Scientific Publications and the Slogan of Impactful Research
Impactful research has become an issue attracting the attention of many parties, including policymakers. The establishment of the National Research and Innovation Agency (BRIN) was based on the desire to realise impactful research. The Ministry of Higher Education, Science, and Technology (Kemendiktisainstek) has also labelled its research programmes as ‘impactful’.
At the Australia-Indonesia Research, Science, and Innovation Collaboration Forum (KONEKSI) held on 28 April 2026, the Deputy Minister of National Development Planning (Wamen PPN)/Deputy Head of Bappenas, Febrian Alphyanto Ruddyard, also reaffirmed the call to move towards impactful research.
The call for impactful research is clearly a positive thing. Unfortunately, this call is often accompanied by positioning the orientation towards scientific publications as the antithesis of impactful research. The question is: is the orientation towards scientific publications truly the main cause of research having no impact?
Publication as a Form of Scientific Validation
In the scientific tradition, publication is not merely an administrative formality. This mechanism is the primary means of ensuring that a finding is trustworthy. Before being published, research must go through a rigorous, anonymous, and independent peer review process.
This process serves to test the validity of methods, the consistency of arguments, and the accuracy of conclusions (Balakumar & Jagadeesh, 2023). In other words, a scientific publication is the point at which a finding is tested by the scientific community, not just unilaterally declared correct by the researcher.
This tradition is not new. In the history of modern science, the practice of peer review can be traced back at least to the 17th century, when the Royal Society of London began publishing the scientific journal Philosophical Transactions in 1665 (Moxham & Fyfe, 2018). Since then, peer review in scientific publications has evolved into a crucial mechanism for maintaining the quality of research knowledge. It is a quality control mechanism that protects society from baseless claims (De La Garza & Vashi, 2022).
Learning from Cases in England and Indonesia
In 2016, the late physicist Stephen Hawking, along with a number of scientists, protested a policy change regarding seven-day health services in England. The policy was based on claims of a ‘weekend effect’, namely an increased mortality rate at weekends.
However, the claim was questioned because it was only supported by a small number of studies, some of which were published without peer review. The British Medical Journal later revealed that the claim was based on flawed data analysis. This debate shows that without a strong and validated evidence base, a policy will instead provoke public distrust.
A similar case, on a different scale, has also occurred in Indonesia. The ‘blue energy’ claim was once touted as an alternative energy solution capable of replacing various types of fuel. However, without scientific publications demonstrating a validation process from the scientific community, the claim ultimately proved unaccountable. This event serves as a reminder that without a rigorous testing mechanism, research can turn from a source of solutions into a source of misinformation.
These two examples underscore one important point: scientific publication is not a barrier to impact, but a prerequisite for credible research results. Without publication through rigorous and independent peer review, a finding is difficult to trust, let alone use as a basis for policy.
A Trigger for Impact and Global Competitiveness
Beyond being a validation mechanism, scientific publication also functions as a means of knowledge dissemination (Rao, 2021). Unlike research reports, which are generally limited to funders, scientific publications allow research results to be accessed widely, including by policymakers. In this context, scientific publication is precisely the initial gateway to impact. Research that is not published is essentially absent from the public knowledge space.
The relationship between scientific publication and impact is also reflected in various forms of recognition. Many works that later led their scientists to win the Nobel Prize—the highest award for a scientist—first went through a rigorous scientific publication process. In fact, it is not uncommon for these works to have experienced initial rejection during the peer review process before finally being published and recognised.
ScienceAlert in 2016 noted at least eight Nobel Prize-winning scientific articles that had experienced such a rejection phase. This shows that scientific publication is not just about quantity, but about a filtering process that ensures quality so it can have a significant impact.
Furthermore, within the framework of global competitiveness, scientific publications are also recognised as an important indicator. The IMD World Competitiveness Booklet (2025), for example, includes scientific publications as part of the indicators to measure a country’s competitiveness. This confirms that scientific publication is not merely an academic activity, but also a strategic component in national development.
Thus, positioning scientific publication as the enemy of impact can lead to a misguided debate. Scientific publication is not the problem. The problem lies elsewhere. The more relevant question is: why does published research still have no impact?
The Root of the Problem: Production vs. Consumption of Knowledge
The answer to this question cannot be directed solely at researchers. In the context of public policy, for instance, the impact of research always involves two parties: the researcher as the producer of knowledge and the policymaker as the user of knowledge.
From the researcher’s side, the responsibility is relatively clear. Research must be conducted according to the scientific method and tested through peer-reviewed publication. Challenges such as the proliferation of predatory journals are indeed a serious threat because they can weaken the function of publication as a quality guarantor.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/scientific-publications-and-the-slogan-of-impactful-research-1783914735)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/kolom/d-8571418/publikasi-ilmiah-dan-slogan-riset-berdampak), translated from Indonesian