image: Republika

The use of coal as one of Indonesia’s largest energy sources remains a double-edged sword, balancing business interests against environmental sustainability. In an Islamic perspective, coal presents one of the most pressing ethical dilemmas for the Sharia financial sector. Sharia financial institutions are placed in a difficult position, having to balance Sharia compliance with responsibility towards the environment and public welfare. Despite the availability of alternative energy sources, the continued expansion of the coal industry in several Muslim-majority countries, including Indonesia, increases exposure to climate change, ecosystem destruction, and significant economic and social costs.

Greenpeace, in a paper titled ‘Revisiting Coal in Islamic Finance: An Ethical Imperative for Divestment and Sustainability’, urges a review of coal’s permissibility within Sharia financial screening methodologies. The report compares the environmental and health impacts of coal to those of tobacco, which has seen Islamic legal rulings evolve in response to scientific evidence of its harm. It estimates that emissions from coal-fired power plants cause around 6,500 premature deaths annually in Indonesia. Furthermore, coal combustion is a major contributor to global carbon emissions, driving climate change.

Riska Rahman, Head of the Ummah for Earth Project at Greenpeace Indonesia, stated that the negative impacts of coal suggest its inclusion in positive lists for Sharia finance is potentially inconsistent with fundamental Sharia principles. She argued that the ethical foundations of Sharia finance, rooted in the objectives of Islamic law (maqasid syariah), uphold sustainability, social responsibility, and the prevention of harm. ‘We must therefore question whether coal aligns with these ethical foundations,’ she said during a public discussion in Central Jakarta. Rahman also called for an acceleration of the ethical transition of Sharia financing towards green energy instruments.

Iqbal Damanik, Climate and Energy Campaign Manager at Greenpeace Indonesia, said the Sharia finance sector has a significant opportunity to play a role in climate funding. He argued that instead of investing in a commodity that brings more harm to humanity, financing should be redirected to sustainable energy transition. ‘The Sharia financial sector has a great opportunity to pave the way for this transition and reduce dependence on coal,’ he stated, adding that the current climate crisis makes this the right moment for transformation.

Based on various official sources, Indonesia was the first country to issue a sovereign green sukuk, successfully raising 1.25 billion US dollars in 2018. This achievement demonstrates that Sharia financial instruments can mobilise capital for the energy transition and apply the principle of ‘tayyib’ (goodness), serving as a foundation for sustainable development. However, Sharia economics practitioner and academic Hayu Prabowo noted that the landscape of Sharia finance, both in Indonesia and globally, is still largely focused on halal and haram issues and has not fully moved towards broader societal benefit. He pointed out that the ‘tayyib’ principle currently lacks a standardised jurisprudential assessment, as its application requires technical expertise beyond the traditional competence of religious scholars, such as evaluating environmental and health impacts. He encouraged jurisprudential innovation and regulatory clarity, including a global ‘tayyib’ taxonomy and community-based literacy campaigns, stressing that Sharia investment must not only avoid prohibitions but also provide broad benefits for the earth and humanity.

More from 15 July 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/seeking-a-middle-ground-for-coal-in-the-sharia-financial-sector-dilemma-1784109324)
Originally published by Republika (https://sharia.republika.co.id/berita/ti7lp7490/mencari-jalan-tengah-dilema-batu-bara-dalam-sektor-keuangan-syariah), translated from Indonesian
Print