Scientific explanation for why sacrificial meat is tougher than store-bought meat
Some of you may have noticed the difference between sacrificial meat slaughtered during Idul Adha and regular store-bought meat. Some claim it is tougher, has a pungent smell, and spoils faster. There is a scientific reason behind this.
In Indonesia, animal sacrifice rituals have become a public spectacle, akin to folk entertainment. This tradition involves keeping goats and cattle in temporary pens near mosques or roadside areas until shortly before slaughter. These conditions can stress the animals, affecting meat quality.
Researchers have found that stress before slaughter scientifically affects meat quality through changes in muscle metabolism, particularly glycogen reserves and post-mortem pH levels. A study titled ’ Effects of heat stress on animal physiology, metabolism, and meat quality: A review ’ found that when animals experience fear, heat, fatigue, long transport, dehydration, or rough handling, their bodies release stress hormones like adrenaline and cortisol. This accelerates muscle glycogen use. However, post-slaughter, glycogen is needed to produce lactic acid, which lowers pH normally. If this process is disrupted, meat quality changes.
Research in Meat Science journal explains acute stress before slaughter can cause Pale Soft Exudative (PSE) meat, particularly in poultry and pork. The meat becomes paler, softer, and watery due to rapid pH drop while muscle temperature is high. Conversely, chronic stress can lead toDark Firm Dry (DFD) meat, common in beef. The meat appears darker, firmer, and less durable because glycogen is depleted before slaughter, leaving higher pH levels.
Other scientific reviews indicate stress before slaughter affects meat colour, texture, tenderness, water-holding capacity, flavour, shelf life and bacterial growth. Therefore, animal welfare in the modern food industry is not just ethical but also about product quality.
Numerous studies conclude that calmer handling and minimal distress before slaughter produce meat with better sensory qualities and stability.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/scientific-explanation-for-why-sacrificial-meat-is-tougher-than-store-bought-meat-1780050269)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/lifestyle/20260525155948-33-737870/alasan-ilmiah-daging-kurban-lebih-alot-dibanding-beli-di-pasar), translated from Indonesian